fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2014 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2014The Nikon 500mm F4 Official thread

  
 
suteetat
Offline
Details
p.54 #1The Nikon 500mm F4 Official thread
https://morboi.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/ND8_7438-1.jpg



https://morboi.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/ND8_8196.jpg


500/4e FL with TC14e iii, D850
slightly cropped
May 21, 2020 at 05:49 AM
ChrisMak
Offline
Details
p.54 #2The Nikon 500mm F4 Official thread
suteetat wrote:
https://morboi.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/ND8_7438-1.jpg

https://morboi.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/ND8_8196.jpg

500/4e FL with TC14e iii, D850
slightly cropped


Since you seem to have both the 500PF and the 500 f4E, how do these compare in your opinion? I have the 500PF on the Z7, and think it is a great combo, but when putting on the 1.4TC, I feel it is less compelling. I would really like a 700mm option that is more than just acceptable. I am debating whether I should get a 500f4E after all next to the 500PF, for dedicated birding trips and for use with the 1.4TC. I would love to hear from people who have both these lenses and how they compare bare, but especially with the 1.4TC.

Chris
May 21, 2020 at 07:34 AM
suteetat
Offline
Details
p.54 #3The Nikon 500mm F4 Official thread
ChrisMak wrote:
Since you seem to have both the 500PF and the 500 f4E, how do these compare in your opinion? I have the 500PF on the Z7, and think it is a great combo, but when putting on the 1.4TC, I feel it is less compelling. I would really like a 700mm option that is more than just acceptable. I am debating whether I should get a 500f4E after all next to the 500PF, for dedicated birding trips and for use with the 1.4TC. I would love to hear from people who have both these lenses and how they compare bare,
...Show more →

Personally, I think at close distance, sharpness is not that different but the longer the distance, the more obvious the difference is when you pixel peep. 500/4E also retain contrast better against the sun. Of course 500/4 will have better separation.
I would not hesitate to put tc14e iii on 500/4 at all but also think that it is still very good on 500PF but at f8, light could be
come more of a problem.
Generally, if I can use 500/4, I would prefer to use 500/4 but its weight and size is not always practical and in that case, I
would gladly use 500PF for sure.
May 21, 2020 at 08:10 AM
ChrisMak
Offline
Details
p.54 #4The Nikon 500mm F4 Official thread
Thanks,
I find that the "crispness" and auto focus suffer noticeably with the 1.4TC on the 500PF in lower-medium contrast light. Auto focus does not always lock on accurately, but then I am referring to larger distances. It's my experience that distance shooting is most affected by the use of a teleconverter. I noticed that to a large degree with the Canon 400DOII. I.m.o. the 500PF is best without 1.4TC, and works but does not exite with the 1.4TC in anything but very good, bright light. I will rent the 500f4E in due time to see if it is worth the hefty price and weight. Perhaps Nikon releases the 600PF, 600mm bare is enough with the cropping power of the Z7.

suteetat wrote:
ChrisMak wroteSince you seem to have both the 500PF and the 500 f4E, how do these compare in your opinion? I have the 500PF on the Z7, and think it is a great combo, but when putting on the 1.4TC, I feel it is less compelling. I would really like a 700mm option that is more than just acceptable. I am debating whether I should get a 500f4E after all next to the 500PF, for dedicated birding trips and for use with the 1.4TC. I would love to hear from people who have both these lenses and how they compare bare, but especially with the 1.4TC.

Chris
Personally, I think at close distance, sharpness is not that different but the longer the distance, the more obvious the difference is when you pixel peep. 500/4E also retain contrast better against the sun. Of course 500/4 will have better separation.
I would not hesitate to put tc14e iii on 500/4 at all but also think that it is still very good on 500PF but at f8, light could be
come more of a problem.
Generally, if I can use 500/4, I would prefer to use 500/4 but its weight and size is not always practical and in that case, I
would
...Show more →
May 21, 2020 at 09:57 AM
suteetat
Offline
Details
p.54 #5The Nikon 500mm F4 Official thread
nesting season for blue tailed bee eaters.
D850 + 500/4e Fl + TC14e iii cropped quite a bit.

https://morboi.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/ND8_8751.jpg


https://morboi.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/ND8_8997.jpg


May 28, 2020 at 04:07 AM
suteetat
Offline
Details
p.54 #6The Nikon 500mm F4 Official thread
https://morboi.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/ND8_0329-ii.jpg


Some cropping, D850, 550/4e FL @ F4
Jun 01, 2020 at 07:04 AM
buseyphoto
Offline
Details
p.54 #7The Nikon 500mm F4 Official thread
Same experience here after testing the 500PF this week.

Very sharp lens, but when shooting with the 1.4TC III in bad light, but AF was surprisingly bad. Now also thinking about renting a 500f4 as I need the extra reach from the TC.


ChrisMak wrote:
Thanks,
I find that the "crispness" and auto focus suffer noticeably with the 1.4TC on the 500PF in lower-medium contrast light. Auto focus does not always lock on accurately, but then I am referring to larger distances. It's my experience that distance shooting is most affected by the use of a teleconverter. I noticed that to a large degree with the Canon 400DOII. I.m.o. the 500PF is best without 1.4TC, and works but does not exite with the 1.4TC in anything but very good, bright light. I will rent the 500f4E in due time to see if it is worth the
...Show more →
suteetat wrote
ChrisMak wroteSince you seem to have both the 500PF and the 500 f4E, how do these compare in your opinion? I have the 500PF on the Z7, and think it is a great combo, but when putting on the 1.4TC, I feel it is less compelling. I would really like a 700mm option that is more than just acceptable. I am debating whether I should get a 500f4E after all next to the 500PF, for dedicated birding trips and for use with the 1.4TC. I would love to hear from people who have both these lenses and how they compare bare, but especially with the 1.4TC.

Chris
Personally, I think at close distance, sharpness is not that different but the longer the distance, the more obvious the difference is when you pixel peep. 500/4E also retain contrast better against the sun. Of course 500/4 will have better separation.
I would not hesitate to put tc14e iii on 500/4 at all but also think that it is still very good on 500PF but at f8, light could be
come more of a problem.
Generally, if I can use 500/4, I would prefer to use 500/4 but its weight and size is not always practical and in that case, I
would gladly use 500PF for sure.


Jun 12, 2020 at 09:11 PM
ChrisMak
Offline
Details
p.54 #8The Nikon 500mm F4 Official thread
I had the Canon 400DOII with both 1.4tc and 2.0tc on the 7DII before I switched to Nikon, and even with the 2.0tc that combo had better (more consistent) AF than the 500PF + 1.4TC.
I now use the 500PF on the Z7, but even then, I find AF performance (consistency) and IQ (fine detail) not satisfactory.
The 500PF is perhaps best to shoot bare, especially at larger distances.
So I really hope that the 500mm f4E does significantly better with the 1.4TC AF wise but also for fine detail.

buseyphoto wrote:
Same experience here after testing the 500PF this week.

Very sharp lens, but when shooting with the 1.4TC III in bad light, but AF was surprisingly bad. Now also thinking about renting a 500f4 as I need the extra reach from the TC.

ChrisMak wroteThanks,
I find that the "crispness" and auto focus suffer noticeably with the 1.4TC on the 500PF in lower-medium contrast light. Auto focus does not always lock on accurately, but then I am referring to larger distances. It's my experience that distance shooting is most affected by the use of a teleconverter. I noticed that to a large degree with the Canon 400DOII. I.m.o. the 500PF is best without 1.4TC, and works but does not exite with the 1.4TC in anything but very good, bright light. I will rent the 500f4E in due time to see if it is worth the hefty price and weight. Perhaps Nikon releases the 600PF, 600mm bare is enough with the cropping power of the Z7.

suteetat wrote
ChrisMak wroteSince you seem to have both the 500PF and the 500 f4E, how do these compare in your opinion? I have the 500PF on the Z7, and think it is a great combo, but when putting on the 1.4TC, I feel it is less compelling. I would really like a 700mm option that is more than just acceptable. I am debating whether I should get a 500f4E after all next to the 500PF, for dedicated birding trips and for use with the 1.4TC. I would love to hear from people who have both these lenses and how they compare bare, but especially with the 1.4TC.

Chris
Personally, I think at close distance, sharpness is not that different but the longer the distance, the more obvious the difference is when you pixel peep. 500/4E also retain contrast better against the sun. Of course 500/4 will have better separation.
I would not hesitate to put tc14e iii on 500/4 at all but also think that it is still very good on 500PF but at f8, light could be
come more of a problem.
Generally, if I can use 500/4, I would prefer to use 500/4 but its weight and size is not always practical and in that case, I
would gladly use 500PF for sure.

Jun 13, 2020 at 06:33 AM
RandyR
Offline
Details
Jun 13, 2020 at 07:32 AM
RandyR
Offline
Details
Jun 13, 2020 at 07:33 AM
RandyR
Offline
Details
p.54 #11The Nikon 500mm F4 Official thread
ChrisMak wrote:
I had the Canon 400DOII with both 1.4tc and 2.0tc on the 7DII before I switched to Nikon, and even with the 2.0tc that combo had better (more consistent) AF than the 500PF + 1.4TC.
I now use the 500PF on the Z7, but even then, I find AF performance (consistency) and IQ (fine detail) not satisfactory.
The 500PF is perhaps best to shoot bare, especially at larger distances.
So I really hope that the 500mm f4E does significantly better with the 1.4TC AF wise but also for fine detail.

buseyphoto wroteSame experience here after testing the 500PF this week.

Very sharp lens, but when shooting with the 1.4TC III in bad light, but AF was surprisingly bad. Now also thinking about renting a 500f4 as I need the extra reach from the TC.

ChrisMak wroteThanks,
I find that the "crispness" and auto focus suffer noticeably with the 1.4TC on the 500PF in lower-medium contrast light. Auto focus does not always lock on accurately, but then I am referring to larger distances. It's my experience that distance shooting is most affected by the use of a teleconverter. I noticed that to a large degree with the Canon 400DOII. I.m.o. the 500PF is best without 1.4TC, and works but does not exite with the 1.4TC in anything but very good, bright light. I will rent the 500f4E in due time to see if it is worth the hefty price and weight. Perhaps Nikon releases the 600PF, 600mm bare is enough with the cropping power of the Z7.

suteetat wrote
ChrisMak wroteSince you seem to have both the 500PF and the 500 f4E, how do these compare in your opinion? I have the 500PF on the Z7, and think it is a great combo, but when putting on the 1.4TC, I feel it is less compelling. I would really like a 700mm option that is more than just acceptable. I am debating whether I should get a 500f4E after all next to the 500PF, for dedicated birding trips and for use with the 1.4TC. I would love to hear from people who have both these lenses and how they compare bare, but especially with the 1.4TC.

Chris
Personally, I think at close distance, sharpness is not that different but the longer the distance, the more obvious the difference is when you pixel peep. 500/4E also retain contrast better against the sun. Of course 500/4 will have better separation.
I would not hesitate to put tc14e iii on 500/4 at all but also think that it is still very good on 500PF but at f8, light could be
come more of a problem.
Generally, if I can use 500/4, I would prefer to use 500/4 but its weight and size is not always practical and in that case, I
would gladly use 500PF for sure.


the 1.4 is invisible on the 500e, AF and IQ
even the 1.7 works very well


[edit] isn't the canon f/4 ? I've never had a 5.6 lens take a TC well. For me I'll use the 1.7 and 2x on f/2.8 lenses and the 1.4 on f/2.8 and f/4 lenses, primes only and nothing greater than f/4, I'd rather get closer
Jun 14, 2020 at 04:13 AM
ChrisMak
Offline
Details
p.54 #12The Nikon 500mm F4 Official thread
Thanks, that sounds positive. The 500MM E is so expensive that it has to be right as it won't allow me to purchase anything else for quite a while. But if it takes the 1.4TC as well as the Canon 400DOII does, than it will be worth it. The 400 DOII is F4 yes, but still works great at 800mm F8

RandyR wrote:
ChrisMak wroteI had the Canon 400DOII with both 1.4tc and 2.0tc on the 7DII before I switched to Nikon, and even with the 2.0tc that combo had better (more consistent) AF than the 500PF + 1.4TC.
I now use the 500PF on the Z7, but even then, I find AF performance (consistency) and IQ (fine detail) not satisfactory.
The 500PF is perhaps best to shoot bare, especially at larger distances.
So I really hope that the 500mm f4E does significantly better with the 1.4TC AF wise but also for fine detail.

buseyphoto wroteSame experience here after testing the 500PF this week.

Very sharp lens, but when shooting with the 1.4TC III in bad light, but AF was surprisingly bad. Now also thinking about renting a 500f4 as I need the extra reach from the TC.

ChrisMak wroteThanks,
I find that the "crispness" and auto focus suffer noticeably with the 1.4TC on the 500PF in lower-medium contrast light. Auto focus does not always lock on accurately, but then I am referring to larger distances. It's my experience that distance shooting is most affected by the use of a teleconverter. I noticed that to a large degree with the Canon 400DOII. I.m.o. the 500PF is best without 1.4TC, and works but does not exite with the 1.4TC in anything but very good, bright light. I will rent the 500f4E in due time to see if it is worth the hefty price and weight. Perhaps Nikon releases the 600PF, 600mm bare is enough with the cropping power of the Z7.

suteetat wrote
ChrisMak wroteSince you seem to have both the 500PF and the 500 f4E, how do these compare in your opinion? I have the 500PF on the Z7, and think it is a great combo, but when putting on the 1.4TC, I feel it is less compelling. I would really like a 700mm option that is more than just acceptable. I am debating whether I should get a 500f4E after all next to the 500PF, for dedicated birding trips and for use with the 1.4TC. I would love to hear from people who have both these lenses and how they compare bare, but especially with the 1.4TC.

Chris
Personally, I think at close distance, sharpness is not that different but the longer the distance, the more obvious the difference is when you pixel peep. 500/4E also retain contrast better against the sun. Of course 500/4 will have better separation.
I would not hesitate to put tc14e iii on 500/4 at all but also think that it is still very good on 500PF but at f8, light could be
come more of a problem.
Generally, if I can use 500/4, I would prefer to use 500/4 but its weight and size is not always practical and in that case, I
would gladly use 500PF for sure.
the 1.4 is invisible on the 500e, AF and IQ
even the 1.7 works very well

[edit] isn't the canon f/4 ? I've never had a 5.6 lens take a TC well. For me I'll use the 1.7 and 2x on f/2.8 lenses and the 1.4 on f/2.8 and f/4 lenses, primes only and nothing greater than f/4, I'd rather get closer

Jun 14, 2020 at 08:41 AM
brian_sp
Offline
[X]
Details
p.54 #13The Nikon 500mm F4 Official thread
ChrisMak wrote:
Thanks, that sounds positive. The 500MM E is so expensive that it has to be right as it won't allow me to purchase anything else for quite a while. But if it takes the 1.4TC as well as the Canon 400DOII does, than it will be worth it. The 400 DOII is F4 yes, but still works great at 800mm F8



Talk to Geoff (arbitrage), he has experience with both lens you are wondering about, the canon and the nikon

Jun 14, 2020 at 12:20 PM
RandyR
Offline
Details
Jun 14, 2020 at 01:43 PM
suteetat
Offline
Details
p.54 #15The Nikon 500mm F4 Official thread
A few more from the past few weeks.

https://morboi.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/ND8_4057.jpg


https://morboi.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/monarch.jpg


https://morboi.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/ND8_3150.jpg
Jun 14, 2020 at 05:31 PM
bobmcg
Offline
Details
p.54 #16The Nikon 500mm F4 Official thread
This is my first real attempt at BIF and birds in general. Comments and constructive suggestions appreciated.



© bobmcg 2019


















Edited on Jun 19, 2020 at 09:30 AM · View previous versions
Jun 15, 2020 at 12:38 PM
brian_sp
Offline
[X]
Details
p.54 #17The Nikon 500mm F4 Official thread
^^^^
nice job Bob, really like the last 3 shots


squabbling tree swallows







Jun 15, 2020 at 08:55 PM
brian_sp
Offline
[X]
Details
p.54 #18The Nikon 500mm F4 Official thread








Edited on Jul 25, 2020 at 08:40 PM · View previous versions
Jul 09, 2020 at 04:00 PM
brian_sp
Offline
[X]
Details
p.54 #19The Nikon 500mm F4 Official thread








Jul 14, 2020 at 11:37 PM
brian_sp
Offline
[X]
Details
p.54 #20The Nikon 500mm F4 Official thread






Jul 25, 2020 at 04:37 PM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister