fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Sony a7R 28mm Lens Shootout

  
 
timballic
Offline
Details
p.4 #1Sony a7R 28mm Lens Shootout
Thanks sebboh those are again excellent
Jan 27, 2015 at 03:06 AM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.4 #2Sony a7R 28mm Lens Shootout
Tariq,
Here's a shot that has some pretty distant houses on the left side of the frame (the Susquehanna River is pretty wide.)

Sony a7R + SMC Pentax 28mm f/3.5 K (@f/11)

Full Size
SooC Full Size

-Tim

Tariq Gibran wrote:
tsdevine wroteThe 31 looks very nice Tariq. I picked up another SMC 28mm 3.5 K and it doesn't perform quite as well as the one I tested here.

That left side does look a little suspicious, maybe a little like mine when I use the Rayqual. I wish you weren't so far away Tariq, I'd love to compare our copies.

-Tim
Yeah, it would be great to compare them together. I may do a test using a different adapter on the 28 as, like mentioned, the Rayqual may be just shy of true infinity focus with the 28 and/ or may just not play well with that lens for some reason. The 31 actually focuses a tiny bit past infinity with the Rayqual.

Here is the same 28/3.5K using a different adapter at F8 taken with the A7r. I'm not 100% sure but there may be a hint of softness at distance in one of the mid frame zones of the
...Show more →
Jan 28, 2015 at 05:53 AM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.4 #3Sony a7R 28mm Lens Shootout
The processed image looks pretty good for F11 to me. There is some softening at distance, very noticeable in the SooC version which looks much better in the processed image (particularly the distant trees). Beyond overall exposure (are you using both exposure offset and illumination?) and turning noise reduction down/ off, I'm curious as to what other processing in Photo Ninja you are using (are you adjusting the Detail slider?).
Jan 28, 2015 at 07:01 AM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.4 #4Sony a7R 28mm Lens Shootout


Exposure and Detail
Illumination - 26 (it was underexposed somewhat)
Exposure offset - 0
Highlights - -0.50
Shadows - 0
Black - 0
Contrast - 20
Detail - 3

Color enhancement
Style - Scenic
Intensity - 33

Noise
Defaults...other than
Luminance noise reduction enabed
Smoothing - 2
Defringe - 90

Sharpening - 80

Chromatic Aberration - off

I usually use 5 on the detail slider (the other shots in this thread are at 5.) I actually backed it off to 3 for this shot. I actually turned on more noise reduction than the default, which I usually do. But I try to keep that smoothing setting between 1 and 3 if possible (in this case 2.)

-Tim

Jan 28, 2015 at 07:23 AM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.4 #5Sony a7R 28mm Lens Shootout

One of the things I love about this lens is the depth of field in seems to be able to produce. Reminds my of my ZE 21. The near corners are sharp, yet things at infinity are reasonably sharp as well, even at the edges. Most of the 28mm lenses I've tested can't keep the bottom corners this sharp while maintaining acceptable sharpness at the edges at distance. It's usually one or the other, sharp at distance on the edges but close corners blurred, or close corners pretty sharp and edges blurred.

-Tim
Jan 28, 2015 at 07:25 AM
timballic
Offline
Details
p.4 #6Sony a7R 28mm Lens Shootout
tsdevine wrote:
One of the things I love about this lens is the depth of field in seems to be able to produce. Reminds my of my ZE 21. The near corners are sharp, yet things at infinity are reasonably sharp as well, even at the edges. Most of the 28mm lenses I've tested can't keep the bottom corners this sharp while maintaining acceptable sharpness at the edges at distance. It's usually one or the other, sharp at distance on the edges but close corners blurred, or close corners pretty sharp and edges blurred.

-Tim


That's just what I'm finding with the 24mm comparison Tim, the difference in dof. I think the FDn is the best I've seen for this in 24mm. I haven't got the Pentax though, as even the better "A" version isn't supposed to be particularly good cf. the ones I'm comparing.



Edited on Jan 28, 2015 at 07:30 AM · View previous versions
Jan 28, 2015 at 07:29 AM
Jochenb
Offline
Details
p.4 #7Sony a7R 28mm Lens Shootout
Gary Clennan wrote:
How does the OM28/2 perform on the A7X camera's? I don't recall seeing many samples....


Pretty good. It sharpens up a lot when stopping down. From F8 it gets very decent across the frame.
It's a low contrast lens that renders nice colors IMHO.

Here are 2 examples from my OM28/2:





Jan 28, 2015 at 07:29 AM
timballic
Offline
Details
p.4 #8Sony a7R 28mm Lens Shootout
Perhaps I'll have a look at my OM 28/2 cf. OM 28/3.5 (that I've just got.)

On the 5DII the 28/2 was a favourite,(once I found a good copy), but I haven't tried on the A7 yet as I've tended to use the FE 28-70 so far for this fl.
Jan 28, 2015 at 07:32 AM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.4 #9Sony a7R 28mm Lens Shootout

I'm not sure if any of the older Pentax 24's will be as good as this 28. The 28 doesn't have't floating elements though, and I haven't done much testing close range. But at f/11 I can get a pretty amazing amount of near to far DoF.

I have an FDn 24 2.8, and I actually like my Nikon 24mm f/2.8 AI a little better. Maybe I have to do more testing. The FDn seems a little nervous on the edges, don't know if it's astigmatism or what it is. The Nikon is better to the edges, but not as good in the deep corners.

But as you note in your 24 tests, it's amazing how different DoF can be with lenses...maybe partially due to the cover glass interaction, but I have to believe a good part of it is just lens behavior.

-Tim

timballic wrote:
tsdevine wroteOne of the things I love about this lens is the depth of field in seems to be able to produce. Reminds my of my ZE 21. The near corners are sharp, yet things at infinity are reasonably sharp as well, even at the edges. Most of the 28mm lenses I've tested can't keep the bottom corners this sharp while maintaining acceptable sharpness at the edges at distance. It's usually one or the other, sharp at distance on the edges but close corners blurred, or close corners pretty sharp and edges blurred.

-Tim
That's just what I'm finding with the 24mm comparison Tim, the difference in dof. I think the FDn is the best I've seen for this in 24mm. I haven't got the Pentax though, as even the better "A" version isn't supposed to be particularly good cf. the ones I'm comparing.



Jan 28, 2015 at 07:41 AM
timballic
Offline
Details
p.4 #10Sony a7R 28mm Lens Shootout
tsdevine wrote:
I have an FDn 24 2.8, and I actually like my Nikon 24mm f/2.8 AI a little better. Maybe I have to do more testing. The FDn seems a little nervous on the edges, don't know if it's astigmatism or what it is. The Nikon is better to the edges, but not as good in the deep corners.

-Tim



Oh, I wish you hadn't said that Tim, I'd discarded the Nikkor as most reports I came across said the FDn had the better edges!
Perhaps when I've finished "round one", I'll sell off a couple that least please me and get the Nikkor and a ø49mm Fdn and compare those with my favourites. I've got the time, but not the brass!

Jan 28, 2015 at 07:49 AM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.4 #11Sony a7R 28mm Lens Shootout
Well, I think I need to do another test.... And you never know about copy to copy variation. So take my comments as anecdotal until I do some more controlled comparison shots.

And I've heard most people consider the FDn 24 2.8 a better performer on the a7 series than the Nikkor.

-Tim

timballic wrote:
tsdevine wroteI have an FDn 24 2.8, and I actually like my Nikon 24mm f/2.8 AI a little better. Maybe I have to do more testing. The FDn seems a little nervous on the edges, don't know if it's astigmatism or what it is. The Nikon is better to the edges, but not as good in the deep corners.

-Tim
Oh, I wish you hadn't said that Tim, I'd discarded the Nikkor as most reports I came across said the FDn had the better edges!
Perhaps when I've finished "round one", I'll sell off a couple that least please me and get the Nikkor and a ø49mm Fdn and compare those with my favourites. I've got the time, but not the brass!



Jan 28, 2015 at 07:53 AM
timballic
Offline
Details
p.4 #12Sony a7R 28mm Lens Shootout
Well, Just for interest I looked on ebay.eu (always a dangerous thing to do! ;o)) and there was a rather nice 24/2.8 Ai at nearly half the usual price, so for interest I bought it! I can either return it if any real problems or quickly resell if it doesn't measure up. I hope I'm right that the design was unchanged Ai to AiS, apart from possible coating changes. (I know the 28/2.8 did change design)
That's one thing with buying nikon, there's nearly always a good selection.
Jan 28, 2015 at 08:10 AM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.4 #13Sony a7R 28mm Lens Shootout
tsdevine wrote:
Exposure and Detail
Illumination - 26 (it was underexposed somewhat)
Exposure offset - 0
Highlights - -0.50
Shadows - 0
Black - 0
Contrast - 20
Detail - 3

Color enhancement
Style - Scenic
Intensity - 33

Noise
Defaults...other than
Luminance noise reduction enabed
Smoothing - 2
Defringe - 90

Sharpening - 80

Chromatic Aberration - off

I usually use 5 on the detail slider (the other shots in this thread are at 5.) I actually backed it off to 3 for this shot. I actually turned on more noise reduction than the default, which I usually do. But I try to keep that smoothing setting between 1 and 3 if possible (in this case 2.)

-Tim



Thanks Tim.

The Pentax 28/3.5 K does seem to have some special powers when it comes to sharpness at closer distances at those near edges/ borders in particular. I have noticed this is well in my comparisons.


Jan 28, 2015 at 08:31 AM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.4 #14Sony a7R 28mm Lens Shootout

Yes, no design changes between the 24mm f/2.8 AI and AI-s. Only the 28mm f/2.8 had changes from the AI to AI-s.

-Tim

timballic wrote:
Well, Just for interest I looked on ebay.eu (always a dangerous thing to do! ;o)) and there was a rather nice 24/2.8 Ai at nearly half the usual price, so for interest I bought it! I can either return it if any real problems or quickly resell if it doesn't measure up. I hope I'm right that the design was unchanged Ai to AiS, apart from possible coating changes. (I know the 28/2.8 did change design)
That's one thing with buying nikon, there's nearly always a good selection.


Jan 28, 2015 at 08:34 AM
timballic
Offline
Details
p.4 #15Sony a7R 28mm Lens Shootout
It seems that the biggest change was the intoduction of SIC coatings (Super integrated coatings) intoduced in late 2004, only the later and most expensive AiS versions have this.
Jan 28, 2015 at 08:51 AM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.4 #16Sony a7R 28mm Lens Shootout

You could always buy the lenses with SIC from B&H...they still sell both the 24/2.8 AIS and 28/2.8 AIS as new.

-Tim
Jan 28, 2015 at 12:40 PM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.4 #17Sony a7R 28mm Lens Shootout

I keep telling myself that and I try not to look at your 31 shots!

-Tim

Tariq Gibran wrote:
tsdevine wroteExposure and Detail
Illumination - 26 (it was underexposed somewhat)
Exposure offset - 0
Highlights - -0.50
Shadows - 0
Black - 0
Contrast - 20
Detail - 3

Color enhancement
Style - Scenic
Intensity - 33

Noise
Defaults...other than
Luminance noise reduction enabed
Smoothing - 2
Defringe - 90

Sharpening - 80

Chromatic Aberration - off

I usually use 5 on the detail slider (the other shots in this thread are at 5.) I actually backed it off to 3 for this shot. I actually turned on more noise reduction than the default, which I usually do. But I try to keep that smoothing setting between 1 and 3 if possible (in this case 2.)

-Tim
Thanks Tim.

The Pentax 28/3.5 K does seem to have some special powers when it comes to sharpness at closer distances at those near edges/ borders in particular. I have noticed this is well in my comparisons.



Jan 28, 2015 at 07:00 PM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.4 #18Sony a7R 28mm Lens Shootout
tsdevine wrote:
I keep telling myself that and I try not to look at your 31 shots!

-Tim

Tariq Gibran wrote
tsdevine wroteExposure and Detail
Illumination - 26 (it was underexposed somewhat)
Exposure offset - 0
Highlights - -0.50
Shadows - 0
Black - 0
Contrast - 20
Detail - 3

Color enhancement
Style - Scenic
Intensity - 33

Noise
Defaults...other than
Luminance noise reduction enabed
Smoothing - 2
Defringe - 90

Sharpening - 80

Chromatic Aberration - off

I usually use 5 on the detail slider (the other shots in this thread are at 5.) I actually backed it off to 3 for this shot. I actually turned on more noise reduction than the default, which I usually do. But I try to keep that smoothing setting between 1 and 3 if possible (in this case 2.)

-Tim
Thanks Tim.

The Pentax 28/3.5 K does seem to have some special powers when it comes to sharpness at closer distances at those near edges/ borders in particular. I have noticed this is well in my comparisons.


I did another comparative test today using a different adapter with the 28/3.5K. I do believe it made a positive difference. Particularly for medium to close distances like you shoot, that Pentax 28 is damn good. Here again in this scene, the 28 offers an extended foreground dof/ sharpness compared to the 31, particularly noticeable in the f5.6 and F8 shots. Focus point for both lenses was the center small tree in the medium distance zone (image center). I also believe I'm seeing that the 31 may somehow be showing diffraction effects at F11 more so than the 28. As for the 31, it does offer sharper side borders at F5.6 and F8 and if one looks at the smaller distant objects, they are sharper with the 31. I think the 31 pretty much peaks by F8 and the 28 at F11 (which works out nicely given it seems to somehow be more resistant to diffraction effects).

For these images as with the previous bunch, I did no additional sharpening (beyond default) or clarity enhancements in ACR.

PK28F8 by tariqgibranstudio, on Flickr

Link for 28 Album:
https://flic.kr/s/aHsk7kGUBz

Link for 31 Album:
https://flic.kr/s/aHsk7mdLqU
Jan 28, 2015 at 10:19 PM
osv2
Offline
[X]
Details
p.4 #19Sony a7R 28mm Lens Shootout
Tariq Gibran wrote:
I did another comparative test today using a different adapter with the 28/3.5K. I do believe it made a positive difference. Particularly for medium to close distances like you shoot, that Pentax 28 is damn good. Here again in this scene, the 28 offers an extended foreground dof/ sharpness compared to the 31, particularly noticeable in the f5.6 and F8 shots.


for me, the 28/3.5 does indeed look better there, but the 31ltd is cleaner all the way across the frame, it's pretty impressive.

thx for the post.
Jan 28, 2015 at 11:26 PM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.4 #20Sony a7R 28mm Lens Shootout
osv2 wrote:
Tariq Gibran wroteI did another comparative test today using a different adapter with the 28/3.5K. I do believe it made a positive difference. Particularly for medium to close distances like you shoot, that Pentax 28 is damn good. Here again in this scene, the 28 offers an extended foreground dof/ sharpness compared to the 31, particularly noticeable in the f5.6 and F8 shots.
for me, the 28/3.5 does indeed look better there, but the 31ltd is cleaner all the way across the frame, it's pretty impressive.

thx for the post.


You're welcome.
Jan 29, 2015 at 12:26 AM
FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister