Why would anyone buy a Harley ... you had to work on them more than you rode them and they'd leave you stranded more than a Honda ever would. Sometimes things change, sometimes not. If ASP shows to be buggy, etc. ... well then, that would be the "not". But a peek under the hood for a ride isn't the end of the world.
That being said, there doesn't seem to be an obvious way to separate RAW from JPG like in Bridge. Having Noise Ninja built in is interesting (never used NN before). Doesn't seem to have an "auto advance" when culling (haven't found it yet). Keystroke commands seem easy enough so far, but it takes one to cull/label/flag/rate, one to advance.
But, I think the thing to remember is that for those who DON'T LIKE ACR/LR ... it's worth a peek @ looking into. If you DO LIKE ACR/LR ... likely not much to see (except the addition of layers/NoiseNinja/possible performance diff) and you should stick with ACR/LR. As mentioned earlier, I don't see this as an LR Killer, just a possible option for those who don't like ACR/LR.