p.3 #35Ds production samples posted (RAWs and JPEGs)
ronno wrote:
[description of Sequoia tree forest with sunlit patches and shadows]
And I am shooting people so bracketing is not an option.
Then you have something to learn about photographing people (not "shooting" people) with bracketing.
You put the person / people in an area of even illumination, and only for the exposure that is going to use the tones from that level of lighting. So, not in the deep shadows or the bright sun, but the middle exposure. You would not want to put them into a blotchy mix of sun and shadow anyway. Then while blending you can mix that area of that exposure in so that it fills that area in the final images. Yes, it does need partially manual blending, but it does not require them to be in all three exposures. If necessary you can add a little diffuse flash light to brighten up the people a stop.
Or you ask them to hold still and you use the rapid shot AEB capability of the 5DS in continuous mode for the three shots in very little time.
Here is a photograph I made the latter way where I asked the model (not a professional) to hold very still while I made the three exposures, with a 5D 20D. They were made at 42, 44, and 47 seconds after the minute, so you can see it is not hard. The 5DS makes it possible to do this much faster, in a fraction of a second more than the actual exposures consume.
p.3 #45Ds production samples posted (RAWs and JPEGs)
ronno wrote:
And about "too many pixels": in all my 20 or so years shooting professionally, I'm pretty sure that I have never had a client ask for more detail in a finished image.
Ah, yes. But, ...
They may ask for more detail during the contract negotiations, if they know that you can provide it by a high pixel count camera like the 5DS, especially if you let them know as part of your marketing and sales that you can provide such a service.
So, ... only too many pixels for a pro if one doesn't see it as a business opportunity or is determined to do things the way they always have.
p.3 #85Ds production samples posted (RAWs and JPEGs)
Monito wrote: ronno wrote[description of Sequoia tree forest with sunlit patches and shadows]
And I am shooting people so bracketing is not an option.Then you have something to learn about photographing people (not "shooting" people) with bracketing.
I hope even with the years of experience that you mention that you might learn something from this that you find useful.
Monito, thanks for the lesson.
I guess if your subject is sitting statue-like and braced against a table then bracketing is ok. Have you ever tried to get a natural expression on someone's face while bracketing?
Furthermore I now have the D750 which negates the need for trying to bracket with people!
And I look forward to a Canon which can do the same. (I have plenty Canon equipment as well...)
p.3 #115Ds production samples posted (RAWs and JPEGs)
ronno wrote:
Monita, just found this on your site. Is this another bracketing shot?
No. That is a different technique entirely (in camera multiple exposure with a 20D that does not have multiple exposure capability).
You have to trawl my site to make some kind of point? And post a photograph I made to make your point? What is your point you are trying to make by posting my photograph? Do you have a point other than to "L O L"? Go ahead. Laugh.
And if you are so cool, you would have the courtesy and take the care to spell my name correctly.
p.3 #125Ds production samples posted (RAWs and JPEGs)
alundeb wrote:
Not only does the number of pixels have little bearing on the amount of noise when the images are presented at the same resolution, but regarding low ISO DR, the effect is the opposite. It is well established knowledge that high resolution helps the low ISO DR. It can easily be examplified with the Sony A7r vs A7s. The older high resolution A7r outperforms the newer "Noise king" low resolution A7s with a full stop for DR at ISO 100. It is also the same effect that makes the 5Ds appear slightly better than the 6D.
The theory behind is a bit complicated, but in short the dynamic range at low ISO for a given sensor technology is constant per pixel, and does not vary with pixel size. This has to do with where in the signal chain the DR limiting noise origins. When a higher resolution image is downsampled to a lower resolution, the noise level per pixel is reduced and the dynamic range per pixel increased. When compared to an image from another sensor with the same technology but lower pixel count, the higher pixel count sensor get the highest DR. ...Show more →
The pixel count does, indeed, have an effect on the quantity of noise in a photo, but is not significant except for the portions of the photo made with very little light, to include deep shadows at base ISO and progressively more of the photo as the photographer uses higher and higher ISO settings. The mathematics/physics of it is explained in detail here and well demonstrated here.
p.3 #165Ds production samples posted (RAWs and JPEGs)
Monito, I was not making fun of the photo per se; I was making a bad joke about bracketing with people in the shot.
Anyway if someone is going to be offering free advice for professionals as you have, it is fair game to qualify their statements by viewing what they have accomplished with the camera. Thus I visited your site.
I think the more we know about one another's photography (as opposed to simply reading words in forums), the easier it is to put forum comments into perspective.
IMO.
p.3 #175Ds production samples posted (RAWs and JPEGs)
ronno wrote:
Monito, I was not making fun of the photo per so; I was making a bad joke about bracketing with people in the shot. Anyway if someone is going to be offering free advice for professionals as you have, it is fair game to qualify their statements by viewing what they have accomplished with the camera. Thus I visited your site. I think the more we know about one another's photography (as opposed to simply reading words in forums), the easier it is to put forum comments into perspective. IMO.
I don't mind you or FM members visiting my site. I don't mind you or FM members viewing my photographs.
But you could not and would not address my points. Instead of interacting, you posted one of my photographs as an attack on my technique and laughed in my face; a photograph and a technique that have nothing to do with the topic or content of this thread. When called on your attempt to shut me down, you retreat to the claim it was a joke. I refer you to Dan's post above.
The logical endpoint of the "post the other guy's photos" tactic is that people who share the photographs would be attacked and people who don't share or post their websites would get a free pass. Which is a completely nonsensical way to run things.
Just because somebody is a professional does not make them immune to being engaged in a debate or discussion with somebody else and, yes, getting free advice (you said something was impossible and I posted an example with explanation). One can't drop names, draw up robes, say "I'm a professional and you are not so your words are worthless" and expect to be respected.
When someone makes points, deal with the points. It does not matter what their experience or skills are.
The tactic of "qualifying their statements" by posting their photographs (without permission and without even asking) is as bogus and meaningless as saying that a movie reviewer can't review movies unless they are an Academy Award winning director / producer. It's like saying the only qualified sports writers / commentators would be major league MVPs or championship winning coaches.
It's akin to saying the only people qualified to comment on cameras are camera engineers. Oh, wait, you aren't a DSLR camera engineer. Oops.
p.3 #185Ds production samples posted (RAWs and JPEGs)
I did reply stating that bracketing is not practical for 99.9 percent of people pictures. Nor is it required with better sensors. And thats the point really.
It sounds like you are saying that taking good photos has nothing to do with spouting facts and figures in a forum. Which is true.
p.3 #195Ds production samples posted (RAWs and JPEGs)
Ronno all of the shots you posted look like they were lit.
Lighting the shot completely defeats the point/need for these "lift the shadow games", especially when the background is a near no-op like those.
They don't look like good images to prove your point at all.. you have deep shadows and/or purposely/artistically blown highlights in several of them. Good photos but they sure don't seem to point to the issue people are fretting about.
The hypothetical "super important executives posing in the shade of sequoias under noon sun with an expansive background" is a more appropriate example but it's still one that can be solved with setup.. set up lights ahead of time with an assistant or other bystander.. get everything perfect and then nail the shot right away when the busy execs are ready. No different than any other portrait environment. Since the shot has to be done under harsh noon light it's not changing much for hours so you've got time to set it up.
The only time I seem to get the point of the "lift the shadow" folks is when you seem to want a high-key photo with no blown highlights and you shot in harsh light with no attempt to control lighting. The London bridge example is actually a fine example IMO. The folks who want the Sony DR want that picture to have no deep shadows under the boat as far as I can tell. I prefer the shadows to remain shadows so the Canon image is 100% fine to me. But if you want all the shadows lifted to 18% gray than clearly the Sony sensors are the way to go. But if I was the customer no way I'm buying the one that has all the shadows obliterated by lifting them to 18% gray. All of your photos look better because they have wide tonal range, if the shadows were all lifted artificially they would look worse.
p.3 #205Ds production samples posted (RAWs and JPEGs)
bboule wrote:
Ronno all of the shots you posted look like they were lit.
Lighting the shot completely defeats the point/need for these "lift the shadow games", especially when the background is a near no-op like those.
They don't look like good images to prove your point at all.. you have deep shadows and/or purposely/artistically blown highlights in several of them. Good photos but they sure don't seem to point to the issue people are fretting about.
The hypothetical "super important executives posing in the shade of sequoias under noon sun with an expansive background" is a more appropriate example but it's still one that can be solved with setup.. set up lights ahead of time with an assistant or other bystander.. get everything perfect and then nail the shot right away when the busy execs are ready. No different than any other portrait environment. Since the shot has to be done under harsh noon light it's not changing much for hours so you've got time to set it up.
The only time I seem to get the point of the "lift the shadow" folks is when you seem to want a high-key photo with no blown highlights and you shot in harsh light with no attempt to control lighting. The London bridge example is actually a fine example IMO. The folks who want the Sony DR want that picture to have no deep shadows under the boat as far as I can tell. I prefer the shadows to remain shadows so the Canon image is 100% fine to me. But if you want all the shadows lifted to 18% gray than clearly the Sony sensors are the way to go. But if I was the customer no way I'm buying the one that has all the shadows obliterated by lifting them to 18% gray. All of your photos look better because they have wide tonal range, if the shadows were all lifted artificially they would look worse....Show more →
One of the first (darkroom) rules I learned is that every photo needs to have a true black. Break this rule only very carefully as you run the risk of producing rather lousy looking photographs.