Evan, the simple response to this portrait is I like it. Ive looked at it a few times and still, I like it. This morning I read your post on laziness and revisited this post and now have a better understanding of why I like it and why I think its successful in your efforts to create a "nice, simple portrait of a friend".
Per usual, you have executed the lighting and posing perfectly allowing me to get lost in his expression and explore other details that will help tell me the story of this stranger. His positioning on the chair and overall build tells me he is physically strong and possibly exhibits leadership qualities. Knowing your history with the armed forces, this is my first clue that this may be a friend whom you have served with. The juxtaposition of his expression tells me there is more to this person than strength. The way in which he leans on his hand breaks the mood of strength and the slight smile offers an insight to his kindness and possible sense of humor.
Further exploration of his wardrobe tells me he is married and I wonder if he is a father. The watch is the final detail and second clue that he might be military. Enough of the watch is showing that I recognize the brand and know that it is commonly marketed to and worn by military.
Not sure if it was intentional to use these small details as accents to his character but it worked for me. Well done.