first off, I never used micro 4/3, and my only exposure to mirrorless was a Sony NEX-7 for a brief time. But I see a mirrorless camera to supplement, if not replace, my DSLR system.
But while looking at different models, I think that if one wants compact size, the APS-C cameras are better options. Sure, they are still larger and heavier than comparable M4/3 counterparts, but then again they have larger sensors. More importantly, and I'm using the Sony system as a reference, should one want to upgrade to FF, you would have the option (and use some of the lenses too, as they share the same mount).
For myself, I think that my next mirrorless camera will probably be an APS-C mirrorless. Again, I'm not putting down M4/3 or anything, I'm sure there are some fantastic cameras and lenses. I'm just kind of thinking out aloud.
howard wrote:
first off, I never used micro 4/3, and my only exposure to mirrorless was a Sony NEX-7 for a brief time. But I see a mirrorless camera to supplement, if not replace, my DSLR system.
But while looking at different models, I think that if one wants compact size, the APS-C cameras are better options. Sure, they are still larger and heavier than comparable M4/3 counterparts, but then again they have larger sensors. More importantly, and I'm using the Sony system as a reference, should one want to upgrade to FF, you would have the option (and use some of the lenses too, as they share the same mount).
For myself, I think that my next mirrorless camera will probably be an APS-C mirrorless. Again, I'm not putting down M4/3 or anything, I'm sure there are some fantastic cameras and lenses. I'm just kind of thinking out aloud....Show more →
On the contrary we could also argue that in the long run m43 might be a better "crop" system than APS-C. While I currently use an APS-C mirrorless, in future I could easily see myself as having two types of mirrorless systems - an FF mirrorless as the main "large" system and the m43 as the small carry-everywhere system. Depending on how these systems develop over next few years, APS-C could be either the "best of both worlds" or the unwanted middle ground which is neither small enough to match m43 nor high enough quality to match FF.
I have 3 systems. FF Canon, for the TS-E lenses mainly; Leica M, because I'm a long time rangefinder guy, and m43. My usage is about 10% Canon, 30% Leica and 60% m43. m43 has all the quality I need (prints up to 30x40"), great lenses which often are better than Canon's, the best IBIS on the market and allows me to carry a whole outfit with two bodies and 5 or 6 lenses from 14-600 equiv. in a Domke 803.
The main problem with APS-C is that while the sensor is a little bigger than m43 and many bodies are no larger than the Olympus cameras I use, the lenses are as large as and often are FF in size, but have a longer equiv. focal length. All in all, the system is a lot larger. I've had 5 or 6 APS-C bodies since the 6mp Canon D60, and at this point it is the APS-C cameras that are unconvincing and don't have a future IMHO; certainly not in my usage/preference.
I think the biggest thing in favor of APS-C right now is the price. The barrier to entry into the FF world is still pretty high. APS-C on there other hand is priced very aggressively and is no more expensive than m43. Thus a lot of users think that if they can get a somewhat larger sensor for the same price as m43 then why not go for APS-C. However as FF gets even cheaper and m43 sensors get even better, APS-C might get squeezed from both ends.
I just spent 2 weeks in Alaska with an EM1, 12-40/2.8 and 40-150/2.8. Two high quality lenses that cover 24-300mm. Great traveling kit, fantastic IBIS, good IQ, no need for a tripod. I am never going back to APS-C. But, looking at the A7rII for a FF option.
galenapass wrote:
I just spent 2 weeks in Alaska with an EM1, 12-40/2.8 and 40-150/2.8. Two high quality lenses that cover 24-300mm. Great traveling kit, fantastic IBIS, good IQ, no need for a tripod. I am never going back to APS-C. But, looking at the A7rII for a FF option.
Good question. I am both but using u4/3 for travel. That is where it really shines for me. I guess I should say there is no way I will ever go back to APS-C for travel - to be more clear. I have a little over 1800 shots from Alaska, and I am finding that the OMD EM1 (plus EM5II) did a great job. This was my first major trip with u4/3 and I am really impressed with the number of keepers, and the IQ. Up until this point I was a little ambivalent about not taking a lager sensor, but now I am confident.
Good question. I think short term it does for sure. But if Canon can shrink down a DSLR Rebel, like the SL1/100D, even more, then there might be competition in the small interchangeable lens camera (S-SILC)market.
I'm taking credit for new terms...S-SILC....small single interchangeable lens camera. And when either MILC or S-SILC get smaller, SMILES - Small Micro (or Mirrorless) Interchangeable Lens Ensnaring System.
I think it does, as it's another option, and people like options. Personally, I always shoot wide open with short lenses, so my preferences are APS-C or FF for bokeh fun, but if I were a nature or sports photographer, I could see it being great as a more compact and cheaper way of getting reach. Of course, there are the superzoom compacts, but those come with their own compromises (as does all gear).
I don't like predicting the future, but I'd like to say Micro 4/3 has a future. I certainly hope to be using it in the future.
As mentioned earlier, APSC systems don't have much advantage over full frame mirrorless in terms of system size -- the lenses are quite large, even if the bodies are as compact as M43 bodies. Every time I entertain the thought of picking up an APSC body for adapted legacy lenses, I conclude I'd rather wait for secondhand full frame options to drop in price. A7 bodies are already getting really cheap. (...Or a mirrorless medium format from Fuji...)
Personally, I think it's great to have all the options we currently have. Everyone's got a different ideal balance between price/size/IQ balance. And I think Micro 4/3 has a strong and unique position.
If they can improve on the AF tracking, as I am sure they can (if Sony can do it, so can Olympus), there is a great future - especially for sport and wildlife shooters. Neither FF nor APS-C can make a 600/4 lens that is super-compact and super-light like the soon-to-be-released 300/4 PRO. With the 1.4x TC you get an equivalent focal length of 840mm at f5.6 in an ultra compact form that is completely hand-holdable. This would be a dream pair of lenses for shooting small birds and BIF.
I find APS-C mirrorless for me is the dead format unless you are a penny pincher looking for a bargain. The Sony APS-C mirrorless has a rather worthless lens selection compared to m43 and clearly the future for Sony mirrorless is FF (which is looking pretty awesome though some of the lenses have been a bit of a let down). Now Fuji is interesting in mirrorless APS-C and they do have a great suite of lenses for certain photography, but nothing as extensive as m43 - and Fuji certainly is pricey (at least as pricey as m43). Still I think Fuji has a strong case for a lot of photographers, especially the kind that hang around FM. And as far as the "going out of business" risk goes at least m43 has two companies compared to Fuji. Sony's APS-C will probably just waste away even if Sony goes strong.
But in the end APS-C is a "why bother" middle for me. The nice Fuji glass is pretty big compared to some wonderful and wonderfully small m43 primes. The Sony APS-C just doesn't have anything I see a point to compared to their own FF offering and any of the other mirrorless competition. The Sony FF is looking like it is going to be a great system.
So to me just go FF if you don't like m43 and Fuji's offering doesn't tickle you. But of course everyone has different things that are important to me, so I suspect my opinion is rather as worthless to others as the OP's (EDIT: Not trying to take a dig at the OP here, re-reading I think it sort of sounds that way - I just meant there are a lot of different camera systems because there are a lot of different photographers and what makes sense to one often doesn't to another - cheers!)
kwalsh wrote:
But in the end APS-C is a "why bother" middle for me. The nice Fuji glass is pretty big compared to some wonderful and wonderfully small m43 primes. The Sony FF is looking like it is going to be a great system.
I think you are 100% correct. The evidence clearly points to Sony making major strides selling their full frame mirrorless cameras. Further, Olympus and Panny have built up a very impressive system of micro 4/3rd equipment.
When out and about traveling, these 3 brands are by far, the most commonly seen in the mirrorless world.
Sony's recent efforts will only drive things even further in this direction, although the higher cost might be a mitigating factor.
at all the m43 fans saying APS-C is getting squeezed. It's ironic since m43 is losing marketshare faster than Canon and Nikon. Unfortunately for them, they are so wrong. APS-C is the single biggest interchangeable lens mount there is. Yes, Sony is not currently paying much attention to their APS-C lenses, but it hasn't had an effect on sales. In fact, that also holds true for Canon and Nikon, whose APS-C lineup (each) still dwarfs the mirrorless market. Even Sony's APS-C mirrorless is bigger than all of m43.
Having said that, I don't think either m43 nor APS-C have great futures. It's not that FF will completely displaced those format. It's just that smartphone and 1" sensors will make cropped sensors seem like a waste of time to most user, and most users are low end users who won't see the value in slightly better images when a smartphone + RX100 will do the job for most of their shooting. The market will shrink, and FF will survive as the pro and enthusiast preferred mount. It's also the market that spends the most money on glass and accessories. Sure, the lenses are much bigger but people who spend a lo of money tend not to care that much. Unfortunately for m43 and APS-C, their demographics are easily swayed by the convenience and cost savings of a smartphone or RX100. APS-C will stick around as the bargain mount for entry level users, but m43 is likely dead long term. The cropped sensor market has never suffered from lack of lenses as Canon and Nikon has demonstrated. m43's lens superiority over Sony's APS-C lineup won't matter. It never has. It never will. It's not an opinion. It's the plain objective fact.
I have never seriously considered M4/3 - it's just too small. As soon as the light drops those small sensors become challenged. Nice idea though, just not for me.
Re: some of the comments above, it'd be nice to see Sony build a simple, cost-effective, compact fullframe body aimed squarely at manual focus glass. Strip it down completely: on/off, ISO, shutter speed, focus peaking, 8-10fps, 1080p for those moments.
MarkRyan wrote:
As mentioned earlier, APSC systems don't have much advantage over full frame mirrorless in terms of system size -- the lenses are quite large, even if the bodies are as compact as M43 bodies. .
Then you get the likes of Arias saying that fullframe has little advantage over APS-C.But it does have an advantage and he and his ilk gloss over it.
Fuji could fit fullframe sensors into current bodies - didn't someone analyse XF glass and show it to be FF compatible? So yeah, size - Fuji's, although not big, could accommodate FF sensors - that'd be nice.
There is no way Fuji can issue another camera using that rehashed 16MP X-Trans without me buying a ticket to Japan to personally kick them in the balls. The X-T10 needs to be the end of the line for it.
Whether it does have a viable future I don't know, because I don't know if it's doing well enough in the marketplace for the manufacturers to survive with it.
I do know, though, that it should have a future, since it's probably the best balance between quality and size/weight, at least as long as you're buying into the better bodies and lenses.
I'm heavily invested in Olympus MFT (but also use Canon for birds and Sony for FF) and I see three weaknesses:
- continuous AF, but this is basically true for all mirrorless cameras
- noise at lower ISOs than the competition: I hope they find a way to alleviate this
- only 16mp: it's enough for most images, but if they can up it to 24mp, it would be great
Interesting perspectives, thanks for all the input.
To clarify: I really like some of the M4/3 designs, if nothing else, those cameras and lenses look exquisitely crafted. I am sure they produce high quality images too.
However, the enthusiast market is shrinking and highly competitive. All are squeezed (even DSLRs) from the bottom by smart phone and tablets -- it is now so common to the point of annoyance to see so many people with selfie sticks and large tablets to take pictures
Olympus as a company is not in good shape at all. Panasonic, with its other consumer products, will be around, but I think it remains to be seen how the market evolves and if they will stick it out. Sony as a company seems to be (at least for the moment) committed to FF mirrorless. That being the case, they will always be able to drag along APS-C if they want to (consumers of their APS-C products automatically have the ability to use their FF lenses). I personally think that APS-C mirrorless has better survivability than M4/3, though, really, I wish they all stick around to give us different choices.
Factually incorrect. Olympus as a company is doing very well. They are the industry leader in medical imaging. 80% of their business is in this field. Their share price has gone up almost 1000 yen in the past 12 months.