p.2 #1Images: 5Ds RAWs with +5.00 Exposure: Noise and DR
atodzia wrote:
I wonder if the sharpness of the 5DS will be similar to the sharpness of the 7D Mark II which has the same pixel size and an AA filter. I have a 7D2 and the files it produces are sharper then my 5D3. The newest 5DS raw images that are being discussed are really quite sharp, even without any sharpening done to them.
For several reasons, the system resolution should be higher overall. (With a given lp/mm lens, there are more mm's across the frame to hold lp's with the larger sensor — which is not to denigrate the fine performance of the 7DII.)
p.2 #5Images: 5Ds RAWs with +5.00 Exposure: Noise and DR
Seems to be business as usual as far as DR range goes. You certainly wouldn't push shadows more than 2 stops on this camera. It's probably better than the 5D III and will blow it away for detail at least below ISO 3200.
p.2 #6Images: 5Ds RAWs with +5.00 Exposure: Noise and DR
Pixel Perfect wrote:
Seems to be business as usual as far as DR range goes. You certainly wouldn't push shadows more than 2 stops on this camera. It's probably better than the 5D III and will blow it away for detail at least below ISO 3200.
You must be seeing something different from what I'm seeing. The two-stop push here produces no noise that would be visible at sub-100% magnification sizes. The three-stop push of nearly pure black (luminosity level: 0) shows a little bit of noise, but I did not add any NR to this and I wouldn't hesitate one bit to do that push in a large fine art print. By adding NR the 4-stop push could restore detail (quite a lot of detail) to shadow areas and prevent them from being blocked. The radical 5-stop push creates some color shifts and noise that would be more difficult to deal with. (I'll agree that it would be a very poor choice to underexpose an entire frame by 5 stops and try to bring it back to what passes for a normal exposure in post. ;-)
Some caveats:
1. This is a downloaded test RAW that I did not create myself, so I cannot know the entire background of the file. I'll be able to work with my own files soon, though.
2. It is my guess that the Sony sensor still will have somewhat more useful DR at low ISOs. That doesn't mean much to me, but some will feel otherwise. To the extent that this is critical to them, they may want to get on with life and buy that Sony or Nikon camera — both companies produce fine equipment, too.
3. The quality of the noise that appears at, say, five stops pushed in post, look pretty good.
The file is what it is, and I suppose we'll all come to different conclusions about what it means to our own photography. I'm looking forward to getting my hands on my copy of the 5Ds R before long and seeing how closely my real world results conform to what I think the test files are telling me.
p.2 #8Images: 5Ds RAWs with +5.00 Exposure: Noise and DR
It has less to due with the noise at +3 in those shots, but the lack of detail captured within the dark areas. When I recover shadows like that on a Sony sensor, I'd expect much more information than what I'm seeing here.
But, like you said, it's a tiny spot in the image, so it doesn't really help us here.
I'd rather see something done like this:
and then be able to compare the noise in recovery:
I came into this thread with an open mind, but from what was shown I am, currently, unimpressed. In fact most of the sample shots I'm seeing look mushy and undetailed once viewed full size.
p.2 #9Images: 5Ds RAWs with +5.00 Exposure: Noise and DR
Braineack wrote:
I came into this thread with an open mind, but from what was shown I am, currently, unimpressed. In fact most of the sample shots I'm seeing look mushy and undetailed once viewed full size.
This also may have to do with the lens that's used. The pictures I took myself with the 11-24 and 100L were far from mushy. But then again maybe we have different standards.
p.2 #10Images: 5Ds RAWs with +5.00 Exposure: Noise and DR
Braineack wrote:
I came into this thread with an open mind, but from what was shown I am, currently, unimpressed. In fact most of the sample shots I'm seeing look mushy and undetailed once viewed full size.
Yikes! That photo is....umm....well....uh.....yes, you're absolutely right, the 5DS may not be a good fit for you.
p.2 #11Images: 5Ds RAWs with +5.00 Exposure: Noise and DR
IMO, the zoomed-in shots of the baby could be soft - or mushy, as you put it, due to not being properly focused. Also, when the sun is behind the subject that you're shooting, the light acts as a filter that comes between the lens and the subject, which creates a soft image.
I'm not supporting this camera one way or the other. This has just been my personal experience. When the camera comes out, I will grab a CF card and head to the camera store and take some test shots that I can observe on my monitor to determine that value this camera brings to my way of shooting.
p.2 #12Images: 5Ds RAWs with +5.00 Exposure: Noise and DR
Braineack wrote:
I came into this thread with an open mind, but from what was shown I am, currently, unimpressed. In fact most of the sample shots I'm seeing look mushy and undetailed once viewed full size.
p.2 #13Images: 5Ds RAWs with +5.00 Exposure: Noise and DR
Braineack wrote:
I am, currently, unimpressed. In fact most of the sample shots I'm seeing look mushy and undetailed once viewed full size.
That is a common experience given a dramatic increase in sensor resolution because ...
... smaller pixels viewed at 100% magnify technique and optical issues more than larger pixels.
sqrt (50.6 / 22.1) = 151 % more linear resolution
That means that when a 5D3 and 5DS image are viewed at 100%, the 5DS pixel area is enlarged 50% more, and lens blur, DoF blur, mis-focus blur, lens aberrations, and contrast loss are magnified 50% more in the 5DS view.
5DS is a much more dramatic increase over 5D3 and 1D-X than those two are over a 16 MPx or 12 MPx camera.
p.2 #14Images: 5Ds RAWs with +5.00 Exposure: Noise and DR
Monito wrote: Braineack wroteI am, currently, unimpressed. In fact most of the sample shots I'm seeing look mushy and undetailed once viewed full size.That is a common experience given a dramatic increase in sensor resolution because ...
... smaller pixels viewed at 100% magnify technique and optical issues more than larger pixels...
Or, as I like to say, looking at the photo closer doesn't make your lenses get sharper! Those who think that their higher MP photos should look sharper at 100% magnification might read the second of my links above for an explanation of why that won't be the case and why that isn't a bad thing. ;-)
p.2 #15Images: 5Ds RAWs with +5.00 Exposure: Noise and DR
Deezie wrote:
IMO, the zoomed-in shots of the baby could be soft - or mushy, as you put it, due to not being properly focused. Also, when the sun is behind the subject that you're shooting, the light acts as a filter that comes between the lens and the subject, which creates a soft image.
I'm not supporting this camera one way or the other. This has just been my personal experience. When the camera comes out, I will grab a CF card and head to the camera store and take some test shots that I can observe on my monitor to determine that value this camera brings to my way of shooting. ...Show more →
I know why MY shot is soft (misfocused and shooting into sun), but these real example shots from the 5Dr aren't impressive to me (almost like NR was applied)--the first Canon released look amazing (there was one studio shot of a girl in an elaborate dress that was great).
But if we are talking recovery of the RAW file, then I'd like to test a test more like that where it was underexposed by 3 stops intentionally, then recovered. That's all im saying, taking a tiny little portion of the frame isn't showing us much. You can see in my shot that the +3EV recovery didn't add much noise--nothing more than shooting at 800ISO or so.
p.2 #16Images: 5Ds RAWs with +5.00 Exposure: Noise and DR
Braineack wrote: Deezie wroteIMO, the zoomed-in shots of the baby could be soft - or mushy, as you put it, due to not being properly focused. Also, when the sun is behind the subject that you're shooting, the light acts as a filter that comes between the lens and the subject, which creates a soft image.
I'm not supporting this camera one way or the other. This has just been my personal experience. When the camera comes out, I will grab a CF card and head to the camera store and take some test shots that I can observe on my monitor to determine that value this camera brings to my way of shooting.I know why MY shot is soft (misfocused and shooting into sun), but these real example shots from the 5Dr aren't impressive to me (almost like NR was applied)--the first Canon released look amazing (there was one studio shot of a girl in an elaborate dress that was great).
But if we are talking recovery of the RAW file, then I'd like to test a test more like that where it was underexposed by 3 stops intentionally, then recovered. That's all im saying, taking a tiny little portion of the frame isn't showing us much. You can see in my shot that the +3EV recovery didn't add much noise--nothing more than shooting at 800ISO or so.
My major point had to do with your unsupported notion that high MP Canon files will be soft. There is nothing about the camera or the files that would lead us to think that, and your "test" examples' softness almost certainly was caused by something else. (Photographers have long looked at 100% crops of new, higher photo site density cameras and mistakenly thought that they produced softer images. They failed to understand the different effect of comparing 100% magnification crops from sources with different photo site densities.)
I'm also looking forward to making photographs with the 5Ds R and producing very large prints with them. The point of the small examples shared here was to take a close look (100% magnification) at one specific thing, namely the effect of pushing exposure by varying numbers of stops on noise and related things.
p.2 #17Images: 5Ds RAWs with +5.00 Exposure: Noise and DR
I never really suggested they would be, I said: ...most of the sample shots I'm seeing look mushy and undetailed once viewed full size.
I've seen plenty of 24 and 36MP images from both FF and Crop sensors at 100% to expect to see a certain level of detail/clarity/contrast/sharpness in images--call it a benchmark if you will.
I opened the link, looked at the images and came away disappointed. I saw soft, undetailed, images shot with decent enough glass and formed an opinion and expressed it.
p.2 #18Images: 5Ds RAWs with +5.00 Exposure: Noise and DR
Braineack wrote:
I never really suggested they would be, I said: ...most of the sample shots I'm seeing look mushy and undetailed once viewed full size.
I don't have the same experience. They are full of detail and are as crisp as I would expect given parameters like lenses and diffraction effects.
Braineack wrote:
I've seen plenty of 24 and 36MP images from both FF and Crop sensors at 100% to expect to see a certain level of detail/clarity/contrast/sharpness in images--call it a benchmark if you will.
Not a benchmark for reasons Dan and I have explained above.
Broken link. (403 Forbidden) Assuming it works, it's a JPEG. You know, one of those images with processing already baked in and unrecoverable. You do know that, right?
p.2 #19Images: 5Ds RAWs with +5.00 Exposure: Noise and DR
I don't have the same experience. They are full of detail and are as crisp as I would expect given parameters like lenses and diffraction effects.
I just don't tend to feel that way when I view full size samples of images--these just left me unimpressed. that's that's just my opinion of those specific set of samples from that photographer--nothing more, nothing less.
I still would like to see recovery of the RAW file #46. I think it makes a better candidate to recover given the large underexposed areas that could be recovered and reviewed--a shot that most people probably end up making and wanting to recover when using evaluative metering shooting subjects against a bright background. In this shot the subjects and underexposed, so it would be a very similar recover like the example I posted from my own images. I think this would be a better test of the DR and noise from recovery instead of a tiny portion of the full image.
p.2 #20Images: 5Ds RAWs with +5.00 Exposure: Noise and DR
Braineack wrote: Earlier quoteI don't have the same experience. They are full of detail and are as crisp as I would expect given parameters like lenses and diffraction effects.I just don't tend to feel that way when I view full size samples of images--these just left me unimpressed. that's that's just my opinion of those specific set of samples from that photographer--nothing more, nothing less.
I still would like to see recovery of the RAW file #46. I think it makes a better candidate to recover given the large underexposed areas that could be recovered and reviewed--a shot that most people probably end up making and wanting to recover when using evaluative metering shooting subjects against a bright background. In this shot the subjects and underexposed, so it would be a very similar recover like the example I posted from my own images. I think this would be a better test of the DR and noise from recovery instead of a tiny portion of the full image....Show more →
It is already explained by DPREVIEW test http://tinyurl.com/qh7urzy and their DR sample: http://tinyurl.com/qdqba9v canon cam can't handle the WDR scenes, you need to use the filters to lower the DR in these cases.