p.1 #1Olympus 17/1.8 vs Panasonic 15/1.7 vs Panasonic 20/1.7
Hi All,
I am currently using GX7 with kit lens and looking to add compact fast prime for day to day normal/low light shooting.
Based on your experience if you have to choose one, which one would you choose between Olympus 17/1.8, Panasonic 15/1.7 and Panasonic 20/1.7?
p.1 #2Olympus 17/1.8 vs Panasonic 15/1.7 vs Panasonic 20/1.7
I've owned all of them except the Panasonic 15mm.
The P20 is sharp but has unpleasant rendering. Some amazing pictures though of people using this lens so can't argue with some of their results. The noisy slowish feeling AF also was not a joy to use.
The O17 F1.8 has pleasing rendering but lacks a bit of micro contrast punch. Quick AF and its better as a portrait lens than a landscape lens.
Samples of the P15 looks similar to the P25F1.4 which is in my top 3 favorite lenses of all time.
p.1 #3Olympus 17/1.8 vs Panasonic 15/1.7 vs Panasonic 20/1.7
I've had all three. I loved the 20, got great pics with it, but sold after getting the PL25 as I greatly preferred the rendering, despite 40mm equivalent being my favorite focal length for a general purpose lens. The 20 was just a bit colder, clinical to my eye and the 25 more organic, warmer and punchier. The PL25 is a great lens and reminds me that great glass is where to spend.
I still have the 17/1.8 but is on long term loan to a friend. I like the size and MF damping is nice and sharpness seems more consistent across the frame vs the PL25, at least at wider apertures. But it seemed to lack punch of the PL25 - competent but no wow - and then I got the PL15, so I'm in no rush to get back from loan.
The PL15 I like as it is clearly in the PL25 and PL42.5 family in terms of rendering, thus making a nice prime kit with consistent look. Plus the build quality is very good and the wider focal length yields something close to 35mm in the 4k video crop mode on the GH4 (presumably on future Pany bodies as well). So if you shoot video, that is a consideration.
That being said, a new 20v2 for $299 is cheap for occasional use and I like the small profile (depth) compared to the 15 or 25.
p.1 #4Olympus 17/1.8 vs Panasonic 15/1.7 vs Panasonic 20/1.7
I like the PL15 a lot. It's not the sharpest lens wide open, but the rendering is similar to the PL 25 and PL 42.5, the build quality is great, it's small, AF is reasonably fast, and I love the aperture ring.
p.1 #5Olympus 17/1.8 vs Panasonic 15/1.7 vs Panasonic 20/1.7
itai195 wrote:
I like the PL15 a lot. It's not the sharpest lens wide open, but the rendering is similar to the PL 25 and PL 42.5, the build quality is great, it's small, AF is reasonably fast, and I love the aperture ring.
Well nothing is as sharp as the 42.5 of course! But I did want to comment that I find the 15 to be quite sharp wide open compared to the competition of modest sized lenses in that focal length. LensTip did give a fairly ridiculous review in which they measured the 15/1.7 to be as sharp as any other nearby focal length lens and then in their text said it wasn't sharp enough. And there is certainly variation both in lenses and perceptions of sharpness. But compared to the other options here the 15 is at least as sharp if not the sharpest of the bunch wide open in the center.
And to the OP, I responded to your same question over at mu-43. Good luck with your decision!
Oct 01, 2014 at 01:20 PM
savingspaces
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.1 #6Olympus 17/1.8 vs Panasonic 15/1.7 vs Panasonic 20/1.7
darrellc wrote:
I've had all three. I loved the 20, got great pics with it, but sold after getting the PL25 as I greatly preferred the rendering, despite 40mm equivalent being my favorite focal length for a general purpose lens. The 20 was just a bit colder, clinical to my eye and the 25 more organic, warmer and punchier. The PL25 is a great lens and reminds me that great glass is where to spend.
I still have the 17/1.8 but is on long term loan to a friend. I like the size and MF damping is nice and sharpness seems more consistent across the frame vs the PL25, at least at wider apertures. But it seemed to lack punch of the PL25 - competent but no wow - and then I got the PL15, so I'm in no rush to get back from loan.
The PL15 I like as it is clearly in the PL25 and PL42.5 family in terms of rendering, thus making a nice prime kit with consistent look. Plus the build quality is very good and the wider focal length yields something close to 35mm in the 4k video crop mode on the GH4 (presumably on future Pany bodies as well). So if you shoot video, that is a consideration.
That being said, a new 20v2 for $299 is cheap for occasional use and I like the small profile (depth) compared to the 15 or 25....Show more →
p.1 #7Olympus 17/1.8 vs Panasonic 15/1.7 vs Panasonic 20/1.7
Savingspaces - 43rumours site had a link to a reputable eBay seller at this price a few days ago. Just checked and listing is gone, but I've seen them for $299-$329 before. Seems like Panasonic or their distributors use eBay from time to time.
p.1 #8Olympus 17/1.8 vs Panasonic 15/1.7 vs Panasonic 20/1.7
I've been quite happy with my 20 f/1.7, I'd compare it to a nifty fifty. The AF isn't super fast, but it's fine for me because my E-M5 isn't great for tracking focus anyway. It doesn't have much in the way of character, but it's pretty sharp and decent global contrast. The size is the real draw for me, and it falls nicely between the 12 f/2 and 45 f/1.8. Probably my most used lens and I have no intentions of replacing it.
p.1 #9Olympus 17/1.8 vs Panasonic 15/1.7 vs Panasonic 20/1.7
17mm f/1.8 is my favorite m43 lens.
1. I love the field of view, much better than 20mm which is not wide enough for my tastes. This is the only field of view you ever need (unless you are doing sports photography or birding).
2. Has very little purple fringing on Olympus cameras. I did not like the purple fringing I got with the 14mm, and I hear on the internet that the 20mm also causes PF problems on Olympus cameras.
3. Very even center to corner sharpness when stopped down.
4. Center to corner sharpness is improved if you don't use the center focus point. This lens has a field curvature problem. Which you can work around or even take advantage of if you realize how it impacts your images.
5. Even wide open, whatever you focus on is sharp, but because of field curvature you cannot get a flat plane sharp all over when the lens is wide open. Stopped down to f/2.2 this improves a lot.
6. Yes the lens has poor micro-contrast which makes photos appear less sharp, but you can fix that by applying sharpening in Lightroom or Photoshop.
7. Lens also has poor macro-contrast, and the clarity slider in Lightroom helps here.
Overall, I agree this is not the greatest lens ever made because of field curvature and poor contrast.
On the other hand, I also see this lens as the best reason to buy Micro Four Thirds:
1. Do any APS-C DSLRs have a fast 35mm-equivalent prime? No they do not!
2. The Sony NEX 35mm-equivalent lens is very expensive and twice the size and weight.
3. With an Olympus body, you get IMAGE STABLIZATION with this lens, and no other camera system gives you that except for a Canon full frame body with the new 35mm-IS lens. Which actually sells for a pretty reasonable price, only $599 at Amazon, but with Canon Full Frame you are looking at a much bigger and heavier camera and you lose the advantages of live-view plus EVF which I really like, plus the improved accuracy of CDAF focusing.
p.1 #12Olympus 17/1.8 vs Panasonic 15/1.7 vs Panasonic 20/1.7
I also think the 17mm f1.8 lens is an excellent lens. I also own the 25mm f1.4, 75mm f1.8 and the 12-40mm and 35-100mm zooms, and the 150mm f2.0 (4/3 not m4/3) prime. The 17mm f1.8 is not outclassed by any of these lenses -- it's different. Excellent for environmental portraits or "street" photography. Wouldn't be my first choice for landscape, but I wouldn't hesitate to use it for landscape if it's what I had with me or on my camera at that time.
p.1 #13Olympus 17/1.8 vs Panasonic 15/1.7 vs Panasonic 20/1.7
Oh - I also owned the 20mm, but agree that I much prefer the look of the 25mm f1.4 . The 20mm is as sharper or sharper than the 25mm f1.4, but it lacks the presence or "look" of the 25mm and 17 mm lenses
OK it's not cheap if you include price in "equivalence"That's a mirrorless system, not a DSLR.
Also, the lens is more expensive bigger and heavier than the Olympus 17mm f/1.8, and it's not image stabilized.
If I had to stop using Olympus, I'd switch to Canon 6D with the 35mm f/2 IS lens. Which probably takes pretty good photos.
EOS M 22mm stm, yes its mirrorless but its one of the best lenses I've used and it came with a camera for only $250.
p.1 #15Olympus 17/1.8 vs Panasonic 15/1.7 vs Panasonic 20/1.7
The Canon 22mm F2 lens pancake is really the benchmark every other pancake mirrorless lenses should be judged. It's much better than the Panasonic 20mm F1.7 in speed and rendering. High micro contrast but still very pleasing.
p.1 #16Olympus 17/1.8 vs Panasonic 15/1.7 vs Panasonic 20/1.7
Thank you all! This has been very helpful discussion indeed. After going through replies and numerous photos, I have concluded to build all Panny kit with 15/25/42.5. Now have to decide whether to go for 15 or 25 first.