fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2014 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2014A7 or A7R with Vintage MF glass? Poll Inside!

  
 
sebboh
Offline
Details
p.2 #1A7 or A7R with Vintage MF glass? Poll Inside!
Dudewithoutape wrote:
I heard about the color, noise, and res, but didn't know about the extra microcontrast! Thanks for the heads up. Do you mind sharing your thoughts on the bargain rangefinder lenses? Do you mean the Zeiss M line? Those are the only ones I've read about thus far. Post or PM is fine.

You are very right about the RX1 vs R as far as I remember reading as well. I should look for a used RX1 if I'm going that route, rather than a new RX1R. Very good point.


the zm lenses are more good values than bargains (they're still not that cheap). i was thinking of the voigtlander, contax g, canon ltm, jupiters and other russian lenses.


uhoh7 wrote:
I shot many lenses on both.

I found for non-native glass the A7 is much better, outside the center.

Beyond that, the superior centers of the R are not visible viewing whole images.

I wanted the A7r to be "the solution"; it wasn't. I returned it and am much happier with the plain 7.



gotta disagree. all the slr lenses i tried on both cameras showed at least a little improvement on the a7r versus the a7.

Mar 29, 2014 at 02:25 PM
Dudewithoutape
Offline
Details
p.2 #2A7 or A7R with Vintage MF glass? Poll Inside!
AhamB wrote:
One reason why the A7r would be a bit more attractive to me is that it seems to have less issues with sensor reflections.


Sensor reflections! Is the A7R really better than the A7 in this regard?

Edit - after some light google searching, it appears it's definitely more apparent in the A7 than the A7R. It also depends on UWA or WA RF lenses or the FE 35 2.8. Lenses with longer register distances and FL may see this issue less.
Mar 29, 2014 at 02:47 PM
carlitos
Offline
Details
p.2 #3A7 or A7R with Vintage MF glass? Poll Inside!
After reading this thread to this point, I wonder if one can tell the difference between the A7 and A7/r (or D800 and D800E) when the image is printed - apart from the quantity of pixels.

Not to throw the thread off topic, but I've printed enough large images on watercolor paper - scanned from film with a Nikon scanner - to know that a lot of images don't even survive to the printing stage. Print is a completely different medium, with far less dynamic range than a color monitor. About all you can hope for is a sharp image.
Mar 30, 2014 at 08:54 AM
jctriguy
Offline
Details
p.2 #4A7 or A7R with Vintage MF glass? Poll Inside!
retrofocus wrote:
jcolwell wrote
Makten wroteAsk yourself what the point of 36000000 pixels is. If you don't need it, get the a7.
Obviously, you haven't been swayed by the "need high MPx" whiners on the Canon forum.
You would say the opposite if Canon had such sensor in the first place. Can you add some value to this post? I don't think so because you never obviously tried this Exmor sensor.


How did you find the A7 vs the A7r? Curious what the difference in resolution is in real world terms.
Mar 30, 2014 at 04:07 PM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.2 #5A7 or A7R with Vintage MF glass? Poll Inside!
jctriguy wrote:
retrofocus wrote
jcolwell wrote
Makten wroteAsk yourself what the point of 36000000 pixels is. If you don't need it, get the a7.
Obviously, you haven't been swayed by the "need high MPx" whiners on the Canon forum.
You would say the opposite if Canon had such sensor in the first place. Can you add some value to this post? I don't think so because you never obviously tried this Exmor sensor.
How did you find the A7 vs the A7r? Curious what the difference in resolution is in real world terms.


I have only the A7R and never compared it to the A7. Personally I have no interest in the A7, since it offers me no advantages over the A7R. I can only compare the A7R to my 5D MkII, and this difference is very visible. I can see details in the photos taken with the A7R which are much harder to see in the 5D MkII. But the main difference on the first look of a photo taken with the A7R is the much better tonal range - I don't even need a graduated ND filter in difficult light/contrast situations. I was really positively surprised by this.
Mar 30, 2014 at 04:22 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.2 #6A7 or A7R with Vintage MF glass? Poll Inside!
carlitos wrote:
After reading this thread to this point, I wonder if one can tell the difference between the A7 and A7/r (or D800 and D800E) when the image is printed - apart from the quantity of pixels.

Not to throw the thread off topic, but I've printed enough large images on watercolor paper - scanned from film with a Nikon scanner - to know that a lot of images don't even survive to the printing stage. Print is a completely different medium, with far less dynamic range than a color monitor. About all you can hope for is a sharp image.


Watercolor paper is probably one of the reasons the dynamic range is so limited. There are other options out there if you want more dynamic range in the print. Obviously, none of the papers have as much dynamic range as a good LCD monitor.
Mar 30, 2014 at 06:40 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.2 #7A7 or A7R with Vintage MF glass? Poll Inside!
retrofocus wrote:
jctriguy wrote
retrofocus wrote
jcolwell wrote
Makten wroteAsk yourself what the point of 36000000 pixels is. If you don't need it, get the a7.
Obviously, you haven't been swayed by the "need high MPx" whiners on the Canon forum.
You would say the opposite if Canon had such sensor in the first place. Can you add some value to this post? I don't think so because you never obviously tried this Exmor sensor.
How did you find the A7 vs the A7r? Curious what the difference in resolution is in real world terms.
I have only the A7R and never compared it to the A7. Personally I have no interest in the A7, since it offers me no advantages over the A7R. I can only compare the A7R to my 5D MkII, and this difference is very visible. I can see details in the photos taken with the A7R which are much harder to see in the 5D MkII. But the main difference on the first look of a photo taken with the A7R is the much better tonal range - I don't even need a graduated ND filter in difficult light/contrast situations.
...Show more →

Just got my A7R last week and really did not have any time to try it out. Planning on a weekend in Portland in May where 'I'll give it a run in the Gorge.
Mar 30, 2014 at 06:42 PM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.2 #8A7 or A7R with Vintage MF glass? Poll Inside!
chez wrote:
Just got my A7R last week and really did not have any time to try it out. Planning on a weekend in Portland in May where 'I'll give it a run in the Gorge.


Sounds good - congrats! Be cautious when you first use it - I found this camera takes a bit of a learning curve to get used to especially if you (like myself) are not familiar with the Sony menu structure in the beginning. Even after having the A7R for several weeks now, I am still finding out new things. I personally like the EVF better than the display to compose and review photos (using the display mostly for menu options).
Mar 30, 2014 at 06:55 PM
tennclay
Offline
Details
p.2 #9A7 or A7R with Vintage MF glass? Poll Inside!
sebboh wrote:
uhoh7 wroteI shot many lenses on both.

I found for non-native glass the A7 is much better, outside the center.

Beyond that, the superior centers of the R are not visible viewing whole images.

I wanted the A7r to be "the solution"; it wasn't. I returned it and am much happier with the plain 7.
gotta disagree. all the slr lenses i tried on both cameras showed at least a little improvement on the a7r versus the a7.




I agree with that disagreement I have both the A7r and A7 and with a few SLR lenses, and the A7r benefits are clearly visible with all the ones I have. I have also heard multiple people claim you can't shoot the A7r handheld, it is for tripod use only - that one is pretty silly.
Mar 30, 2014 at 07:25 PM
philber
Offline
Details
p.2 #10A7 or A7R with Vintage MF glass? Poll Inside!
I use old, cheap and good Olympus glass (28mm f:2.0, 50mm f:1.4) on my A7R, and they really sing. I did compare A7 and A7R. There is a difference, to the point that, after some direct comparisons, I could tell which was which without comparison. Not a big difference, but, if you know where to look, it is defintely there.
Mar 30, 2014 at 11:28 PM
LightShow
Offline
Details
p.2 #11A7 or A7R with Vintage MF glass? Poll Inside!
Dudewithoutape wrote:
retrofocus wroteVoted A7R. The difference is huge, and I am using the A7R a lot with my FD lens gear. IQ is excellent, both resolution-wise and in the tonal range.
Which FD lenses do you shoot with, if you don't mind sharing? Post or PM is fine.

I'm mostly shooting FD SSC 24/1.4 Aspherical and now 55/1.2 Aspherical and soon to arrive 85/1.2 Aspherical, the best FD lens is the 35/2.8 Tilt/Shift, it's just awesome, sadly all these are near $1000 each, the good news is that the 24/2.8, 35/2, 50/1.4, 50/3.5 macro, & 85/1.8 are all good performers.

I also like my Topcor's, and my Minolta Rokkor MC's.
I've not had a whole lot of time to shoot with work dominating my life... Which help pay for my lens addiction.
My profile has a fairly up to date, list if you're curious about something, feel free to ask, just pm me a link to the thread. Also my flicker feed should have the lens used tagged to the pic.
Mar 30, 2014 at 11:52 PM
toshiro
Offline
Details
p.2 #12A7 or A7R with Vintage MF glass? Poll Inside!
I bought an A7r when released and used it for a couple of months but ended up selling it and buying a A7. IMHO the known issues with the A7r (RF wides, shutter vibration, startup time...) make the A7 a much better option, specially at the price it is selling lately, not more than a X100s.

If someone told me a couple of years ago that a 24 mpx FF camera smaller than a Leica M could be bought for that price I wouldn't believe it

BTW I'm new on the forum, so hi everybody
Mar 31, 2014 at 04:41 AM
wfrank
Offline
Details
p.2 #13A7 or A7R with Vintage MF glass? Poll Inside!
tennclay wrote:
sebboh wrote
uhoh7 wroteI shot many lenses on both.

I found for non-native glass the A7 is much better, outside the center.

Beyond that, the superior centers of the R are not visible viewing whole images.

I wanted the A7r to be "the solution"; it wasn't. I returned it and am much happier with the plain 7.
gotta disagree. all the slr lenses i tried on both cameras showed at least a little improvement on the a7r versus the a7.
I agree with that disagreement I have both the A7r and A7 and with a few SLR lenses, and the A7r benefits are clearly visible with all the ones I have. I have also heard multiple people claim you can't shoot the A7r handheld, it is for tripod use only - that one is pretty silly.


So besides the something like 20%+ linear more pixels, what would the other advantages be that you find clearly visible all the time?

And, BTW, tripod is good tool for harvesting that potential extra resolution instead of throwing them away with some spontaneous live type of photography.


Edited on Apr 01, 2014 at 05:35 AM · View previous versions
Mar 31, 2014 at 03:54 PM
sebboh
Offline
Details
p.2 #14A7 or A7R with Vintage MF glass? Poll Inside!
wfrank wrote:
tennclay wrote
sebboh wrote
uhoh7 wroteI shot many lenses on both.

I found for non-native glass the A7 is much better, outside the center.

Beyond that, the superior centers of the R are not visible viewing whole images.

I wanted the A7r to be "the solution"; it wasn't. I returned it and am much happier with the plain 7.
gotta disagree. all the slr lenses i tried on both cameras showed at least a little improvement on the a7r versus the a7.
I agree with that disagreement I have both the A7r and A7 and with a few SLR lenses, and the A7r benefits are clearly visible with all the ones I have. I have also heard multiple people claim you can't shoot the A7r handheld, it is for tripod use only - that one is pretty silly.
So besides the something like 20%+ linear more pixels, what would the other advantages be that find clearly visible all the time?

And, BTW, tripod is good tool for harvesting that potential extra resolution instead of trowing them away with some spontaneous live type of photography.


sharper pixels with a bit more local contrast, better noise performance, probably better color too... i bought the a7 anyway. just because the a7r looks slightly better at 100% magnification and in prints doesn't make up for it's deficiencies in responsiveness and performance with rangefinder lenses for me personally.

the original post was in response to uhoh who claimed that the a7r performed worse with slr lenses than the a7.

wrt tripods – they're nice at marginal shutter speeds, but don't really do much when you're not shooting at marginal shutter speeds. yes, marginal shutter speeds for the a7r are marginally higher than they are for the a7.

Apr 01, 2014 at 12:12 AM
uhoh7
Offline
Details
p.2 #15A7 or A7R with Vintage MF glass? Poll Inside!
sebboh wrote:
wfrank wrote
tennclay wrote
sebboh wrote
uhoh7 wroteI shot many lenses on both.

I found for non-native glass the A7 is much better, outside the center.

Beyond that, the superior centers of the R are not visible viewing whole images.

I wanted the A7r to be "the solution"; it wasn't. I returned it and am much happier with the plain 7.
gotta disagree. all the slr lenses i tried on both cameras showed at least a little improvement on the a7r versus the a7.
I agree with that disagreement I have both the A7r and A7 and with a few SLR lenses, and the A7r benefits are clearly visible with all the ones I have. I have also heard multiple people claim you can't shoot the A7r handheld, it is for tripod use only - that one is pretty silly.
So besides the something like 20%+ linear more pixels, what would the other advantages be that find clearly visible all the time?

And, BTW, tripod is good tool for harvesting that potential extra resolution instead of trowing them away with some spontaneous live type of photography.
sharper pixels with a bit more local contrast, better noise performance, probably better color too... i bought the a7 anyway. just because the a7r looks slightly better at 100% magnification and in prints doesn't make up for it's deficiencies in responsiveness and performance with rangefinder lenses for me personally.

the original post was in response to uhoh who claimed that the a7r performed worse with slr lenses than the a7.

wrt tripods – they're nice at marginal shutter speeds, but don't really do much when you're not shooting at marginal shutter speeds. yes, marginal shutter speeds for the a7r are marginally higher
...Show more →

I'd like to see where the A7r does "better" than the A7 with any SLR lens. Some of mine seemed more or less equal, but once I went wider than 50mm it was quite a difference. Sure there are more pixels, but they are often funky pixels. And the R rez advantage is never visible when the whole image is viewed on a mac retina display.

I did not believe this could be so at first, and I wanted the R to be the "one", but in the end I had to believe my "lying eyes"

My benchmark lens was the FD 35/SSC radioactive, which retained edge performance much better at f/8 on the A7 than on the R.

In fact both cameras have the flaw of relying on their processors for optimal sharpness with the native glass, as claus points out, instead of just making a true "R" model with a very thin cover on the sensor.

It's not that you don't see great images with the R, but it's ability to produce them is restricted.

So is the A7, but much less so.

However it's possible they could be modified to do what they should: apparently maxmax has been doing quite a few conversions, though you don't see any sign on their site. I'm trying to find someone who has had an HR conversion to see what effect it has and what the downsides may be.

Anyway that's my take, after shooting alot with both cameras and wanting badly for the A7r to be the best.

I'm afraid the most valuable lesson the A7s have taught me is that the M9 is no bigger in real world use, and not that much more money (you see them now for 3k often), and despite it's silly focus method, the lens selection is unbelievable and the results are a league above the sonys, for me.

Sure you have the 55 on the A7r, but I will take the M9 with a 50 lux or many other 50s over that myself...with the caveat of ISO at 800 or less...preferably less. But an argument could be made that at 55 the sony is in the Leica league, but where else?

All that said the Sonys are great new choices for all of us.

We each have our own priorities and "eyes" so I don't expect my conclusions to be right for all other shooters, and in few more months they may not even be right for me

I'm still amazed sony seems to have no clue that a nex-5 style FF with a near naked sensor would sell like crazy.

Edited on Apr 01, 2014 at 01:24 AM · View previous versions
Apr 01, 2014 at 12:52 AM
sebboh
Offline
Details
p.2 #16A7 or A7R with Vintage MF glass? Poll Inside!
uhoh7 wrote:
I'd like to see where the A7r does "better" than the A7 with any SLR lens. Some of mine seemed more or less equal, but once I went wider than 50mm it was quite a difference. Sure there are more pixels, but they are often funky pixels. And the R rez advantage is never visible when the whole image is viewed on a mac retina display.


i shot the same scene with the rokkor 24/2.8, rokkor 28/2, 58/1.2, contax g 28/2.8, contax g 45/2, and leica m 40/2 summicron-c on both the a7r and the a7 (but on different days). only the contax g 28/2.8 looked worse on the a7r when downsized to 24mp, all the rest looked sharper (even in the corners) on the a7r. i will try to normalize white balance etc and make crops when i have time to post the comparisons.

on a side note, mac retina displays seem to have done a great job of negating pixel peeping since most people can't resolve their pixel detail without putting on reading glasses and pressing their nose against the screen (this is probably a good thing, now they have to pay attention to other aspects of iq).

Apr 01, 2014 at 01:21 AM
wfrank
Offline
Details
p.2 #17A7 or A7R with Vintage MF glass? Poll Inside!
sebboh wrote:
uhoh7 wroteI'd like to see where the A7r does "better" than the A7 with any SLR lens. Some of mine seemed more or less equal, but once I went wider than 50mm it was quite a difference. Sure there are more pixels, but they are often funky pixels. And the R rez advantage is never visible when the whole image is viewed on a mac retina display.
i shot the same scene with the rokkor 24/2.8, rokkor 28/2, 58/1.2, contax g 28/2.8, contax g 45/2, and leica m 40/2 summicron-c on both the a7r and the a7 (but on different days). only the contax g 28/2.8 looked worse on the a7r when downsized to 24mp, all the rest looked sharper (even in the corners) on the a7r. i will try to normalize white balance etc and make crops when i have time to post the comparisons.

on a side note, mac retina displays seem to have done a great job of negating pixel peeping since most people can't
...Show more →

Agree to the last fully.

For the other part(s) it's a lot of hair splitting. I just dont subscribe to implicit claims equaling higher resolution to better IQ. Other much more important factors come into place if we focus on images and leave what can, and sometimes cant, be detected in 100% crop.

I was not on a budget and got the A7. There are some annoying things with it for sure, most of them shared with the A7r. And some things are better and some worse. The A8's will continue that journey I am sure, hopefully with a few less quirks and no new ones introduced.

This forum is really "great" at identifying all those issues quickly
Apr 01, 2014 at 05:55 AM
alwang
Offline
Details
p.2 #18A7 or A7R with Vintage MF glass? Poll Inside!
uhoh7 wrote:
I'm afraid the most valuable lesson the A7s have taught me is that the M9 is no bigger in real world use, and not that much more money (you see them now for 3k often), and despite it's silly focus method, the lens selection is unbelievable and the results are a league above the sonys, for me.

Sure you have the 55 on the A7r, but I will take the M9 with a 50 lux or many other 50s over that myself...with the caveat of ISO at 800 or less...preferably less. But an argument could be made that at 55 the
...Show more →

I would love to see a comparison between the A7r and FE35 against the M9 and your Leica 35 of choice: I'd be pretty confident that the higher resolution would compensate for any lens deficiencies, and then of course at higher ISOs it would be no contest. Of course, that's just one other focal length.

If you're willing to use SLR lenses, I find it hard to believe you couldn't find a lens (mostly Zeiss) at most focal lengths that is beyond the M9's league (or beyond) on the A7r.
Apr 01, 2014 at 07:48 AM
redisburning
Offline
Details
p.2 #19A7 or A7R with Vintage MF glass? Poll Inside!
ddd

Edited on May 01, 2014 at 06:11 PM · View previous versions
Apr 01, 2014 at 08:06 AM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.2 #20A7 or A7R with Vintage MF glass? Poll Inside!
alwang wrote:
I would love to see a comparison between the A7r and FE35 against the M9 and your Leica 35 of choice: I'd be pretty confident that the higher resolution would compensate for any lens deficiencies, and then of course at higher ISOs it would be no contest.


I would be interested to see such side-by-side comparison, too.
Apr 01, 2014 at 08:17 AM
FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister