fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2014 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2014Official Nikon 1 thread

  
 
DougJGreen
Offline
Details
p.51 #1Official Nikon 1 thread
Higgins72 wrote:
DougJGreen wrote
Higgins72 wrote
DougJGreen wrote
Higgins72 wrote
DougJGreen wroteThe fact that the photo above was taken with effectively 4 MP really speaks volumes about all the folks who are carrying on that 24 MP, or 20 MP, or 32 MP, or whatever, is not sufficient nowadays.
Except that it is clearly stated to be a crop which only reaches decent results because of the available pixels in the first place. The format (CX), combined with the lens provides puts a higher number of pixels on the target to achieve a usable picture in the first place.

One of the reasons people want higher pixel densities on larger format sensors is so they can, when applicable, achieve results like this through cropping. And if the entire sensor area is capable of this level of detail then you can print to ever higher qualities.
Except it was 4 MP out of 10, not out of 20, or 24 MP.
My point being that it was the equivalent of 4MP out 72MP (full frame equivalent). Hence why people want more pixels.
I agree that people who don't know how to use their gear might want to crop that much, but nobody else would, except in an emergency where you were caught carrying the wrong equipment.

Why on earth would you want to lug around an extra 90+ % of pixels you won't be using, and more importantly, the sort of heavy lenses to expose those pixels which you are going to discard.

Put simply, anyone who is consistently cropping over 90% of their frame is using the wrong gear.
Or it might be that someone who knows exactly what they are doing would want the camera to have plenty of pixels so that when the need arises they can get the shot above without having to carry an additional camera with increased pixel density. More pixels provides more usability.


It might be, but most likely not. This is the mindset of someone who wants a smartphone with 100 MP and uses digital cropping instead of using the proper lens for the situation.
Aug 13, 2018 at 08:32 AM
Higgins72
Offline
Details
p.51 #2Official Nikon 1 thread


DougJGreen wrote:
Higgins72 wrote
DougJGreen wrote
Higgins72 wrote
DougJGreen wrote
Higgins72 wroteExcept that it is clearly stated to be a crop which only reaches decent results because of the available pixels in the first place. The format (CX), combined with the lens provides puts a higher number of pixels on the target to achieve a usable picture in the first place.

One of the reasons people want higher pixel densities on larger format sensors is so they can, when applicable, achieve results like this through cropping. And if the entire sensor area is capable of this level of detail then you can print to ever higher qualities.
Except it was 4 MP out of 10, not out of 20, or 24 MP.
My point being that it was the equivalent of 4MP out 72MP (full frame equivalent). Hence why people want more pixels.
I agree that people who don't know how to use their gear might want to crop that much, but nobody else would, except in an emergency where you were caught carrying the wrong equipment.

Why on earth would you want to lug around an extra 90+ % of pixels you won't be using, and more importantly, the sort of heavy lenses to expose those pixels which you are going to discard.

Put simply, anyone who is consistently cropping over 90% of their frame is using the wrong gear.
Or it might be that someone who knows exactly what they are doing would want the camera to have plenty of pixels so that when the need arises they can get the shot above without having to carry an additional camera with increased pixel density. More pixels provides more usability.
It might be, but most likely not. This is the mindset of someone who wants a smartphone with 100 MP and uses digital cropping instead of using the proper lens for the situation.


So the picture above was taken with the incorrect lens? The only downside to more pixels is increased file size. Not sure why this is so hard to understand.
Aug 13, 2018 at 12:57 PM
DougJGreen
Offline
Details
p.51 #3Official Nikon 1 thread
No, but it also wasn't taken with a 100 megapixel camera and cropped down to 4 MP. If it had been, then, yes, it would have been taken with the wrong lens for the job.

Other downsides to far larger file sizes include: Far greater cost of the sensor, and the memory, and the overall system bandwidth needed to handle those much bigger files. Not to mention the lenses needed to resolve all those megapixels. If you don't see a camera+lens that costs many thousands of dollars but doesn't produce better end results than a properly chosen camera+lens that costs between 1/4th to 1/10th as much - and is also smaller and lighter, to be wasteful, I'm not sure how to explain choosing the right tool for the job to you.

Many more pixels than you are actually going to use do not come for free.

Aug 13, 2018 at 01:05 PM
Higgins72
Offline
Details
p.51 #4Official Nikon 1 thread


DougJGreen wrote:
No, but it also wasn't taken with a 100 megapixel camera and cropped down to 4 MP. If it had been, then, yes, it would have been taken with the wrong lens for the job.


So you are saying that if the above picture had been taken with a 76MP full frame camera, with the same lens, from exact same position, and cropped to produce the exact same result, then it would have been taken with the wrong lens?

What lens should have been used?
Aug 13, 2018 at 01:15 PM
DougJGreen
Offline
Details
p.51 #5Official Nikon 1 thread
No, in that case, the wrong camera would have been used. A much less expensive camera which was also far smaller and lighter would have been more optimal for the job. And the ~$4000 or so that was saved in the process could have been utilized to buy something of actual value, as opposed to wasted on unneeded megapixels that would simply get discarded. - after consuming and wasting computer resources in the process.

My prior comments referred to the camera+lens combination being wrongly chosen for the task at hand. In some cases, the lens chosen was overkill and wasteful, while in other cases, the camera chosen was overkill and wasteful. In either case, the wrong camera+lens combination was used to get the specific desired result.
Aug 13, 2018 at 01:47 PM
Higgins72
Offline
Details
p.51 #6Official Nikon 1 thread
DougJGreen wrote:
No, in that case, the wrong camera would have been used. A much less expensive camera which was also far smaller and lighter would have been more optimal for the job. And the ~$4000 or so that was saved in the process could have been utilized to buy something of actual value, as opposed to wasted on unneeded megapixels that would simply get discarded. - after consuming and wasting computer resources in the process.

My prior comments referred to the camera+lens combination being wrongly chosen for the task at hand. In some cases, the lens chosen was overkill and wasteful, while
...Show more →

What is wasteful is having to carry multiple camera lens combinations in the first place.
Aug 13, 2018 at 03:45 PM
DougJGreen
Offline
Details
p.51 #7Official Nikon 1 thread
You don't actually need the big, expensive one with all the extra megapixels you won't be using. You can do just fine with the smaller, lighter 20 MP camera that costs a fraction as much.

Obviously, if a $500 camera does the job you need exactly as well as a $4000 one where you are discarding 90% of the sensor's larger area that you paid good money for, the $4000 camera is a waste of $3500.
Aug 13, 2018 at 04:22 PM
Higgins72
Offline
Details
p.51 #8Official Nikon 1 thread
DougJGreen wrote:
You don't actually need the big, expensive one with all the extra megapixels you won't be using. You can do just fine with the smaller, lighter 20 MP camera that costs a fraction as much.

Obviously, if a $500 camera does the job you need exactly as well as a $4000 one where you are discarding 90% of the sensor's larger area that you paid good money for, the $4000 camera is a waste of $3500.


Not sure why you are convinced that I am suggesting carrying a camera worth $4000 where routinely discarding 90% of the pixels. Never suggested such a thing.

Aug 13, 2018 at 05:52 PM
jpelt78
Offline
Details
p.51 #9Official Nikon 1 thread
I think he’s working up to his punchline that all anyone needs is M4/3. And that we are all silly for having full frame or DX cameras.
Aug 13, 2018 at 06:34 PM
DougJGreen
Offline
Details
p.51 #10Official Nikon 1 thread
jpelt78 wrote:
I think he’s working up to his punchline that all anyone needs is M4/3. And that we are all silly for having full frame or DX cameras.


No, I think DX is justifiable for many folks. Of course it would be more so if Nikon made some more good lenses that were optimized for the format.

OTOH, easily 80% of the folks who believe they need full frame don't really.
Aug 13, 2018 at 06:49 PM
DougJGreen
Offline
Details
p.51 #11Official Nikon 1 thread
Higgins72 wrote:
DougJGreen wroteYou don't actually need the big, expensive one with all the extra megapixels you won't be using. You can do just fine with the smaller, lighter 20 MP camera that costs a fraction as much.

Obviously, if a $500 camera does the job you need exactly as well as a $4000 one where you are discarding 90% of the sensor's larger area that you paid good money for, the $4000 camera is a waste of $3500.
Not sure why you are convinced that I am suggesting carrying a camera worth $4000 where routinely discarding 90% of the pixels. Never suggested such a thing.



Well you did suggest you were looking for 76 Megapixels in order to be able to crop appropriately. And since you were not interested in having multiple systems, that would be the one you'd be predominantly using -given that you at least occasionally would need that sort of resolution. And if you actually did buy and routinely use a 76 Megapixel camera, I'm pretty sure it would set you back at least $4K, and that you'd typically not be using the majority of those 76 Megapixels.
Aug 13, 2018 at 06:54 PM
Higgins72
Offline
Details
p.51 #12Official Nikon 1 thread
DougJGreen wrote:
jpelt78 wroteI think he’s working up to his punchline that all anyone needs is M4/3. And that we are all silly for having full frame or DX cameras.
No, I think DX is justifiable for many folks. Of course it would be more so if Nikon made some more good lenses that were optimized for the format.

OTOH, easily 80% of the folks who believe they need full frame don't really.


What people actually need is irrelevant.
What people want is what sells cameras.
Aug 13, 2018 at 06:55 PM
DougJGreen
Offline
Details
p.51 #13Official Nikon 1 thread
Higgins72 wrote:
DougJGreen wrote
jpelt78 wroteI think he’s working up to his punchline that all anyone needs is M4/3. And that we are all silly for having full frame or DX cameras.
No, I think DX is justifiable for many folks. Of course it would be more so if Nikon made some more good lenses that were optimized for the format.

OTOH, easily 80% of the folks who believe they need full frame don't really.
What people actually need is irrelevant.
What people want is what sells cameras.


Apparently not, because cameras are not actually selling all that well, other than mirrorless ones. It seems that most folks realize that the camera they got a few years ago, or even their newest cell phone, is all that they want.
Aug 13, 2018 at 06:57 PM
jpelt78
Offline
Details
p.51 #14Official Nikon 1 thread
That’s not true. Mirrored cameras are still outselling mirrorless. See below for YTD 2018. A portion of Canon’s share will be mirrorless so it’s between 2-1 to 3-1 mirrored-mirrorless still. Of course that needle will start to move soon with Nikon entering mirrorless again.

^^^^^^^^^
Nikkei published their 2018 interchangeable lens camera market share report:

Canon: 49.1%
Nikon: 24.9%
Sony: 13.3%
All other companies combined have less than a 13% market share (the top 3 camera manufacturers gained 6.2% in 2018 to a total of 87.3%). While Canon and Sony gained market share (3.9% and 2.9%), Nikon lost 0.6%.

DougJGreen wrote:
Higgins72 wrote
DougJGreen wrote
jpelt78 wroteI think he’s working up to his punchline that all anyone needs is M4/3. And that we are all silly for having full frame or DX cameras.
No, I think DX is justifiable for many folks. Of course it would be more so if Nikon made some more good lenses that were optimized for the format.

OTOH, easily 80% of the folks who believe they need full frame don't really.
What people actually need is irrelevant.
What people want is what sells cameras.
Apparently not, because cameras are not actually selling all that well, other than mirrorless ones. It seems that most folks realize that the camera they got a few years ago, or even their newest cell phone, is all that they want.
Aug 13, 2018 at 07:27 PM
DougJGreen
Offline
Details
p.51 #15Official Nikon 1 thread
How's the growth rate for mirrored cameras, compared to mirrorless ones? You do realize that all of Canon's growth happened in Mirrorless, don't you? (as did Sony's).
Aug 13, 2018 at 07:29 PM
jpelt78
Offline
Details
p.51 #16Official Nikon 1 thread
You didn’t say growth rate, you said not selling all that well except mirrorless. Except mirrored outsells by a wide margin so it’s actually mirrorless that’s not selling all that well. And Canon and Sony’s share growth appears to have come at the expense of mostly those outside the Big 3.
Aug 13, 2018 at 07:39 PM
DougJGreen
Offline
Details
p.51 #17Official Nikon 1 thread
Declining sales from a large baseline is a worse situation, sales-wise, than rapidly growing sales from a small baseline. The former is indicative of companies heading to failure. The latter is indicative of companies that have a future.

Declining sales means selling is going badly, while growth means selling is going well - irrespective of the actual volumes.

Sales in decline is synonymous with not selling well.
Aug 13, 2018 at 08:03 PM
jpelt78
Offline
Details
p.51 #18Official Nikon 1 thread
The sales bucket is going not going to get any bigger because of mirrorless. It will probably still shrink a little bit from now. It’s only a change in mix not overall growth of sales.
Aug 13, 2018 at 08:10 PM
DougJGreen
Offline
Details
p.51 #19Official Nikon 1 thread
I agree, but I'd rather be the product line manager for mirrorless than for DSLR. And DSLR sales will decline irrespective of mirrorless sales.
Aug 13, 2018 at 08:13 PM
SiMuMe
Online
Details
p.51 #20Official Nikon 1 thread
How about let's get back to the demised Nikon 1 pictures


V1 + 1 Nikkor 10mm f/2.8 | F5.6 ISO 100 -0.33 EV
Aug 25, 2018 at 12:33 PM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister