fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015A7rII game plan. What are you doing

  
 
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.16 #1A7rII game plan. What are you doing
snapsy wrote:
Steve Spencer wrote
alundeb wrote
snapsy wrote
alundeb wrote
snapsy wroteNot sure if for B you mean misalignment for sensing or movement. I don't think misaligned elements can cause misfocusing in terms of movement; they could cause misfocus in terms of sensing, esp for the peripheral AF points that would be more sensitive to the misalignment. At least for decentered/tilted misalignments. If instead by misaligned you mean the focusable element within the lens is misaligned such that its position is wrong relative to where the AF drive though it put the lens. I believe most USM systems have positional sensing mechanisms that account for that and so they don't rely on absolute element position assumptions.

Lastly, if by misaligned you mean as detected by phase sensing afterwards (which would be correct and what I think you meant), then there would be no difference between A and B as both would be detected as out-of-phase by the sensing mechanism. But in both cases there may not be a final AF movement to correct that differential for a given PDAF acquisition cycle; as the experiments in this article demonstrated, the system is not entirely closed loop; sometimes the system will perform a final AF movement and either not re-sense the phase or not correct if the phase is slightly off, likely because it thinks it's already "close enough" to not warrant the performance penalty of another movement cycle.
I think we can agree that since lens specific AFMA compensates for some optical differences between lenses, it does not only compensate for the difference between the PDAF sensor plane and the image sensor plane. If AFMA is necessary with a perfectly aligned but separate PDAF sensor, it is also necessary with a PDAF sensor integrated in the image sensor.
All of the sensor-based PDAF systems I've read about use phase detect for the initial focus acquisition and then refine that focus using contrast detect. The same appears to be true on the A7rII based on this interview, which is likely faster than the A7/A7II due to the A7rII's faster sensor readout (faster CDAF sampling). This means AF tune wont be required. From the interview:

DE: What about the low-light limit when you have phase-detect pixels? It seems to me that the separate phase-detect sensors like in an SLR, they can have big pixels, but on the sensor chip, we have, I mean they're limited to the size of the actual pixels.

KM: That's a good question. So, when we use... in terms of autofocus, we are using a hybrid focus, so first we use the phase-detection focus to get close to the object. Then near the object, we start to use contrast AF to get a clear peak. Then we adjust the focus. Then in order to make very precise focus (because 42-megapixel means very very small pixels), and also the focusing point could be a very small one, therefore we phase-detection together with contrast AF, contrast focus.
This discussion derived from the context of CDAF being disabled with some types of lenses via adapter. If PDAF is not accurate, and CDAF is disabled, Canon lens owners are screwed with the A7r II. AFMA is their only hope to get accurate AF with EF lenses if Sony don't turn around and enable CDAF. Which in turn makes the AF much slower because of the slow protocol.
As I said previously, however, there would still be room for metabones or another adapter maker to add AFMA. Bo Ming who works for metabones even has some experience developing AFMA for Contax N lenses converted to Canon mount (his conversions, at least the later ones, did offer AFMA). So, there is some reasonable hope, IMO, that even if Sony does nothing, the adapter makers (and metabones in particular) could develop AFMA.
Unless the E-Mount protocol has a mechanism to notify the lens/adapter of the "final AF movement", I'm not sure how the adapter could implement a reliable AFMA.


I don't know if has the mechanism or not. I do know that the E mount protocol is a lot more open than the EF mount protocol and I know that phigment who has developed an electronic adapter for Leica M lenses for E mount said earlier that he thought the adapter ought to be able to provide AFMA. I will take his word for it as I assume he knows a fair bit about both the E mount protocol and developing adapters.
Jun 18, 2015 at 10:22 AM
TMaG82
Offline
Details
p.16 #2A7rII game plan. What are you doing
I'll be skipping this initially, but I'll keep my eyes on the reviews and thoughts and might jump in later when it's about $1,000 cheaper.

Really liking my D810 but find myself shooting with primes more than the zoom because of size. Went to Sesame Place a few days ago with the 810, 24-120 and the 85. Ended up taking approximately 25 pictures or so, just because of the size. Even in a convenient bag, I found myself not taking it out.

I would've thought about getting it if it were $2,200, then a swap of my Nikon glass for the body and 1-2 primes would've worked, but as it is right now, I'm staring a $2,000 or so price tag for the upgrade, so not feasible now. Also with my 2nd due in a few weeks, want to converse as much money as possible.
Jun 18, 2015 at 10:25 AM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.16 #3A7rII game plan. What are you doing
During this whole thread the theme is Sony will discount them and given there past movements its a great assumption. But have to say coming in cheaper than the next best thing the new Canon and its Sonys flagship camera to date than you may not see a discount on it for more than 100 dollars for maybe a year and lets NOT forget about the video folks which is a huge number of people. This is going to fly off the shelves. For a moment stop thinking about you but think about the industry as a whole. Nikon is dying a slow death, lets face it guys there dependent on Sonys sensor . Who says Sony will give them this one , not for at least a year my guess. Now they have a new Adapter Nikon to Sony coming, thats more folks now that are Nikon shooters looking squarely at Sony. Now lets talk Canon, we already can guess the AF capabiliites look darn promising and there 50 mpx is bigger and more money and may still have a DR issue. Not tested it so don't know. But here is my point Sony can now tap both Nikon and Canon user base which is freaking HUGE. Not to mention there own user base and MORE important than anything else. Sony is on the fast train in innovation . You have to ask this question of yourself if your the CEO of Sony. Why would I discount my flagship camera when I am gaining competitive edge at this price point. 100 dollars won't get more people in the door but smoking Canon and Nikon will. Seriously I would not drop this one bloody nickel for at least 1 year because no one is riding up my arch in innovation. Think about that one

So my bottom line for this folks waiting for the floor to drop out on price. I don't think your going to see much for a long time. My bet worst case scenario it will never get below 2999.00
Jun 18, 2015 at 12:28 PM
AGeoJO
Offline
Details
p.16 #4A7rII game plan. What are you doing
Guy, while you were on the other forum, there was something going on over here that you were not aware of. The decrease in prices of Sony cameras, mostly of the A7 II, was not attributed to the official Sony pricing policy. And that's what most folks were or are referring to. Just FYI, of course .
Jun 18, 2015 at 12:45 PM
jaboki
Offline
Details
p.16 #5A7rII game plan. What are you doing
GMPhotography wrote:
So my bottom line for this folks waiting for the floor to drop out on price. I don't think your going to see much for a long time. My bet worst case scenario it will never get below 2999.00


Well... until the Sony employees get their extra yearly discounts.

My problem with the Sony A7 line is the huge fluctuation of price after release. The most recent example is the A7ii. Since it's release in November(ish), I've seen it fluctuate as low as $1000 from it's $1699 MSRP pricing. That's about 60% in reduction. On average it's been selling on the FredMiranda for $1400.

The biggest reason for my hesitance to buy the A7rii, is the fact that history can repeat itself. I would be pretty frustrated if 4-5 months after release the price dropped to about $2000. I'm sure this is all speculation, but I'll personally tread cautiously. Decisions, decisions.
Jun 18, 2015 at 12:46 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.16 #6A7rII game plan. What are you doing
GMPhotography wrote:
During this whole thread the theme is Sony will discount them and given there past movements its a great assumption. But have to say coming in cheaper than the next best thing the new Canon and its Sonys flagship camera to date than you may not see a discount on it for more than 100 dollars for maybe a year and lets NOT forget about the video folks which is a huge number of people. This is going to fly off the shelves. For a moment stop thinking about you but think about the industry as a whole. Nikon is
...Show more →

Really depends on how well it sells after the initial onslaught is over. I've never seen Sony sit on price of a slow selling item. The initial price of the A7R2 puts it out of the reach of many...especially when the A7R can be had for $1,000.
Jun 18, 2015 at 01:06 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.16 #7A7rII game plan. What are you doing
AGeoJO wrote:
Guy, while you were on the other forum, there was something going on over here that you were not aware of. The decrease in prices of Sony cameras, mostly of the A7 II, was not attributed to the official Sony pricing policy. And that's what most folks were or are referring to. Just FYI, of course .


Got it , buying from employees. Very risky, you have no real receipt in your name for warranty work.

People should not count on this though, if it happens its a gift not a given. Personally If I was Sony I would fire them in seconds
Jun 18, 2015 at 01:20 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.16 #8A7rII game plan. What are you doing
jaboki wrote:
GMPhotography wroteSo my bottom line for this folks waiting for the floor to drop out on price. I don't think your going to see much for a long time. My bet worst case scenario it will never get below 2999.00
Well... until the Sony employees get their extra yearly discounts.

My problem with the Sony A7 line is the huge fluctuation of price after release. The most recent example is the A7ii. Since it's release in November(ish), I've seen it fluctuate as low as $1000 from it's $1699 MSRP pricing. That's about 60% in reduction. On average it's been selling on the FredMiranda for $1400.

The biggest reason for my hesitance to buy the A7rii, is the fact that history can repeat itself. I would be pretty frustrated if 4-5 months after release the price dropped to about $2000. I'm sure this
...Show more →

I think one thing to remember here also we where dealing in Gen 1 products and issues came up . Maybe Sony felt compelled to drop prices until they can produce Gen 2 products. I know as still shooters we do not think about video folks lets face it. But they are out there by the truck loads looking at this as a 4K cam internal that is cheap. This one scares me
Jun 18, 2015 at 01:22 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.16 #9A7rII game plan. What are you doing
chez wrote:
GMPhotography wroteDuring this whole thread the theme is Sony will discount them and given there past movements its a great assumption. But have to say coming in cheaper than the next best thing the new Canon and its Sonys flagship camera to date than you may not see a discount on it for more than 100 dollars for maybe a year and lets NOT forget about the video folks which is a huge number of people. This is going to fly off the shelves. For a moment stop thinking about you but think about the industry as a whole. Nikon is dying a slow death, lets face it guys there dependent on Sonys sensor . Who says Sony will give them this one , not for at least a year my guess. Now they have a new Adapter Nikon to Sony coming, thats more folks now that are Nikon shooters looking squarely at Sony. Now lets talk Canon, we already can guess the AF capabiliites look darn promising and there 50 mpx is bigger and more money and may still have a DR issue. Not tested it so don't know. But here is my point Sony can now tap both Nikon and Canon user base which is freaking HUGE. Not to mention there own user base and MORE important than anything else. Sony is on the fast train in innovation . You have to ask this question of yourself if your the CEO of Sony. Why would I discount my flagship camera when I am gaining competitive edge at this price point. 100 dollars won't get more people in the door but smoking Canon and Nikon will. Seriously I would not drop this one bloody nickel for at least 1 year because no one is riding up my arch in innovation. Think about that one

So my bottom line for this folks waiting for the floor to drop out on price. I don't think your going to see much for a long time. My bet worst case scenario it will never get below 2999.00
Really depends on how well it sells after the initial onslaught is over. I've never seen Sony sit on price of a slow selling item. The initial price of the A7R2 puts it out of the reach of many...especially when the A7R can be had for $1,000.


I know we are not talking cheap money here, I'm trying to figure this out in the worst way. Money for me is really not good due to my wife 3 cancers thats been going on for 5 years, so I really have to watch it too. This is a slam dunk as far as need and want. Just gotta figure it out for myself

I just hate to see folks get there hopes up that Sony is going to discount this thing and I agree it will depend on sales.
Jun 18, 2015 at 01:27 PM
AGeoJO
Offline
Details
p.16 #10A7rII game plan. What are you doing
GMPhotography wrote:
AGeoJO wroteGuy, while you were on the other forum, there was something going on over here that you were not aware of. The decrease in prices of Sony cameras, mostly of the A7 II, was not attributed to the official Sony pricing policy. And that's what most folks were or are referring to. Just FYI, of course .
Got it , buying from employees. Very risky, you have no real receipt in your name for warranty work.

People should not count on this though, if it happens its a gift not a given. Personally If I was Sony I would fire them in seconds


After what happened in the past, that is the reputation that Sony indirectly established. It remains to be seen whether there is a change this year or not. If there is, then people will react accordingly and will consider a different approach but I am afraid that it would be for the next generation of cameras. Between you and me, it seems that a lot of folks are playing the existing Sony game this time around and who could blame them? A discount of approximately 25% is hard to resist and that only in just a few short months.
Jun 18, 2015 at 01:32 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.16 #11A7rII game plan. What are you doing
I get it no question. I wish them luck on it. I was thinking during rumor time maybe 2799. But I did not count on the extra stuff either. Hope this trickles down to lessor models
Jun 18, 2015 at 01:38 PM
ecarlino
Offline
Details
p.16 #12A7rII game plan. What are you doing
Guy, i'm with you and smiling at those who think there's going to be any discounting similar to what we've seen thus far in the a7-series.

The orig a7 and a7r were groundbreaking and yet lacked enough that they were upgraded relatively quickly. I've not shot the a7s, nor do i focus on video, so i'm not sure how its user base feels (i.e. does it require a v2 or is it 'good enough' at this point - e.g. would IBIS be of use?)

I feel with the a72 and a7r2, the line-up is mature and updates will not be as frequent. Price should remain firmer. Currency fluctuations may provide room for the occasional rebate.

As far as Sony employees, I don't see them being a big enough factor to even discuss, but they certainly offer an opportunity for those who are highly price sensitive and have a tolerance for risk.

The biggest factor in the price of the a7r2, IMO, would be any future release of the so-called a9. where would its price fit in? Admittedly, $3200 is getting up there and while the Nikon D4 is WAY up there, I'm not sure what features could be included in an a9 that could justify going that far above the a7r2, which may mean that the a7r2 would need to drop in price to make room - but in that case, it would make me think that the a9 is further off than originally anticipated, especially if the a7r2 does a brisk volume.

I think the a9 can wait at least a year now. I also think the lens lineup needs to grow A LOT more before Sony should release an a9 priced near $4k (if it is going to sit above the a7r2, you'd have to figure the price is going to be up there). I'd think that people buying into a $4k+ camera are going to want a fuller native lens system.

The 2 original cameras attracted a lot of alt_lens guys - but if the AF works nearly as good as described with Canon lenses, i think the flood gates may open for Sony and sales will be quite strong for a long time. And frankly, I'd think that those buyers will be willing to pay more to give new life to their lens systems than they alt-lens guys were.

just my guesses - but part of me was going to wait a bit to see if they release the a9 this Fall/Winter - but I've got my pre-order in on the a7r2 b/c i don't see an a9 coming until the end of 2016 now (i have no reason to think this, other than a hunch - given the price and feature set of the a7r2 and given how little Canikon are doing to compete and given the current lens lineup).
Jun 18, 2015 at 01:42 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.16 #13A7rII game plan. What are you doing
If there is a A9 it just got put out for some time. What could they possibly do to make it better than this feature wise but really only making it more durable and weather proofed. I think we are looking at top of the line for awhile until they at least get there next 8 lenses out. Than they can sell the full system idea. I know people will hate me but I see no point in making a A body now. If there is anything this is all lacking is long and fast which are sports guys and wildlife. Frankly Canon has that market so tied up , those folks won't break away.
I don't have the answers but I really have some doubts about the A models. That market keeps tanking and Sony itself with mirrorless is not helping the cause. Interesting times.

I have been a Pro for 40 years and seen this industry change quite a lot but I do see a revolutionary change upon us now and that is calling for smaller, lighter full featured cameras without mirrors. I almost feel sorry for Nikon and Canon. They truly in my mind have 4 wheels stuck in the mud and only one is spinning.
Jun 18, 2015 at 01:56 PM
jaboki
Offline
Details
p.16 #14A7rII game plan. What are you doing
AGeoJO wrote:
GMPhotography wrote
AGeoJO wroteGuy, while you were on the other forum, there was something going on over here that you were not aware of. The decrease in prices of Sony cameras, mostly of the A7 II, was not attributed to the official Sony pricing policy. And that's what most folks were or are referring to. Just FYI, of course .
Got it , buying from employees. Very risky, you have no real receipt in your name for warranty work.

People should not count on this though, if it happens its a gift not a given. Personally If I was Sony I would fire them in seconds
After what happened in the past, that is the reputation that Sony indirectly established. It remains to be seen whether there is a change this year or not. If there is, then people will react accordingly and will consider a different approach but I am afraid that it would be for the next generation of cameras. Between you and me, it seems that a lot of folks are playing the existing Sony game this time around and who could blame them? A discount of approximately 25% is hard to resist and that only in just a few short months.


Took the words out of my mouth. As much as I hate to say it, I wish they limited the employee purchasing to 1 unit. It'll make my decision easier.

Unlimited units means... FredMiranda will have them way cheaper in 4-5 short months... as my A7ii is perfectly fine.
Jun 18, 2015 at 01:59 PM
ecarlino
Offline
Details
p.16 #15A7rII game plan. What are you doing
GMPhotography wrote:
I have been a Pro for 40 years and seen this industry change quite a lot but I do see a revolutionary change upon us now and that is calling for smaller, lighter full featured cameras without mirrors. I almost feel sorry for Nikon and Canon. They truly in my mind have 4 wheels stuck in the mud and only one is spinning.


you could probably imagine the hate that i received on Nikonians 2yrs ago when i started suggesting that Nikon should build a D800 without the mirror and with an EVF that could use all of the F-mount lenses. most people didn't want to hear it b/c their impression of EVF at the time was so low. I countered that, like all tech, it too will improve.

others stated that the F-mount AF wouldn't work if there wasn't a separate focus module - but i always replied, what's the difference if the PD was on the sensor or in a separate module - well Sony just proved that is possible.

i think in Nikon's case, it will be telling how much Sony is willing to share (and when) - b/c if Nikon could get their hands on the sensor from the a7r2, well perhaps there could be a path forward for the F-mount.
Jun 18, 2015 at 02:04 PM
AGeoJO
Offline
Details
p.16 #16A7rII game plan. What are you doing
jaboki wrote:
AGeoJO wrote
GMPhotography wrote
AGeoJO wroteGuy, while you were on the other forum, there was something going on over here that you were not aware of. The decrease in prices of Sony cameras, mostly of the A7 II, was not attributed to the official Sony pricing policy. And that's what most folks were or are referring to. Just FYI, of course .
Got it , buying from employees. Very risky, you have no real receipt in your name for warranty work.

People should not count on this though, if it happens its a gift not a given. Personally If I was Sony I would fire them in seconds
After what happened in the past, that is the reputation that Sony indirectly established. It remains to be seen whether there is a change this year or not. If there is, then people will react accordingly and will consider a different approach but I am afraid that it would be for the next generation of cameras. Between you and me, it seems that a lot of folks are playing the existing Sony game this time around and who could blame them? A discount of approximately 25% is hard to resist and that only in just a few short months.
Took the words out of my mouth. As much as I hate to say it, I wish they limited the employee purchasing to 1 unit. It'll make my decision easier.

Unlimited units means... FredMiranda will have them way cheaper in 4-5 short months... as my A7ii is perfectly fine.



Not only on FM but I have seen quite a few advertise on local CLs. Maybe those are the same folks but maybe not. Who knows, I cannot see well in muddy water like that .

My A7 II works fine, too but I paid the full price for it when it first became available.... Ouch .
Jun 18, 2015 at 02:08 PM
MedicineMan404
Offline
Details
p.16 #17A7rII game plan. What are you doing
Snapsy '....worked with Metabones on a firmware update to the IV EF adapter during the A7rII development to improve AF performanc' Thanks! That is critical/wonderful info.

This thread has turned into a big learning experience/curve for me.
Jun 18, 2015 at 02:18 PM
snapsy
Offline
Details
p.16 #18A7rII game plan. What are you doing
GMPhotography wrote:
AGeoJO wroteGuy, while you were on the other forum, there was something going on over here that you were not aware of. The decrease in prices of Sony cameras, mostly of the A7 II, was not attributed to the official Sony pricing policy. And that's what most folks were or are referring to. Just FYI, of course .
Got it , buying from employees. Very risky, you have no real receipt in your name for warranty work.

Sony warranties are transferable, whereas to Canon and Nikon's are not. Here are the warranty agreements:

Sony USA Warranty Agreement
Canon USA Warranty Agreeement
Nikon USA Warranty Agreement
Jun 18, 2015 at 02:20 PM
MedicineMan404
Offline
Details
p.16 #19A7rII game plan. What are you doing
A lot of the sports/wildlife guys will break away from Canon/Nikon in my opinion. The reason is age, weight, 'wieldability'...though very active (backpacked 21 miles in the heat this past weekend, 2 weeks ago cycle-camped the 80 mile Greenbriar River Trail, etc) I refuse to carry the weight very far anymore. In January I went for these guys:
https://www.flickr.com/photos/medicineman4040/15871692503/in/album-72157647823023723/
I carried a 5Diii + 300 2.8 and a 7Dii + 400DOii for a total of 4 miles and I swear at times I was literally up to mid thigh in snow (balmy too at 2F); once done I swore I'd never do that again and bought a complete m4/3s system (currently waiting on the Oly 300 F4 to be released). Why did I do this? Because Sony will not give me any native focal length in an e-mount (remember this is all about saving weight) over 300mm UNTIL now. The A7Rii is the glimmer of hope many of us older photographers have dreamed of......IF it can AF our Canon glass.
I've said before I have no illusion that the combo will be anything like the 7Dii but it is at least a huge step in the right direction.
Yes you're thinking the A7Rii + Metabones + 400DOii is still going to be weighty but I could have gotten same owl shots with a 400 5.6 (on that day), weight/wieldability are indeed possible.
Jun 18, 2015 at 02:32 PM
AGeoJO
Offline
Details
p.16 #20A7rII game plan. What are you doing
MedicineMan404 wrote:
A lot of the sports/wildlife guys will break away from Canon/Nikon in my opinion.



That remains to be seen. We are hoping that the AF would work as well as on a native Canon body but we don't know that yet. In addition, fast focusing is one thing but being able to follow focus is a completely different beast. Plus, there is the lag issue.... Yes, the mirrorless technology has developed rapidly but frankly, I seriously doubt that the A7r II would be THE camera that would open up the flood gates. Not for sport or wildlife shooters, at least. Maybe the next iteration or the future A9 would. Who knows .
Jun 18, 2015 at 02:43 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister