jcolwell wrote:
takowasa, I really think you're on the wrong track.
Why, in your opinion, then, does a photo of a scene with the same camera, at 1/100 ISO 100 have less noise than a photo at 1/1600 ISO 1600 (or 1/1600 ISO 100 pushed 4 stops), if it is for a reason other than the fact that 16x as much light made up the photo with an exposure time of 1/100?
takowasa wrote: jcolwell wrotetakowasa, I really think you're on the wrong track.Why, in your opinion, then, does a photo of a scene with the same camera, at 1/100 ISO 100 have less noise than a photo at 1/1600 ISO 1600 (or 1/1600 ISO 100 pushed 4 stops), if it is for a reason other than the fact that 16x as much light made up the photo with an exposure time of 1/100?
Same pixel density, less light, more amplification = more noise ... I get that.
That's not the same as:
Same pixel density, same light, same amplification @ crop
Same pixel density, same light, same amplification @ FF
NOTE: the same light is already compensated for @ more light in, spread over larger area = same exposure per pixel (previously concurred)
takowasa wrote:
1) Reduce the electronic noise
2) Increase the full well saturation of the pixel
3) Increase the quantum efficiency of the sensor
How does #1 change if the pixels remain the same size?
How does #2 change if the pixels remain the same size?
What comparison would you suggest already exists that is a fair representation of same densities @ FF vs. 1.6x that clearly illustrates such a difference in noise? (Honest question)
jcolwell wrote:
takowasa, I really think you're on the wrong track.
takowasa wrote:
Why, in your opinion, then, does a photo of a scene with the same camera, at 1/100 ISO 100 have less noise than a photo at 1/1600 ISO 1600 (or 1/1600 ISO 100 pushed 4 stops), if it is for a reason other than the fact that 16x as much light made up the photo with an exposure time of 1/100?
RustyBug wrote:
Same pixel density, less light, more amplification = more noise ... I get that.
So what, in your opinion, was the cause of the greater noise in the 1/1600 photo?
That's not the same as:
Same pixel density, same light, same amplification @ crop
Same pixel density, same light, same amplification @ FF
Feel free to shoot the 1/100 and 1/1600 photos both at ISO 100. Just display both at the same size and brightness. Why does the 1/1600 photo have more noise?
NOTE: the same light is already compensated for @ more light in, spread over larger area = same exposure per pixel (previously concurred)
For the moment, I wish to limit the discussion to 1/100 ISO 100 and 1/1600 ISO 1600 (or 1/100 ISO 100 pushed four stops) on the with the same camera. Why is the 1/1600 photo more noisy if not for the reason that it was made with 1/16 as much light?
takowasa wrote:
1) Reduce the electronic noise
2) Increase the full well saturation of the pixel
3) Increase the quantum efficiency of the sensor
RustyBug wrote:
How does #1 change if the pixels remain the same size?
Improved sensor tech (e.g. D810 vs 5D3).
How does #2 change if the pixels remain the same size?
Also improved sensor tech. However, for a given sensor tech, five of the 5Ds pixels, for example, will have around the same saturation as two of the 5D3 pixels, so the saturation over a given area does not improve with larger pixels.
jcolwell wrote:
takowasa, I really think you're on the wrong track.
Thanks for stepping in. There are some folks here who are persistently and stubbornly wrong about this stuff, and eventually one wants to say, "Fine. Go ahead and be wrong."
gdanmitchell wrote: jcolwell wrotetakowasa, I really think you're on the wrong track.Thanks for stepping in. There are some folks here who are persistently and stubbornly wrong about this stuff, and eventually one wants to say, "Fine. Go ahead and be wrong."
Dan
Dan, I feel that you've chosen to reply with empty praise to someone who agreed with you rather than add meaningful content to the discussion. Perhaps if you could answer the simple question I asked:
Why, in your opinion, does a photo of a scene with the same camera, at 1/100 ISO 100 have less noise than a photo at 1/1600 ISO 1600 (or 1/1600 ISO 100 pushed 4 stops), if it is for a reason other than the fact that 16x as much light made up the photo with an exposure time of 1/100?
it would shed some light on the situation (please excuse the pun!).
takowasa wrote:
Why is the 1/1600 photo more noisy if not for the reason that it was made with 1/16 as much light?
RustyBug wrote:
As stated before:
Same pixel density, less light, more amplification = more noise.
Could you please elaborate your response? I'm afraid I don't quite understand. Are there factors aside from the amount of light making up the photo that contributed to the difference in noise? If so, could you please give a bit of detail on those factors? Thanks!
RustyBug wrote:
What comparison would you suggest already exists that is a fair representation of same densities @ FF vs. 1.6x that clearly illustrates such a difference in noise? (Honest question)
I just noticed your edit. How about the D800 vs D7000?
Sorry, I don't have a better technical explanation to offer (maybe others can assist).
Hopefully, this is not too sound too dismissive ... but I'd be concerned that the D800 vs. D7000 has other reasons besides pixel density contributing to the noise difference (which is evident). Maybe something that doesn't include a $$$ challenged consumer level camera build. (still open minded here)
takowasa wrote: gdanmitchell wrotejcolwell wrotetakowasa, I really think you're on the wrong track.Thanks for stepping in. There are some folks here who are persistently and stubbornly wrong about this stuff, and eventually one wants to say, "Fine. Go ahead and be wrong."
DanDan, I feel that you've chosen to reply with empty praise to someone who agreed with you rather than add meaningful content to the discussion. Perhaps if you could answer the simple question I asked:
Why, in your opinion, does a photo of a scene with the same camera, at 1/100 ISO 100 have less noise than a photo at 1/1600 ISO 1600 (or 1/1600 ISO 100 pushed 4 stops), if it is for a reason other than the fact that 16x as much light made up the photo with an exposure time of 1/100?
it would shed some light on the situation (please excuse the pun!)....Show more →
I'm not answering your question because a) it doesn't make sense to me, and b) I have already described how and why this actually works.
Like I wrote, at a certain point debating about something known to be what it is ceases to be useful. You are welcome to continue your research, and I urge you to go beyond asking question after question after question on this forum and perhaps instead go find some basic information about how digital image capture works online or in a book.
gdanmitchell wrote: jcolwell wrotetakowasa, I really think you're on the wrong track.Thanks for stepping in. There are some folks here who are persistently and stubbornly wrong about this stuff, and eventually one wants to say, "Fine. Go ahead and be wrong."
Dan
I am afraid takosawa is correct here, as far as I have read, and you have written things that go against how photon shot noise works.
"An interesting comment (thanks), coming via testing a pre-release 5Dsr with a test version of DPP4. Low ISO DR is put at 1.5-2 stops better than the 1D X, but high ISO performance (6400) falls marginally behind the 7Dmk2.
The sensor is similar to the 7D2 technology, but has apparently been tuned to maximise low ISO performance."
I am no concerned about the weight of SD cards, but a laptop. I do not think that I will manage to process and store files from 5Ds on a MacBook Air. I am only telling you what I think and hear from other landscape photographers now about the announcement. We still have a couple of months to go. So far I have seen most of photographers I know switching to D800/800E/810 for landscape in the last 2 years. When I was in Iceland for 2 weeks, I think it was 50/50 between D800/800E and 5DMKIII, but all Nikon uses were Canon converts. We really did not talk the gear too much, it was just an observation.
There is one thing that made a difference for me when I saw the announcement - the same DR as MKIII. I was sure that I am going to get this camera in a heartbeat if it had what it has + the DR of Nikon D810.
When I taking pictures like this one, I always want more DR:
alundeb wrote: Light_pilgrim wroteI really do not think that it is a good camera body for ladscape photographers. Landscape is all about the DR and detail. Yes, it will give the resolution but not the DR. I recently talked to my friends from Iceland that are leading photo tours and it is not a camera for them. Imagine that you are out for 2 weeks in wilderness, you pack light. How many memory cards you need to have? What if you want to download and preview some images, what king of laptop you need to have with you? There is a practical aspect of being a landscape photographer too.
It is not a camera for landscape photographers - D810 is.
This is a camera for studio where you can control the DR and need to print big for billboards and magazines. It is to compete with MF.
garydavidjones wroteChuck Westfall in the interview clearly is trying not to undercut the value of the 5D3.
He notes 5D3 has superior video and ISO range than the new 5Ds.
His statements plainly describe the new 5Ds as carefully designed for certain fields,
like landscape and architecture. Canon is continuing its niche design development
style.You arguments are not very consistent.
- If you need to pack light, the D810 has zero advantage over the 5Ds for landscape.
- Weight of memory cards is not a concern for landscape. The 5Ds takes SD cards, and a pile of cheap 128 GB cards weighs nothing.
- Dynamic range is not always more improtant than resolution for landscape, it depends.
- File size for preview is more a concern in studio and tethered shooting than for landscape. So in that respect the 5Ds is not better than the D810 for studio work.
For me the best option right now is to own both the A7r and 5Ds, for different situations. A D810 is an excellent camera too, but doesn't help with weight and doesn't complement the A7r as well. ...Show more →
Sorry, I don't have a better technical explanation to offer (maybe others can assist).
So you're saying that the "amplification" of ISO 1600 causes the noise, not the fact that 1/16 as much light is falling on the sensor? What about 1/1600 ISO 100, then? No amplification there.
jcolwell wrote:
takowasa, I really think you're on the wrong track.
gdanmitchell wrote:
Thanks for stepping in. There are some folks here who are persistently and stubbornly wrong about this stuff, and eventually one wants to say, "Fine. Go ahead and be wrong."
Dan
takowasa wrote:
Dan, I feel that you've chosen to reply with empty praise to someone who agreed with you rather than add meaningful content to the discussion. Perhaps if you could answer the simple question I asked:
Why, in your opinion, does a photo of a scene with the same camera, at 1/100 ISO 100 have less noise than a photo at 1/1600 ISO 1600 (or 1/1600 ISO 100 pushed 4 stops), if it is for a reason other than the fact that 16x as much light made up the photo with an exposure time of 1/100?
it would shed some light on the situation (please excuse the pun!)....Show more →
gdanmitchell wrote:
I'm not answering your question because a) it doesn't make sense to me, and b) I have already described how and why this actually works.
Like I wrote, at a certain point debating about something known to be what it is ceases to be useful. You are welcome to continue your research, and I urge you to go beyond asking question after question after question on this forum and perhaps instead go find some basic information about how digital image capture works online or in a book.
Take care,
Dan
I have to say that I'm disappointed that you would say about me:
Thanks for stepping in. There are some folks here who are persistently and stubbornly wrong about this stuff, and eventually one wants to say, "Fine. Go ahead and be wrong."
and then refuse to answer the simple question I asked:
Why, in your opinion, does a photo of a scene with the same camera, at 1/100 ISO 100 have less noise than a photo at 1/1600 ISO 1600 (or 1/1600 ISO 100 pushed 4 stops), if it is for a reason other than the fact that 16x as much light made up the photo with an exposure time of 1/100?
Indeed, it seems that the comments you levied against me might be better directed in another direction, to tell the truth.
Yes, that is a correct and good description of photon shot noise. A consequence of that is the the noise in an image is mostly defined by the total amount of light hitting the sensor, and the sensor quantum efficiency per area. But takosawa also brings in read noise here, which is important for (engineering) dynamic range.
Sorry, I don't have a better technical explanation to offer (maybe others can assist).So you're saying that the "amplification" of ISO 1600 causes the noise, not the fact that 1/16 as much light is falling on the sensor? What about 1/1600 ISO 100, then? No amplification there.
I'm assuming you have retained the same shutter speed to result in a corresponding 4 stop reduction in light.
Off the cuff ... 4 stops underexposure could be lacking detail @ near silhouette for portions of the scene (depending on DR of the scene), but it could still be clean without any amplification to increase the noise (layman perspective only).
Sorry, I don't have a better technical explanation to offer (maybe others can assist).
Hopefully, this is not too sound too dismissive ... but I'd be concerned that the D800 vs. D7000 has other reasons besides pixel density contributing to the noise difference (which is evident). Maybe something that doesn't include a $$$ challenged consumer level camera build. (still open minded here)
I don't know what to tell you. You asked for an example of the same pixel density on FF and crop, I gave one, and FF came up with less noise. You dismiss the example, feeling that there are "other reasons besides pixel density contributing to the noise difference" and ask for another example, with cameras that have "consumer level camera build".
So, aside from the 6D, what FF camera has a "consumer level build" that will satisfy you? Unfortunately, there are no 8 MP crop camera with sensors from the same generation that I can compare the 6D to.
Well, we do have the 5DS now, yes? When we compare it to the 7D2, we'll find the exact same situation as the D800 vs the D7000.