fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2014 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2014MP-E 65 now Discontinued

  
 
Adrian Jones
Offline

p.1 #1MP-E 65 now Discontinued
Hi all,

Been a while since I have posted here but thought I had better pass this info on to all. Just had to send my MP-E 65 lens in for repair and find that Canon no longer have some parts to repair this lens. Canon UK has confirmed that it has been discontinued even though there are still many for sale in various outlets, If you want a new one best to grab one whilst you can. I have asked Canon UK if there is a new lens in the pipeline and they have said that they will try to find out and let me know but at the moment there seems to be no replacement in the pipeline. If anyone has any info about a replacement then please share the info as I'm sure we would all like to know.

Edited to add the following info,

Canon UK has said that production of this lens ceased more than twelve years ago, this has been confirmed by more than one person from Canon UK. This means that even the lens that I purchased, I think in 2008, was already just about obsolete when I purchased it. Canon has stated that they will only guarantee to repair a lens for five to seven years after production finishes. They have stated that if a new one was bought today, should a problem arise then they would simply replace the lens for a period of one year from purchase date, after that you would be on your own with the possibility that you have a very expensive paper weight.


Adrian
Feb 24, 2014 at 10:18 AM
e6filmuser
Offline
Details
p.1 #2MP-E 65 now Discontinued
Adrian,

Thanks. I entered digital macro via Olympus m4/3. I was strongly considering the purchase of a Canon body and an MPE-65. As this electronically-controlled lens is now a potential liability, I would consider such a venture an expensive mistake.

Harold
Feb 25, 2014 at 02:22 AM
Adrian Jones
Offline
Details
p.1 #3MP-E 65 now Discontinued
Hi Harold,

It may be a possible liability but it is still at the top of the pile for high magnification macro shooting, combine the MP-E 65 with a 5D mk3 and without a shadow of a doubt it is an almost unbeatable combination both for IQ and for the convenience it provides.
The weak point in this lens seems to be the ribbon cable/electronic aperture assembly, Canon do seem to have spares for this at the moment but I don't know for how much longer. My lens was also suffering from wear, it was my main lens and had a great deal of use over the period of my ownership, it was always treated well and used carefully but wear it did and it seems that the parts to repair this wear are the ones no longer readily available now. My lens has lasted for about five years of daily use before the first problems arose, I don't know if that would be considered good, bad or average for an expensive lens. If I could afford it I would buy another in a heartbeat, don't let this news put you off buying one, the pluses of the lens still outweigh the downside in my opinion.

Adrian
Feb 25, 2014 at 04:38 AM
LCPete
Offline
Details
p.1 #4MP-E 65 now Discontinued
This is big news for macro shooters i have emailed Canon UK to find out more information will post on here if and when I hear back from them
I am a very keen macro shooter but I haven't got the MP E as I rarely go past 1:1 but still hoping that canon do bring out a replacement as it's a unique lens
Feb 26, 2014 at 10:27 AM
LCPete
Offline
Details
p.1 #5MP-E 65 now Discontinued
I've just had an email back from Canon UK they are still producing the MP E
That's great news
Feb 26, 2014 at 03:23 PM
Adrian Jones
Offline
Details
p.1 #6MP-E 65 now Discontinued
LCPete wrote:
I've just had an email back from Canon UK they are still producing the MP E
That's great news


If that is correct it is indeed great news but it is at odds with what I have been told. On another forum where I started a similar thread someone else has said they contacted Canon USA and they also said production had ceased some years ago but at present they do have parts for repairs at the moment.

My lens was returned wiith the following letter:

"Dear Sir/Madam

Thank you for forwarding your unit to the Canon Service Centre for examination.

Unfortunately we are unable to carry out the repair to your unit, as the parts required are no longer available for this particular model.

Canon retains spare parts for all our product ranges for five to seven years after the end of production and it is always with great regret when we have to inform our customers that we are unable to undertake a repair, due to lack of spare parts.

When we are aware that the retention period is coming to a close we will purchase as many spare parts as possible to enable us to offer a service to our customers for as long as possible.

Canon (UK) Ltd aims to provide a first class service to all its customers and we apologise for the disappointment and inconvenience caused and are sorry that we can be of no further assistance on this occasion.

Yours sincerely



Canon Imaging Group
Service Centre Administration."

Canon is giving out some very confusing information, I am beginning to question if anyone at Canon actually knows anything at all about photography and the products that they thenselves make.


Feb 26, 2014 at 03:48 PM
LCPete
Offline
Details
p.1 #7MP-E 65 now Discontinued
I see what you mean Adrian that is confusing
Im at work posting using my phone so can't link the email but it basically just said that the MP E is still in production
Feb 26, 2014 at 04:10 PM
LCPete
Offline
Details
p.1 #8MP-E 65 now Discontinued
By the way Adrian does that mean that your lens is broken not repairable I hope not
Feb 26, 2014 at 04:12 PM
Adrian Jones
Offline
Details
p.1 #9MP-E 65 now Discontinued
Certainly is confusing Pete, I now cannot help but wonder how truthful Canon is being about other lenses in their range, what else are they not telling us and how many of the lenses that are still freely available to purchase new are actually discontinued and with a limited support time. I think we all deserve some honest answers from Canon.
Feb 26, 2014 at 04:17 PM
Adrian Jones
Offline
Details
p.1 #10MP-E 65 now Discontinued
LCPete wrote:
By the way Adrian does that mean that your lens is broken not repairable I hope not


It still works Pete but mechanically its not good, magnification ring gets lose then stiff and produces a scrachy sort of sound along with a pinging as if something is catching internally. There was also a large scuff mark on one of the internal elements that could only have occured when it was being worked on. They said to send it back in to get the scuff removed, I did that yesterday, had confirmation that had arrived this morning and then an email that it was on its way by midday, still don't know if it will be usable. :-( Will find out one way or the other when it arrives back tomorrow. I don't think I would trust it if I needed to record something important or if I was going to go out shooting for a day where I had to travel or hike a long way to get to where my subjects were lurking, just wouldn't be worth going far to have it fail on me at the critical moment. I will almost certainly get a new one as soon as I can, its the best lens I have ever owned.
Feb 26, 2014 at 04:31 PM
LCPete
Offline
Details
p.1 #11MP-E 65 now Discontinued
Yes Adrian it's pretty poor on Canons part
I think that your information is most likely more accurate than mine as you got a proper letter from the service department I just got a one line standard response saying that the lens was still in production
I hope that your lens turns out ok but the way it looks another spare is probably a good idea
Feb 26, 2014 at 05:31 PM
LCPete
Offline
Details
p.1 #12MP-E 65 now Discontinued
I seriously thought about getting the MP E but to be honest I wouldn't use it very much I mainly do close ups up to 1:1 rather than the real close stuff
I did try the lens my friend let me have a go but I found it tricky to use my hands are not steady enough!
Feb 26, 2014 at 05:35 PM
Adrian Jones
Offline
Details
p.1 #13MP-E 65 now Discontinued
LCPete wrote:
I seriously thought about getting the MP E but to be honest I wouldn't use it very much I mainly do close ups up to 1:1 rather than the real close stuff
I did try the lens my friend let me have a go but I found it tricky to use my hands are not steady enough!


I too take quite a few shots at 1:1 with both the 100L and 180L, the 180 being my preferred lens for most subjects at that magnification, it also takes the 1.4x converter well with minimal hit to IQ. Having said that the MP-E is by far my favourite macro lens, I just find it much more useful as it allows much smaller subjects to be imaged easily. I have actually got hold of another MP-E now, I was lost without one, so hopefully will be able to carry on with the larger than life shots for a good few years yet. One of the first shots from my new lens from when I tested it out this afternoon.....




Dicyrtomina saundersi par Adrian Jones, on ipernity

Adrian
Feb 27, 2014 at 03:05 PM
LCPete
Offline
Details
p.1 #14MP-E 65 now Discontinued
Excellent shot Adrian looks like the new lens is a good one
Feb 27, 2014 at 09:14 PM
Nass
Offline
Details
p.1 #15MP-E 65 now Discontinued
Fyi - Canon "official" response at http://extreme-macro.co.uk/lenses/ (Katie Appleton, media person for Canon Europe)
Mar 10, 2014 at 08:01 AM
bladesofgrass
Offline
Details
p.1 #16MP-E 65 now Discontinued
A shame since I, like many macro enthusiasts moved to Canon specifically for this lens. I have unfortunately found both the quality of the lens itself and their customer service to be less than desirable. Since my move to Canon 5 years ago I've been through 3 mpe lenses, 2 have failed due to humidity causing problems with the electronic coupling with the diaphragm and another due to problems with the contacts between lens and body. Also been through 4 MT-24 EX units. When repairs take between 1 and 3 months for even basic repairs there's a tipping point in customer satisfaction. A move away from the mpe along with its tendency to have problems would spell a move for myself and probably others. I look at the Canon policy and then I look at a company like Pentax that provides support and compatibility for legacy lenses and it is quite frustrating that they are neither listening to their customers nor following good business practices.

In stock doesn't mean that it's still in production though...
Mar 10, 2014 at 02:58 PM
e6filmuser
Offline
Details
p.1 #17MP-E 65 now Discontinued
That confirms my distrust of the electrical operation. Also, a lens in stock for a decade could have problems with lubricants drying out.

You would think that third party lens manufacturers, such as Sigma, Zeiss or Tamron would have come up with a mechanical alternative by now.

Harold
Mar 11, 2014 at 02:12 AM
DQE1.0
Offline
Details
p.1 #18MP-E 65 now Discontinued
Based on the heavy use of my MP-E lens (over 200,000 photos without problems), and being unwilling to be without this unique lens, I decided to buy a backup copy.

I can't make any sense out of a major company like Canon producing 12+ years of inventory at once! For example, I have read that they make their 1200mm telephoto lens only on demand, one-at-a-time.

The date codes on my two copies apparently show that they are being manufactured shortly before they are sold, as I would expect:

My older MP-E lens, purchased in August 2007, has a date code of UV0700, which implies a manufacturing date of July, 2007.

My backup copy, just acquired, has a date code of UB1103, which implies a manufacturing date of November, 2013.

Thus, it appears that Canon produces these lenses shortly before they are sold, as one would expect for a company that is experienced in inventory management. I speculate that the UK Canon customer service representative saw the 2002 copyright date in the lens manual and perhaps they concluded that they haven't been made since that date (2014-2002 = 12 years). Or, perhaps they confused the lens initial marketing date with each lens' manufacturing date?

The only new features I would personally like to see in the MP-E would be a smaller lens barrel diameter near the front of the lens, and a revised magnification range of about 0.5X to at least 4X, all without losing image quality, of course.
Mar 15, 2014 at 04:04 PM
e6filmuser
Offline
Details
p.1 #19MP-E 65 now Discontinued
DQE1.0 wrote:
I can't make any sense out of a major company like Canon producing 12+ years of inventory at once! For example, I have read that they make their 1200mm telephoto lens only on demand, one-at-a-time.


I don't know whether this justifies it for the MPE, however, there can be considerable commitment of the most skilled staff to the production of some lenses. I have in mind that, when Tamron made film lens in the 1980s, their senior lens maker would spend three days polishing the front of the front element of the 300mm f 2.8 and then another three days polishing the back of it.

Harold
Mar 16, 2014 at 03:16 AM
Adrian Jones
Offline
Details
p.1 #20MP-E 65 now Discontinued
An update: Not 100% sure where or how to start this but here goes..... I had a phone call from Canon UK yesterday about my MPE 65, much to my surprise the chap from Canon said he was ringing as he had found out that I had a problem with my lens and that Canon had not been able to fully repair it to their usual high standard. He said if I could return my lens to Canon once again he would try to get it replaced with a brand new copy of the lens, I can tell you that really took the wind out of my sails, I never expected Canon to do that for me.

He also corrected the information I had been given earlier by several people from Canon, he says that the MPE is still a current lens and will remain so for a while yet as far as he knew. There are some parts however that are now discontinued or unavailable, such as those that were required to do a full repair on my lens. He also confirmed that the MPE has been manufactured more recently than twelve years ago too, he seemed more clued up on the lens that the previous people I had spoken to.

That's about all I can add at the moment, the lens should be available for some time yet and Canon does plan on giving full support in one way or another as I have found out.

I tried to find out if a new version was on the horizon but could not get a definitive answer beyond new lenses are being developed, I don't know if one of these will be a replacement for the wonderful MP-E 65.

Adrian
Mar 22, 2014 at 04:05 PM
FM ForumsMacro & Still LifeJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister