fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2011 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2011Ricoh GXR M module and NEX-5N review

  
 
thrice
Offline
Details
p.2 #1Ricoh GXR M module and NEX-5N review
The M9 has a lower density sensor and no AA filter, moire is certainly a problem but not the end of the world. With higher density sensors like the NEX-5N and NEX-7 it becomes even less of a problem. There is no software correction of moire on the M9.
Dec 19, 2011 at 07:51 AM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.2 #2Ricoh GXR M module and NEX-5N review
thrice wrote:
The M9 has a lower density sensor and no AA filter, moire is certainly a problem but not the end of the world. With higher density sensors like the NEX-5N and NEX-7 it becomes even less of a problem. There is no software correction of moire on the M9.


I have actually seen many examples of severe moire from the m9 posted. I have also seen it occasionally with 5D images I have taken with the weak AA filter. In the case of the 5D, removing the AA filter would likely show lots of moire in the right situations. There may be something to the higher density theory (the moire I have seen from even the GXR M module is quite minor thus far) so it will be interesting to see what happens with the 5n sensor.
Dec 19, 2011 at 08:16 AM
edwardkaraa
Offline
Details
p.2 #3Ricoh GXR M module and NEX-5N review
The presence of the AA filter makes things worse in the corners, inevitably. Leica tried to make the IR filter as thin as possible and completely removed the AA filter in order to reduce the problem of the extreme angle.
Dec 19, 2011 at 08:18 AM
kosmoskatten
Offline
Details
p.2 #4Ricoh GXR M module and NEX-5N review
I could easily trigger moiré on the M9 by doing a simple torture test: snapshot at the building across the street when blinds were down. Moiré would be present in most windows and vary with distance.

I did not find moiré to be a real problem or issue on the M9 in everyday use.

Dec 19, 2011 at 08:27 AM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.2 #5Ricoh GXR M module and NEX-5N review
kosmoskatten wrote:
I could easily trigger moiré on the M9 by doing a simple torture test: snapshot at the building across the street when blinds were down. Moiré would be present in most windows and vary with distance.

I did not find moiré to be a real problem or issue on the M9 in everyday use.



That's basically where I have seen it in examples. Buildings/architecture or pretty much any man made structures which contain a lot of high frequency detail. That's the same situation I occasionally ran into moire with the 5D, but to a lesser degree. Like you say, I doubt it would be an issue unless one shot this type of subject matter on a regular basis.

Just out of curiosity, have you tested your GXR with M module on the building across your street? I'm wondering if it's less of an issue on the GXR.
Dec 19, 2011 at 10:10 AM
kosmoskatten
Offline
Details
p.2 #6Ricoh GXR M module and NEX-5N review
Hah! Great minds think alike.

I was going to, as it is just outside my work room window. But, it is snowing, and dark. People have the blinds up. I'll try tomorrow if they are blind-siding me.
Dec 19, 2011 at 10:36 AM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.2 #7Ricoh GXR M module and NEX-5N review
kosmoskatten wrote:
Hah! Great minds think alike.

I was going to, as it is just outside my work room window. But, it is snowing, and dark. People have the blinds up. I'll try tomorrow if they are blind-siding me.


Ha ha. Cool...literally!
Dec 19, 2011 at 10:42 AM
douglasf13
Offline
Details
p.2 #8Ricoh GXR M module and NEX-5N review
Tariq Gibran wrote:
Sosua wrotePete: I'm not sure, but I think its a significant factor, for sure - will be really interesting when and if people start ripping the AA filters off their 5N's and 7's If the NEX-7 somehow magically became really compatible with wide's, sans-filter, it would be a real hit with this crowd!
I suspect there must be some software correction of moire and other artifacts going on even with the raws from the cameras which ship without AA filters so just ripping out the AA filter might be ugly. Also given the much improved performance of even the 5n over the NEX7 with rangefinder lenses, I doubt the sensor in the 7 would benefit as much. There is some other technical issue with the 7's sensor - lack of offset microlenses, smaller sensel size - holding it back.


MaxMax has been removing aa filters from DSLRs for years, and I've not heard of any software issues. According to Joakim "theSuede," Leica uses an IR filter that is still thicker than average, and its microlens efficiency and fill factor isn't anything special, either, so I'm betting that yanking the AA filter is the biggest difference maker.
Dec 19, 2011 at 11:01 AM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.2 #9Ricoh GXR M module and NEX-5N review
douglasf13 wrote:
Tariq Gibran wrote
Sosua wrotePete: I'm not sure, but I think its a significant factor, for sure - will be really interesting when and if people start ripping the AA filters off their 5N's and 7's If the NEX-7 somehow magically became really compatible with wide's, sans-filter, it would be a real hit with this crowd!
I suspect there must be some software correction of moire and other artifacts going on even with the raws from the cameras which ship without AA filters so just ripping out the AA filter might be ugly. Also given the much improved performance of even the 5n over the NEX7 with rangefinder lenses, I doubt the sensor in the 7 would benefit as much. There is some other technical issue with the 7's sensor - lack of offset microlenses, smaller sensel size - holding it back.
MaxMax has been removing aa filters from DSLRs for years, and I've not heard of any software issues. According to Joakim "theSuede," Leica uses an IR filter that is still thicker than average, and its microlens efficiency and fill factor isn't anything special, either, so I'm betting that yanking the AA filter is the biggest difference maker.


Yes, I remember when this started with the 5D and the hot rod example they have on their site looks rather chunky and full of artifacts - more than I have noticed with say the GXR M module.
http://www.maxmax.com/hot_rod_visible.htm
Dec 19, 2011 at 11:18 AM
Ulff
Offline
Details
p.2 #10Ricoh GXR M module and NEX-5N review
A really excellent review, I enjoyed reading it, thanks!
Dec 19, 2011 at 11:34 AM
michaelwatkins
Offline
Details
p.2 #11Ricoh GXR M module and NEX-5N review
Sean Reid / Reid Reviews today published a review of "Electronic Finder Cameras With Rangefinder Lenses". The first dozen paragraphs or so are entirely occupied with nomenclature where he goes to lengths to explain why he isn't using the term "Mirrorless cameras". His logic is sound but man he sure takes a long time getting to the point at times.

He's comparing the NEX-5N and GXR Mount A12; like most of us, he hasn't had access to the NEX-7. In part one of his review published today, there's little to nothing new that hasn't been discussed at length recently here. In part two, yet to be published, he gets beyond exteriors and ergonomics and nomenclature and will look at lenses known to be problematic with digital sensors which by his reckoning include all the Biogons, a number of CV lenses, and the Leica 18/3, 24/3.8 and 28/2.8. In his own torture test he'll be including the CV15, CV21/4, Zeiss 21/4.5 and CV 28/3.5.

On adapters for the NEX, he mentions Novoflex and the CV adapter; no hint about the Hawk. That's a shame, because the Hawk would provide some photographers with a compelling reason for choosing the NEX over the other regardless of other benefits. I do think I'll write to him about that.



Dec 19, 2011 at 11:38 AM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.2 #12Ricoh GXR M module and NEX-5N review
michaelwatkins wrote:
Sean Reid / Reid Reviews today published a review of "Electronic Finder Cameras With Rangefinder Lenses". The first dozen paragraphs or so are entirely occupied with nomenclature where he goes to lengths to explain why he isn't using the term "Mirrorless cameras". His logic is sound but man he sure takes a long time getting to the point at times.

He's comparing the NEX-5N and GXR Mount A12; like most of us, he hasn't had access to the NEX-7. In part one of his review published today, there's little to nothing new that hasn't been discussed at length recently here. In
...Show more →

In my opinion, Sean is one of the few well known reviewers that actually does a very thorough job with his reviews.
Dec 19, 2011 at 12:41 PM
douglasf13
Offline
Details
p.2 #13Ricoh GXR M module and NEX-5N review
Thanks for the shots, Sam. The thing I'm not wholly convinced of is whether these shots show the 5N having more apparent field curvature, or whether we're just seeing the usual detail difference between cameras with and without an AA filter at the center and the edges. Do the 5N edge crops get more blurry compared to center vs. the GXR edge crops compared to center?
Dec 19, 2011 at 12:57 PM
michaelwatkins
Offline
Details
p.2 #14Ricoh GXR M module and NEX-5N review
Tariq Gibran wrote:
In my opinion, Sean is one of the few well known reviewers that actually does a very thorough job with his reviews.


Agreed. I've found his lens examinations helpful.

That he sometimes is overly wordy on a specific point doesn't take away anything from what he writes. I've no real complaint - I'm not exactly stingy with words myself.
Dec 19, 2011 at 01:40 PM
douglasf13
Offline
Details
p.2 #15Ricoh GXR M module and NEX-5N review
Howdy, Sam. I had another quick question. Which adapter are you using on NEX? If you have one that focuses past infinity, it would be interesting to see how much past infinity you'd need to focus to sharpen up the 5N corners. Thanks!
Dec 19, 2011 at 03:15 PM
Sosua
Offline
Details
p.2 #16Ricoh GXR M module and NEX-5N review
Thanks guys:

Tariq- I've got a few shots with the Ricoh that did show pretty impressive moire on the distant city with the CV 15 (does that mean its really sharp?) which I emailed to Mike - i'll show some crops when I get home. I think the 16mp chip without AA will show less moire. I think however when moire does show up, a quick layer mask and desaturation gets rid of it easily.

Mike - great about Reids new review - i'm a suscriber and look forward to checking it out. From his existing GXR review however I recall him mainly using the GXR as a zone focus tool and I'm not sure how much time he spent working with the EVF and peaking - will good to see his impressions.

Doug - i'm using aFotodiox pro adapter which allows focus past infinity which does improve the 5N results a bit. Strange thing is the Summaron is less problematic on the 5N but the Nokton (which has the more significant field curvature) is the more usable lens on the GXR.

I do need to go past inifnity on 5N enough to mean distant central subject are slightly softer at F5.6 /8. Its workable, but the nice thing with the GXR is I can just dial in 5.6 and park it on the infinity stop and snap away.

With the field curvature thing, i'm not an expert of course, but the Sony does show the same depth of field in the centre which reduces is towards the edges of the frame, even at F8 - I'll try posting some full 'strips' which may show this off better - it is also compounded a little by the difference in acuity though.

Again, the Sony is actually fine with a few work arounds, just seems more 'fool proof' in getting consistent results with the GXR.

With better lenses of course (with less problematic designs and flat fields) these differences would be smaller but I still reckon the GXR would be better at the extremities.

Dec 19, 2011 at 03:47 PM
kosmoskatten
Offline
Details
p.2 #17Ricoh GXR M module and NEX-5N review
douglasf13 wrote:
Howdy, Sam. I had another quick question. Which adapter are you using on NEX? If you have one that focuses past infinity, it would be interesting to see how much past infinity you'd need to focus to sharpen up the 5N corners. Thanks!


I don't think it's quite that simple Douglas, and I can't see the bearing it has on the wide angle lenses. Are you talking about some very specific lenses that have this problem and that it could be somewhat remedied by focusing past infinity?

I thought it was due to the fact that field curvature that is present in the lenses are worsened by the NEX sensor. With that I mean, not corrected and that the sensor is not very forgiving for that lens "flaw". Until anyone can fully disclose how the sensor is built up on the NEX5n, and on the GXR we will have to judge them as we see them in practical use.

Sams test seems credible enough and if you have to go to more extreme lengths than that to improve the imaging from the NEX5n it is most definitely a waste of time - if better results can be had by means of normally operating another camera/sensor.

In my experience I have never seen a solution where focusing past "true" infinity of a lens has produced acceptable results, quite the opposite. Stopping down, yes, focusing past infinity no. Especially if you could and would have to focus some ways past infinity.

It sounds like backwards thinking when you have live view, to "misfocus" in order to produce acceptable images? How do you work that on the fly and for street shots?

I don't think you can make, say the 15/4.5, produce sharp non-smeared corners on the NEX no matter how you try. But if I missed something, please educate me.

In my book I find that if I can visually achieve focus where I want it on a live screen and the camera/lens combination fails to deliver a straight no nonsense output the way I like it, then it is flawed.

It is like when the M8 arrived and there were all sorts of problems that had to be addressed in both hardware (tinted, lens specific filters) and software correction to cope with problems that are due to the lack of innovative engineering to overcome the problems in the first place. The filters and software correction were made after the fact as a make shift solution.

I totally get that Sony is not to keen on going to extreme lengths to ensure that ALL existing glass from other manufacturers will look perfect on their sensor as long as their own look fine - with or without software processing involved. And that is probably key to why the NEX5N is a great camera, but not perfect in that regard. I am almost certain they never tried out any adapterd 12mm or 15mm lenses themselves on the NEX5n before release and now why would they? They made a perfectly good - even great - sensor as per their specs.

EDIT: sorry for the lengthy posting, I am quite tired and I seem to repeat myself a lot, but bear with me.
Also, I look forward to the first guy to rip the AA filter off the NEX5n - go Douglas go!
Dec 19, 2011 at 03:58 PM
kosmoskatten
Offline
Details
p.2 #18Ricoh GXR M module and NEX-5N review
Also, I think that with even better extreme wide angle lenses the GXR would be even more in favor of the NEX5n if it turns out to be an off set micro lens and/or AA-filter glass topping astigmatism thingy or whatever the problem seems to be that holds the NEX5n back that last little bit.
Dec 19, 2011 at 04:21 PM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.2 #19Ricoh GXR M module and NEX-5N review
Sosua wrote:
Tariq- I've got a few shots with the Ricoh that did show pretty impressive moire on the distant city with the CV 15 (does that mean its really sharp?) which I emailed to Mike - i'll show some crops when I get home. I think the 16mp chip without AA will show less moire. I think however when moire does show up, a quick layer mask and desaturation gets rid of it easily.



Thanks. Good info to know regarding the GXR and moire. Desaturation will not get rid of the moire artifact pattern, just the color so, depending on how bad it is - it's not a perfect solution.
Dec 19, 2011 at 05:27 PM
michaelwatkins
Offline
Details
p.2 #20Ricoh GXR M module and NEX-5N review
Sosua wrote:
Tariq- I've got a few shots with the Ricoh that did show pretty impressive moire on the distant city with the CV 15 (does that mean its really sharp?) which I emailed to Mike - i'll show some crops when I get home.


It is pretty impressive... you can see some also on a home on the near shore towards the right; and also affecting (minor) an antenna on that same side, slightly nearer in.

I wonder how the ZM18 would fare in the same conditions and subject? Same?


Dec 19, 2011 at 06:22 PM
FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister