I did a fast backlit comparison and I was surprised by the differences. I haven't revealed which is which yet. I've always enjoyed the "tests" on here and thought I'd give you guys a chance to guess which was which.
#1 has pretty good skin tones, ;-) Does this guy have one dark eye like David Bowie? I think 'Nikon' is the correct answer to this question, and by the way what was the question? Anyway, Nikon it is.
Too many choices to guess, but the Zeiss ZF 2/50 is not exactly a point-freely-at-the-sun type of lens.
The ZF.2 I tried was worse still than the ZF, due to an apparent change in the AR coatings.
Keith B. wrote:
The ZF.2 I tried was worse still than the ZF, due to an apparent change in the AR coatings.
This was said once by an dpr owner that then became confused about what he did or didn't own Somehow then it became the legend. I've owned both zf and zf.2 of the same lenses and there is no such difference from either inspection or use and Zeiss themselves have never offered any such.
It was never true and so your problem needs to be blamed on something else.
Nathan, interesting comparison, it would be nice if you could also post the whole frames so we can see the drawing differences overall. I wonder which is 50mm 1.8 Series E.
OneAnt wrote: Keith B. wroteThe ZF.2 I tried was worse still than the ZF, due to an apparent change in the AR coatings.This was said once by an dpr owner that then became confused about what he did or didn't own Somehow then it became the legend. I've owned both zf and zf.2 of the same lenses and there is no such difference from either inspection or use and Zeiss themselves have never offered any such.
It was never true and so your problem needs to be blamed on something else.
Correct. Zeiss ZF and ZF.2 are completely identical lenses apart from a manual versus electronic aperture.
1: Zeiss at f2
2: Nikon AI-S at @1.4
3: Nikon AI-S @ f2
4: Nikon 55mm micro @ 2.8
5: Series E @ 1.8
6: Zeiss again at f2 (I had to shoot it again because the difference was blowing my mind)
7: 24-70 @2.8
8: 1.4 AF-D @ f2
9: 1.4 AF-D @ 1.4
10: Nikon 1 with 18.5 @1.8
Jman13 wrote:
Curious what ISO the Nikon 1 shot was at...that's a good bit of noise...passable, but looks to be about what I get at ISO 1600 on the OM-D.
#1 is the sharpest and highest contrast of the bunch, that's for sure.
wiseguy010 wrote:
Wow, in this test the Zeiss 50MP sets everything from Nikon far behind.
No surprise from those (like me) who shoot both Nikkor and Zeiss
Ripolini wrote: wiseguy010 wroteWow, in this test the Zeiss 50MP sets everything from Nikon far behind.No surprise from those (like me) who shoot both Nikkor and Zeiss
Of course. :-) But the difference with the Nikon 24-70mm 2.8 for example is much larger than I expected. The Nikon 24-70mm 2.8 is widely considered as a high quality lens, but that doesn't show here.
Well, actually in those shots the 24-70 suffers from flare more than from lack of resolution (there are not so tiny details in the test pictures).
Flare reduces the 'contrast' dramatically.
The Zeiss 50 MP has 8 elements in 6 groups. AFS 24-70/2.8 has 15 elements in 11 groups. Therefore, the former has 12 air-glass interfaces, the latter has 22 air-glass interfaces. No surprise the zoom suffers from flare much more than the 50 MP, even if the Nikkor claims nanocoating.