fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2014 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2014Tamrons Response To AI Servo Issue.

  
 
gwaww
Offline
Details
p.12 #1Tamrons Response To AI Servo Issue.
This is an email that was forwarded to me from my local Tamron rep:

"
As you know, I have shot this lens on a variety of camera bodies and did not have any issue using it in Ai Servo mode. The lens is in the hands on many reviewers at this time and we have not heard any negative feedback.

What I have confirmed with our lens and other manufacturers lenses similar in focal length is the following.

When in Ai servo mode and attempting to AF lock on a moving subject it is helpful if you first use the manual focus ring and get the subject somewhat in focus and then push the shutter release to obtain AF. I spoke to one of our professionals and asked him his technique and he told me the same thing.

If this does not solve the problem then I would recommend sending me the camera body and well as the lens for our evaluation. It is possible that the lens is not performing to its maximum capability due to the optical performance level, AF structure, and camera AF system.

We would need to see the system to make this determination".

Pat Simonetti
Director
Technical & Customer Service/Distribution
Tamron USA, INC
10 Austin Blvd
Commack, NY
Apr 01, 2014 at 08:20 AM
Roy Morales
Offline
Details
p.12 #2Tamrons Response To AI Servo Issue.
1st - I don't have lens yet .
What bodies was it check on ? FF . crop ?
I only have 3 bodies it will fit - Elan [ won't even be mounted on ] XTI and 7 D .
I don't think I am alone in saying I won't ship my 7 D . I don't need a lens that
will only work on an adjusted body .
Would you list the bodies you checked the lens on and firmware version on each ?
It would also be nice to know the sweet spot on lens .
It would also be nice to know why there are no lenses in stock anywhere .
Can't get part [ s ] , trying to fix problem , major flu outbreak at plant , strike at
one or more plants - Right now most people are assuming you know there are
problems and trying to fix them . Why else would one one back returned lenses
for sale .
I for one just passed on the 100-400 rebate hoping to get the lens .
Apr 01, 2014 at 08:56 AM
gocolts
Offline
Details
p.12 #3Tamrons Response To AI Servo Issue.
gwaww wrote:
This is an email that was forwarded to me from my local Tamron rep:

"
As you know, I have shot this lens on a variety of camera bodies and did not have any issue using it in Ai Servo mode. The lens is in the hands on many reviewers at this time and we have not heard any negative feedback.

What I have confirmed with our lens and other manufacturers lenses similar in focal length is the following.

When in Ai servo mode and attempting to AF lock on a moving subject it is helpful if you first use the
...Show more →

Send those reps links to the multiple threads here from users who have taken a lot of time to test their lens and find the specific problem. Would they really read all the comments here and just say "eh, those people don't know what they're doing!".

While this AI Servo issue doesn't affect me based on how I utilize the lens, it definitely leaves a sour taste in my mouth concerning their future product offerings, and my willingness to suggest their lenses to others.
Apr 01, 2014 at 10:51 AM
MDelinquento
Offline
Details
p.12 #4Tamrons Response To AI Servo Issue.
Such a tidy way for Tamron to validate their quality and shift the onus to its customers.

I'm glad I returned my lens.

M
Apr 01, 2014 at 12:06 PM
dalite
Offline
Details
p.12 #5Tamrons Response To AI Servo Issue.

He did not specify 7D or ID MkIV

His photographer's technique would only see the bird fly away while the photographer is still fumbling with the camera controls

There seems to be a veiled acknowledgment that AF is defective

Apr 01, 2014 at 05:43 PM
Imagemaster
Offline
Details
p.12 #6Tamrons Response To AI Servo Issue.
gwaww wrote:
This is an email that was forwarded to me from my local Tamron rep:

"
As you know, I have shot this lens on a variety of camera bodies and did not have any issue using it in Ai Servo mode. The lens is in the hands on many reviewers at this time and we have not heard any negative feedback.

What I have confirmed with our lens and other manufacturers lenses similar in focal length is the following.

When in Ai servo mode and attempting to AF lock on a moving subject it is helpful if you first use the
...Show more →

What a bunch of double-talk. I guess he has not been in touch with Head Office that has been informed of this problem by me and probably others.

Since when do you have to manually prefocus on a Canon 500 or 600 to get AI Servo AF to work properly?
Apr 02, 2014 at 09:10 AM
dmccombs
Offline
Details
p.12 #7Tamrons Response To AI Servo Issue.
I am bummed to see that Tamron has such low expectations about the autofocus capabilities of their lenses (if you manually prefocus the lens, the autofocus may work - WTF? ).

It looks like the early adopters here saved the rest of the forum members some time and frustration. Thank You all for all the in-depth reports.

I went ahead and bought a Canon 400mm F5.6. You don't have to prefocus this lens, or stand on one leg on a Thursday, to get it to work.

I do wish the Tamron lens worked as it should, but I guess they are determined to keep their 3rd tier reputation. Their response really shows how little, they themselves expect, from their products.
Apr 02, 2014 at 09:28 AM
Jomax
Offline
Details
p.12 #8Tamrons Response To AI Servo Issue.
Imagemaster wrote:
gwaww wroteThis is an email that was forwarded to me from my local Tamron rep:

"
As you know, I have shot this lens on a variety of camera bodies and did not have any issue using it in Ai Servo mode. The lens is in the hands on many reviewers at this time and we have not heard any negative feedback.

What I have confirmed with our lens and other manufacturers lenses similar in focal length is the following.

When in Ai servo mode and attempting to AF lock on a moving subject it is helpful if you first use the manual focus ring and get the subject somewhat in focus and then push the shutter release to obtain AF. I spoke to one of our professionals and asked him his technique and he told me the same thing.

Pat Simonetti
What a bunch of double-talk. I guess he has not been in touch with Head Office that has been informed of this problem by me and probably others.

Since when do you have to manually prefocus on a Canon 500 or 600 to get AI Servo AF to work properly?

Perhaps Tamron has invented "semi-autofocus" ??
Apr 02, 2014 at 07:00 PM
IndyFab
Offline
Details
p.12 #9Tamrons Response To AI Servo Issue.
'When in Ai servo mode and attempting to AF lock on a moving subject it is helpful if you first use the manual focus ring and get the subject somewhat in focus and then push the shutter release to obtain AF. I spoke to one of our professionals and asked him his technique and he told me the same thing"

Would this not require switching AF to Manual switch on lens, then manually focusing focus ring.

So then whats the point of having AF, or am I missing something.

Sounds like at that point you have nothing more than a manually focusing lens. If you change targets, you then have to repeat the process of manually focusing..

Why doesn't AF do this in the first place, as intended .

If I am understanding this correctly, I am having a good laugh.





Apr 02, 2014 at 08:35 PM
riokid
Offline
Details
p.12 #10Tamrons Response To AI Servo Issue.
Most Canon lenses, and all the big guns have FTM (full time manual) feature, which allows you manually adjust focus without switching to Manual mode.

I think the lens in question has that feature too

IndyFab wrote:
'When in Ai servo mode and attempting to AF lock on a moving subject it is helpful if you first use the manual focus ring and get the subject somewhat in focus and then push the shutter release to obtain AF. I spoke to one of our professionals and asked him his technique and he told me the same thing"

Would this not require switching AF to Manual switch on lens, then manually focusing focus ring.

So then whats the point of having AF, or am I missing something.

Sounds like at that point you have nothing more than a manually focusing lens.
...Show more →
Apr 02, 2014 at 09:48 PM
OntheRez
Offline
Details
p.12 #11Tamrons Response To AI Servo Issue.
Imagemaster wrote:
What a bunch of double-talk. I guess he has not been in touch with Head Office that has been informed of this problem by me and probably others.

Since when do you have to manually prefocus on a Canon 500 or 600 to get AI Servo AF to work properly?


IM,

I understand that this lens didn't meet your requirements particularly when coupled with the 7D. You continue to make this point repeatedly and vociferously. I'm still watching this whole discussion wondering about the lens. Frankly it seems remarkable at the price particularly with stationary objects. In the above quote you dismiss Tamron's response (which is rather lame) by noting it doesn't perform like a Canon 500 or 600. Perhaps this is part of the perceived problem with the 120-600. To expect a 2nd tier lens maker to introduce a lens at ~$1K that will compete directly with one of Canon's big primes - what are they $6K - $8K - simply isn't realistic. Even if we concede that Canon's profit margin on the "big whites" is well beyond normal (likely true), there's no way such a lens can be produced in the $1K range. Conversely there is also - best I can tell - no possible way a $1K lens is going to compete against an "ultimate" prime.

It seems clear that at least on some cameras the 120-600 doesn't do AIservo well at all. On the other hand there have been examples presented in this thread of fairly good results by some. The poster with the duck sequence comes to mind. I believe you agreed they were okay but wanted pix from "smaller faster" birds. I agree with you completely. The Tamron zoom is not in the same league as the Canon primes.

Having conceded that point, my real question is "Can the Tamron work well within some limits, e.g., of a tripod on stationary or relatively stationary objects?" This appears to be so from some of the pix in this thread. In other words "Can I get $1K of value at 600mm from the Tamron in a reasonable number of scenarios?" Any thought by you or other users of this lens would be appreciated.

Robert

BTW I regularly have to manually prefocus with macro lenses (including Canon's). Admittedly different subjects, but not necessary a damning indictment.
Apr 03, 2014 at 10:12 AM
Imagemaster
Offline
Details
p.12 #12Tamrons Response To AI Servo Issue.
Robert,

Perhaps you should read my posts more carefully, and not state what I did not say. I did not say "it does not perform like a Canon 500 or 600". I said, Since when do you have to manually prefocus on a Canon 500 or 600 to get AI Servo AF to work properly? That is hardly the same thing. By the way, it is a Tamron 150-600, not a 120-600.

Also, it is you that is comparing the Tamron zoom to primes, not me. You don't have to manually pre-focus Sigma zooms, nor do you have to manually pre-focus the Tamron 200-500, Tamron 90mm macro, or Tamron 180mm macro, so why should you have to do so with the Tamron 150-600 I also have a Canon 100mm macro and I do not HAVE TO manually prefocus.

So what if I continually mention the Tamron does not focus properly with several Canon bodies? I have also stated repeatedly that for stationary subjects, it gives great results and is the best bang for your buck to get to 600mm.
Tamron repeatedly states there is no problem, yet others besides myself repeatedly state otherwise.

Please tell me why the Sigma zooms work properly at the same price range, but the Tamron does not.

Having to prefocus is a damning indictment for those who shoot fast moving subjects. With wildlife, you often barely have time to get the camera up to your eye and get it in the viewfinder, let alone manually prefocus.

FYI, I have another copy arriving today. Supposedly, it will AF properly on my 70D, and will still give me the cheapest 600mm for static subjects on my 1D4.
Apr 03, 2014 at 10:45 AM
gocolts
Offline
Details
p.12 #13Tamrons Response To AI Servo Issue.
Imagemaster wrote:
Robert,

Perhaps you should read my posts more carefully, and not state what I did not say. I did not say "it does not perform like a Canon 500 or 600". I said,
Earlier quoteSince when do you have to manually prefocus on a Canon 500 or 600 to get AI Servo AF to work properly?
That is hardly the same thing. By the way, it is a Tamron 150-600, not a 120-600.

Also, it is you that is comparing the Tamron zoom to primes, not me. You don't have to manually pre-focus Sigma zooms, nor do you have to manually pre-focus the Tamron 200-500, Tamron 90mm macro, or Tamron 180mm macro, so why should you have to do so with the Tamron 150-600
...Show more →

Glad to hear you have another copy coming today...be sure to let us know how it does on the 70D, as that's been a thought of mine going forward depending on the price/performance on a 7DII....assuming it's announced sometime this century.
Apr 03, 2014 at 10:54 AM
Imagemaster
Offline
Details
p.12 #14Tamrons Response To AI Servo Issue.
mfpm wrote:
Imagemaster wroteWith wildlife, you often barely have time to get the camera up to your eye and get it in the viewfinder, let alone manually prefocus.
Which affordable super tele zoom can do that? I'd like one of those....



https://www.fredmiranda.com/reviews/showproduct.php/product/358/sort/7/cat/37/page/1
Apr 03, 2014 at 11:28 AM
Roy Morales
Offline
Details
p.12 #15Tamrons Response To AI Servo Issue.
1st , I don't have the 150-600 .
2nd , I am on back order in 2 local stores
3 rd , I did not like 50-500 or 150-500 siggys , but do own 3 others .
4th , since I don't use AI servo , I don't really care if it works or not .
5th , I seldom drag around a tripod, I do use it in Mexico with a remote [ still
have not caught a good humming bird shot ]
6th , Even if I prefocus my Canon 50 1.4 , it still sucks - I have to use live view
@ 1.4 .
7th , it would be nice if Tamron would print a sticker saying AI servo may not work
on - list a few bodies - or - AI servo will only work on - list a few bodies and release the
lens to the rest of us .
Canon already does - AF won't work @ / above f 6 on crops , the 2X III won't work very
well on non version II lens even if it fits .
Apr 03, 2014 at 01:41 PM
Jim Victory
Offline
Details
p.12 #16Tamrons Response To AI Servo Issue.
Tony I'm another one that is interested in your feedback on the Tamron 150-600 with the 70D.

Looking forward to your evaluation and opinion.

Jim
Apr 03, 2014 at 04:01 PM
Imagemaster
Offline
Details
p.12 #17Tamrons Response To AI Servo Issue.
Jim, needless to say, it is another cloudy, rainy day in the PNW so have just taken some test shots with my 1D4. The AF in AI Servo works this time, and AF in One Shot mode works with a Kenko 1.4x DGX TC.

Hopefully will get to test with 70D tomorrow.

Just for anyone's interest, the serial number on my first copy was 0018XX and on this copy is 0070XX. Seems to confirm this is from Tamron's second shipment to North America.

Edited on Apr 03, 2014 at 08:22 PM · View previous versions
Apr 03, 2014 at 07:02 PM
Roy Morales
Offline
Details
p.12 #18Tamrons Response To AI Servo Issue.
Thanks , hopefully they are shipping .
Apr 03, 2014 at 07:05 PM
Firefighterjos
Offline
Details
p.12 #19Tamrons Response To AI Servo Issue.
Imagemaster wrote:
Jim, needless to say, it is another cloudy, rainy day in the PNW so have just taken some test shots with my 1D4. The AF in AI Servo works this time, and AF in One Shot mode works with a Tamron 1.4x DGX TC.

Hopefully will get to test with 70D tomorrow.

Just for anyone's interest, the serial number on my first copy was 0018XX and on this copy is 0070XX. Seems to confirm this is from Tamron's second shipment to North America.



They send you a whole new lens and do it seem to perform better?

Edited on Apr 03, 2014 at 08:00 PM · View previous versions
Apr 03, 2014 at 07:56 PM
lowa2
Offline
Details
p.12 #20Tamrons Response To AI Servo Issue.
Imagemaster wrote:
Jim, needless to say, it is another cloudy, rainy day in the PNW so have just taken some test shots with my 1D4. The AF in AI Servo works this time, and AF in One Shot mode works with a Tamron 1.4x DGX TC.

Hopefully will get to test with 70D tomorrow.

Just for anyone's interest, the serial number on my first copy was 0018XX and on this copy is 0070XX. Seems to confirm this is from Tamron's second shipment to North America.


Tony,

Servo works on the 1D4 now with this new lens?
Apr 03, 2014 at 07:59 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister