CritterRacing wrote:
Man i got a headache. this guy showed up today with a nice hole in his head. the first shot its closed up and looking kinda ok, then seconds latter it was ripped open some how. pretty gruesome.
Still, I am not seeing anything posted that I can't get with a 300 f/4 PF + 2x TCE III
The extra size, weight, + tripod collar (not to mention extra $2,000 cost) of the 500 PF does not seem to produce anything I can't get already, no extra expense, no extra weight, no extra size.
Compare what has been posted with these photos taken with the 300 PF + 2x TC.
Honestly, I don't see any photo-quality advantage that would make me spend an extra $1500 to forego the terrific size/weight advantage of my 300 + TC combo
arbitrage wrote:
Don't waste your time Will. He was banned for a year, back for a week and already in five different arguments spanning five different threads
Thanks for being a fan and follower.
Correction though: of the 20 posts I've made since my return, only 3 topics have involved disagreements in perspective, none of them unfriendly. (And, believe it or not, it's okay to disagree )
I've also posted quality images that you'd be lucky to equal, let alone top, even harvesting from your best, saved archives
Your post here, in contrast, is a direct attack having nothing to do with the subject (fyi).
You won't see me do the same to you ... no matter how hard you look ... so have a good one.
JohnK007 wrote: arbitrage wroteDon't waste your time Will. He was banned for a year, back for a week and already in five different arguments spanning five different threads I've also posted quality images that you'd be lucky to equal, let alone top, even harvesting from your best, saved archives
I could never equal the quality of your images....no one could....
And what does that have to do with anything, I have no idea, as I said nothing about your images??
JohnK007 wrote: arbitrage wroteDon't waste your time Will. He was banned for a year, back for a week and already in five different arguments spanning five different threads Thanks for being a fan and follower.
Correction though: of the 20 posts I've made since my return, only 3 topics have involved disagreements in perspective, none of them unfriendly. (And, believe it or not, it's okay to disagree )
I've also posted quality images that you'd be lucky to equal, let alone top, even harvesting from your best, saved archives
Your post here, in contrast, is a direct attack having nothing to do with the subject (fyi).
You won't see me do the same to you ... no matter how hard you look ... so have a good one.
Since you enjoy disagreement, you'll be happy to know that I disagree with you. Your photos aren't very good. The rabbit is angled away from the viewer, the background is much too distracting, and the foreground is worse. You have multiple stalks coming right through the rabbit's body and face.
The perch in your hawk photo is awful. For one, you can tell it was cut by man, and two, it is WAY too prominent. Moreover, you've cut off the hawk's tail, and the background behind the hawk is much too bright and distracting. Finally, the hawk's face is angled away from you, which does not always bother me, but, here, it does. Looks like having 100mm less in this situation would have been very beneficial.
Your last photo is a little better. The bird and background look good, but the perch ruins it. The stems behind the bird are bad and distracting on their own, but the foreground stem and leaf are what tank the image. They're much too prominent and distracting.
groob wrote:
Since you enjoy disagreement, you'll be happy to know that I disagree with you. Your photos aren't very good. The rabbit is angled away from the viewer, the background is much too distracting, and the foreground is worse. You have multiple stalks coming right through the rabbit's body and face.
Thanks for your critiques. I found your site, and I must say, if you held yourself to the same standards, there'd be a lot fewer images posted there
That said, I agree with your assessments, though I think you misunderstood my point. We agree, none of the shots I posted would make it to anyone's wall. The point I tried to make is what advantage does a 500mm offer that the 300 PF + 2x TC can't duplicate 95% of the time.
In other words, if we can get passed the fact my rabbit shot is not optimal, can we also agree a 500mm lens would not have made it any better? The environment is the environment; my lens choice didn't "put it there." Honestly, my 300 + 2x TC (600mm) was too close, so a 500 + 1.4 TC (700mm) would have been even worse.
groob wrote:
The perch in your hawk photo is awful. For one, you can tell it was cut by man, and two, it is WAY too prominent. Moreover, you've cut off the hawk's tail, and the background behind the hawk is much too bright and distracting. Finally, the hawk's face is angled away from you, which does not always bother me, but, here, it does. Looks like having 100mm less in this situation would have been very beneficial.
Lol, Lyle, I didn't "put that perch" there ... it's not something I "selected" as an artistic choice ... it represents the reality I was dealt when I chanced upon the hawk
I also didn't "cut off the hawk's tail," the reach of my 300mm + 2x TC was too great to properly-frame the subject. Same as you cut-off this poor crow's feet
I agree with you, that less reach would have been beneficial in framing the hawk better too ... which is a great selling point of carrying a zoom, like the 200-500, or 180-400. Trouble is, zooms are so much bulkier, and less user-friendly, than the 300 PF + TCs. Still, they do offer unmatched reach flexibility.
So, in the end, I actually agree with you much more than I disagree with you. However, I feel you continue to miss the point of my posting it. What would a 500mm lens have done to make this image significantly different?
groob wrote:
Your last photo is a little better. The bird and background look good, but the perch ruins it. The stems behind the bird are bad and distracting on their own, but the foreground stem and leaf are what tank the image. They're much too prominent and distracting.
I like this photo myself. Again, "the perch" isn't something I selected; it represents the reality of the natural environment in which I found the subject. Would the image make it to a discriminating fancier's wall? Probably not. However, I think part of the fun (for all of us) is "discovering wildlife" in its authentic environment. I often enjoy seeing birds and other animals "immersed in the thick of things," even though it may not make it to a wall..
Again, the point is a 500 mm lens wouldn't get rid of the sticks here, either, so the lack of artistic perfection isn't something that has to do with the lens, but the environment. Using a lens that was twice as big, and twice as heavy, would offer no visual advantage to my image, if taken under the same circumstances.
Anyway, I meant to post this point on the 500 f/5.6 PF thread, so I won't again garble this thread topic. I enjoy the size of the 300 PF so much that I can't see myself ever going back to a larger lens for hiking. Maybe for blind work, but for hiking no.
There's obviously no meaningful correlation between gear and talent, and modern consumer glass is sufficiently sharp and well corrected. (Love my 200-500 in bright light!) Still, I wouldn't want to part with the 500 because it's easier to handhold than the f/2.8 400 (I refuse to use tripods) and because f/4 is still okay for low ISOs at dawn and dusk. With the bodies I prefer, ISO 2000 still gets you good colors, but only just.
Nice work on these Christian H. I love the light and compositions. Is that last image a red wolf? It has such an unusual pattern for a guy who lives up north and is accustom to seeing gray wolves. Was it shot in PA?... I did not think that the red wolf had a population that far north.
OwlsEyes wrote:
Nice work on these Christian H. I love the light and compositions. Is that last image a red wolf? It has such an unusual pattern for a guy who lives up north and is accustom to seeing gray wolves. Was it shot in PA?... I did not think that the red wolf had a population that far north.
cheers,
bruce
Thanks, Bruce.
It's a male Eastern Coyote whose family lives in Valley Forge near Philadelphia. These animals are more robust than Western Coyotes but smaller than Gray Wolves, with whom coyotes apparently hybridized at some point during their eastward migration (keeping in mind that North American canid taxonomy is kind of a mess). I'd say he weighs around 60 lbs. They're big enough to kill whitetail, which seems to be the main prey in PA. (So, yeah, we have a thriving population of "small wolves" in the burbs as well as the city itself.) Here's a shot of him during the summer.
Christian H wrote: OwlsEyes wroteNice work on these Christian H. I love the light and compositions. Is that last image a red wolf? It has such an unusual pattern for a guy who lives up north and is accustom to seeing gray wolves. Was it shot in PA?... I did not think that the red wolf had a population that far north.
cheers,
bruceThanks, Bruce.
It's a male Eastern Coyote whose family lives in Valley Forge near Philadelphia. These animals are more robust than Western Coyotes but smaller than Gray Wolves, with whom coyotes apparently hybridized at some point during their eastward migration (keeping in mind that North American canid taxonomy is kind of a mess). I'd say he weighs around 60 lbs. They're big enough to kill whitetail, which seems to be the main prey in PA. (So, yeah, we have a thriving population of "small wolves" in the burbs as well as the city itself.) Here's a shot of him during the summer.
Interesting biology on this species/sub species. You are right about animals in the Genus Canis, they definitely appear to hybridize more readily than other mammalian species. These Eastern Coyotes definitely have some wolf in them. The muzzle and ears are more wolf like than the coyotes that I see throughout Minnesota and the West.
Viewing the photos on these pages kind of confirms the thoughts I've been having when viewing the images on the 500 PF thread. So much talk about "sharpness". The 500 PF seems to be sharp enough. But I feel it's sharp in the same way the 300 AF-P's are sharp. There's just a "crispiness" or edge to the images that lacks character. There's just something missing. Yeah, I know. What's missing is the weight. I get it. This doesn't diminish the value of the 500 PF in terms of portability and weight. I can only imagine it's a pure joy to shoot with. Does it make any sense to say the images of the 500 5.6 look more 200-500 ish than they do 500 f4 ish ? Anyways, comparing a 5.6 lens to a f4 lens that's 3x the cost is probably silly anyways. But then, what do I know ? I'm still shooting an old AF-I
sum1sgrampa wrote:
Viewing the photos on these pages kind of confirms the thoughts I've been having when viewing the images on the 500 PF thread. So much talk about "sharpness". The 500 PF seems to be sharp enough. But I feel it's sharp in the same way the 300 AF-P's are sharp. There's just a "crispiness" or edge to the images that lacks character. There's just something missing. Yeah, I know. What's missing is the weight. I get it. This doesn't diminish the value of the 500 PF in terms of portability and weight. I can only imagine it's a pure joy to shoot with. Does it make any sense to say the images of the 500 5.6 look more 200-500 ish than they do 500 f4 ish ? Anyways, comparing a 5.6 lens to a f4 lens that's 3x the cost is probably silly anyways. But then, what do I know ? I'm still shooting an old AF-I ...Show more →
Based on images shared on this forum so far, image quality is not a good reason to retire your f/4 500 or, indeed, your 200-500 in exchange for the PF. Old age and/or limited mobility and convenience are among the top reasons people have cited, which makes sense in an aging society of couch potatoes. Some folks have even said they don't really care about image quality (crispness, detail, bokeh, or however people define that for themselves.)
IMHO, I think that the quality/success of the resulting photographs from any of these Nikon 500mm lenses (200-500, 300PF/TC, 500PF, 500/4 etc) is much more down to the light, situation and photographer than it is to the lens qualities itself. Yes sometimes having the extra stop from a 500/4 can improve a background that is getting a little too close to the subject and it can get you that extra SS or lower ISO for a stop better quality BUT as far as sharpness/IQ goes I really don't find much in it between my 500FL and 300PF....the 200-500 just requires a little stopping down at 500mm and then even it is everything one needs as far as equipment goes. The real skill comes from waiting for the right subject in the good light with good control of the background distance and complexity.