fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2014 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2014The 20 1.8

  
 
ilnonno
Offline

p.1 #1The 20 1.8
Dear all,
for those waiting for the lens, I had the chance to try it out.


  1. First impression, very, very light, but not shabby construction. Slightly higher ring focus slack than the 24 1.4.
  2. Focus is relatively quick, and it seemed to be very sure (in the 50 or so frames I shot, both near and far, I never got the dreaded 24 1.4 "random" behaviour), both in normal light (outside) and under tungsten/mixed (shop).
  3. Image quality is acceptable at 1.8/2. I only had the D3s with me, so no higher resolution body available (there was a D750, but didn't want to push my luck to much ). Both f1.8 and f2 exhibit a bit of veiling glare, image is sharp enough in the center region, but it's not bitingly sharp. Sharpness tapers off 2/3 or so out of the frame.
    F2.8 gets the lens very sharp in the center, although the extreme borders still lose quite a bit.
    F4 improves the borders a bit, but then, lateral CA rears its head. F5.6 gets you probably acceptable borders, but CA increases once again at the periphery. Distance for this shot was circa 30m (my favourite building in front the shop on which I "test" all lenses ).
  4. all focus on the "aperture" series test was done, again, at 30-40m, and using live view at the intended aperture: no comment thus on focus shift.
  5. Distortion: I am absolutely no expert here (and quite like some barrel distortion often myself...), but I didn't happen to see any evident "wavy" pattern, which is the worst offender. Sure there is some barrel going on, but on straight lines it didn't felt too bothering.
  6. Vignetting is pronounced at f1.8. I can't quantify, but it's certainly there, and very visible. Whether it's worse than the 24 1.4, I don't know.
  7. Cusiously (and unexpectedly, seen what I had witnessed with the 58 1.4G...) longitudinal CA seems relatively well corrected, something that's been a bane of all the fast 1.4Gs of late (with the 58 and 85 being too "champions" in this...).


I am using ultrawides much less these days (even the 24 stays mostly in the bag), so didn't snatch my copy right there.
But I am thinking of ditching both the 17-35 and the 16-35 for it.
It's lighter than either, very small, and, at least on a low MP body, it appears useable already wide open. It sharpens well in post even wide open, although the difference once you hit 2.8 is pretty evident.
Curiously, it reminded me of the Sigma 20 1.8 I tried once. The Sigma had much more veiling flare, and a "purplish" appearance to images at 1.8/2, sharpening up well after that. The Nikon keeps a bit of flare, but it's pretty neutral wide open, and sharp enough already in a large portion of the frame.

By the way, I was surprised to see it is a "N" lens (none of the other 1.8G is, if I recall correctly).
I tried to get it to flare by pointing it at the strong lights of the shop, both centering the light in the frame and putting it at the borders, and – apparently – failed to get any serious flare, or almost any if at all.

I love when others share experiences on lenses I haven't yet tried, so thought to return back something to the community: don't chastise me if it's not relevant/accurate enough as a review!

Lory
Sep 25, 2014 at 01:23 AM
Jorgen Udvang
Offline
Details
p.1 #2The 20 1.8
Thank you for the report. This is a strong candidate for my planned 20/28/50/85mm f/1.8 quintet. The 28mm is also an "N" lens btw.

Now, where's that 135mm f/1.8?!?
Sep 25, 2014 at 02:35 AM
shujert
Offline
Details
p.1 #3The 20 1.8
The 28/1.8 also has Nano coat, but none of the others do. I'm planning to pick one up to replace my 14/2.8 and 28/1.8. Thanks for the report!
Sep 25, 2014 at 06:30 AM
mawz
Offline
Details
p.1 #4The 20 1.8
shujert wrote:
The 28/1.8 also has Nano coat, but none of the others do. I'm planning to pick one up to replace my 14/2.8 and 28/1.8. Thanks for the report!


It's worth noting that of the 1.8's, the 20 and 28 are the premium lens at their focal length, while the 35, 50 and 85 are the value lenses at theirs. Unsurprising that the premium lenses get the better coatings.
Sep 25, 2014 at 07:05 AM
rattymouse
Offline
Details
p.1 #5The 20 1.8
mawz wrote:
shujert wroteThe 28/1.8 also has Nano coat, but none of the others do. I'm planning to pick one up to replace my 14/2.8 and 28/1.8. Thanks for the report!
It's worth noting that of the 1.8's, the 20 and 28 are the premium lens at their focal length, while the 35, 50 and 85 are the value lenses at theirs. Unsurprising that the premium lenses get the better coatings.


The wider the viewpoint, the greater the chance for flare so perhaps thats why the 20 and 28 get the nano magic dust.

Sep 25, 2014 at 07:51 AM
low325
Offline
Details
p.1 #6The 20 1.8
Thanks for sharing your experience with this lens
Sep 25, 2014 at 08:22 AM
Sagar
Offline
Details
p.1 #7The 20 1.8
Thanks for your review. I am really eying building 20,35,50,85 f/1.8s as my "compact" DF kit soon.
Sep 25, 2014 at 08:27 AM
jhinkey
Offline
Details
p.1 #8The 20 1.8
A more rigorous test for flare and ghosting are night scenes with bright lights or the noon sun on a cloudless, clear day.
Can you share any full size images at the various apertures you tested?
Sep 25, 2014 at 08:49 AM
williamkazak
Offline
Details
p.1 #9The 20 1.8
mawz wrote:
shujert wroteThe 28/1.8 also has Nano coat, but none of the others do. I'm planning to pick one up to replace my 14/2.8 and 28/1.8. Thanks for the report!
It's worth noting that of the 1.8's, the 20 and 28 are the premium lens at their focal length, while the 35, 50 and 85 are the value lenses at theirs. Unsurprising that the premium lenses get the better coatings.


What makes you think so? Nano and price?
Sep 25, 2014 at 10:41 AM
shujert
Offline
Details
p.1 #10The 20 1.8
williamkazak wrote:
mawz wrote
shujert wroteThe 28/1.8 also has Nano coat, but none of the others do. I'm planning to pick one up to replace my 14/2.8 and 28/1.8. Thanks for the report!
It's worth noting that of the 1.8's, the 20 and 28 are the premium lens at their focal length, while the 35, 50 and 85 are the value lenses at theirs. Unsurprising that the premium lenses get the better coatings.
What makes you think so? Nano and price?


At 35mm, there's the Nikon 35/1.4. At 50mm, there's the 50/1.4 and 58/1.4. At 85mm, there's the 85/1.4. The argument that the 28 and 20 are the premium lenses at their focal length, thereby getting Nano coating, makes a lot of sense.
Sep 25, 2014 at 11:08 AM
LeifG
Offline
Details
p.1 #11The 20 1.8
shujert wrote:
williamkazak wrote
mawz wrote
shujert wroteThe 28/1.8 also has Nano coat, but none of the others do. I'm planning to pick one up to replace my 14/2.8 and 28/1.8. Thanks for the report!
It's worth noting that of the 1.8's, the 20 and 28 are the premium lens at their focal length, while the 35, 50 and 85 are the value lenses at theirs. Unsurprising that the premium lenses get the better coatings.
What makes you think so? Nano and price?
At 35mm, there's the Nikon 35/1.4. At 50mm, there's the 50/1.4 and 58/1.4. At 85mm, there's the 85/1.4. The argument that the 28 and 20 are the premium lenses at their focal length, thereby getting Nano coating, makes a lot of sense.


The 35mm gets ED glass, the 28mm doesn't. I would argue that the 14-24mm lens is the premium ultra wide. The 28mm does not seem to have the same snap, although my experience with it is as yet insufficient for me to be sure.

I read somewhere that nano is more effective for wide lenses, possibly because wide lenses are more susceptible to ghosting and flare.
Sep 25, 2014 at 11:33 AM
M_J_Helin
Offline
Details
p.1 #12The 20 1.8
Is there any information about the amount of coma?
Sep 25, 2014 at 12:09 PM
mawz
Offline
Details
p.1 #13The 20 1.8
LeifG wrote:
The 35mm gets ED glass, the 28mm doesn't. I would argue that the 14-24mm lens is the premium ultra wide. The 28mm does not seem to have the same snap, although my experience with it is as yet insufficient for me to be sure.

I read somewhere that nano is more effective for wide lenses, possibly because wide lenses are more susceptible to ghosting and flare.


The 14-24 is the premium ultra-wide zoom, the 16-35 the mid-range, the 18-35 the value option. None of those make the 20/1.8, the 24/1.4 or the 28/1.8 not the premium primes at those focal lengths.

The 28 seems to be designed primarily for reportage/environmental portraiture, it's not at its best shooting landscape, although it remains quite competent. It does seem to be very good closer in though
Sep 25, 2014 at 12:40 PM
r.gil
Offline
Details
p.1 #14The 20 1.8
Just got my 20mm...
I'm keeping it....!!!
shot hand held 1000 ISO D600
wide open F1.8 with available light in my kitchen...
http://www.pbase.com/gilaudio/image/157568317/original.jpg
Sep 25, 2014 at 03:53 PM
mshi
Offline
[X]
Details
p.1 #15The 20 1.8
In my opinion this is designed as a feather-weight landscape lens. As long as it's sharp edge to edge at f/8 and smaller apertures and has acceptably small amount of distortion with good control of flares, I'll be buying.
Sep 25, 2014 at 04:14 PM
LeifG
Offline
Details
p.1 #16The 20 1.8
mawz wrote:
LeifG wroteThe 35mm gets ED glass, the 28mm doesn't. I would argue that the 14-24mm lens is the premium ultra wide. The 28mm does not seem to have the same snap, although my experience with it is as yet insufficient for me to be sure.

I read somewhere that nano is more effective for wide lenses, possibly because wide lenses are more susceptible to ghosting and flare.
The 14-24 is the premium ultra-wide zoom, the 16-35 the mid-range, the 18-35 the value option. None of those make the 20/1.8, the 24/1.4 or the 28/1.8 not the premium primes at those focal lengths.

The 28 seems to be designed primarily for reportage/environmental portraiture, it's not at its best shooting landscape, although it remains quite competent. It does seem to be very good closer in though


The F1.8 lenses form a range with surprisingly good quality and modest cost. I doubt there is any reason to think some are premium, some not. The 20mm might have poorer performance simply because it is harder to make an ultra wide, but the quality has yet to be assessed.

Yes the 28mm does well close up, on a par with the old manual lens which had CRC. I use mine for landscapes.

Example
Sep 25, 2014 at 04:18 PM
juicer
Offline
Details
p.1 #17The 20 1.8
mshi wrote:
In my opinion this is designed as a feather-weight landscape lens. As long as it's sharp edge to edge at f/8 and smaller apertures and has acceptably small amount of distortion with good control of flares, I'll be buying.



If it's not good at wider apertures (for night skies), then what is the benefit of it over the 18-35g? The weight difference is not that big.

Sep 25, 2014 at 04:48 PM
Jason_Brook
Offline
Details
p.1 #18The 20 1.8
The 20 and 28 are premiums because there's no 1.4 equivalent above them. It's a simple concept. You guys are arguing semantics.
Sep 25, 2014 at 04:50 PM
Strobo
Offline
Details
p.1 #19The 20 1.8
juicer wrote:
mshi wroteIn my opinion this is designed as a feather-weight landscape lens. As long as it's sharp edge to edge at f/8 and smaller apertures and has acceptably small amount of distortion with good control of flares, I'll be buying.
If it's not good at wider apertures (for night skies), then what is the benefit of it over the 18-35g? The weight difference is not that big.



Two benefits that I can see:

1) The 20mm will be much easier to focus due to narrower DOF
2) The 20mm viewfinder image will be about 6-7x as bright as the 18-35mm at 20mm
Sep 25, 2014 at 04:57 PM
NazgulKing
Offline
Details
p.1 #20The 20 1.8
Strobo wrote:
juicer wrote
mshi wroteIn my opinion this is designed as a feather-weight landscape lens. As long as it's sharp edge to edge at f/8 and smaller apertures and has acceptably small amount of distortion with good control of flares, I'll be buying.
If it's not good at wider apertures (for night skies), then what is the benefit of it over the 18-35g? The weight difference is not that big.
Two benefits that I can see:

1) The 20mm will be much easier to focus due to narrower DOF
2) The 20mm viewfinder image will be about 6-7x as bright as the 18-35mm at 20mm


The distortion in the 20mm seems to be a lot less than the 18-35.
Sep 25, 2014 at 05:00 PM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister