Re: Will a wide Cokin-P holder vignette on a 24mm TSE (shifte...
I\'m not familiar with the Cokin products so I can\'t comment on them. The Lee Fouldation holder is for 100 x 150 filters. I just did this test. Using a 82 to 77mm step-down ring and a standard (not wide angle) 77mm Lee adapter to the Lee holder - no vignetting at f3.5 and no vignetting on vertical tilt. It would only vignette on horizontal shift (i.e. shift for pano\'s - etc.). The vignetting in the horizontal position is due to the build up area of the filter holder on the left and right. You could remove layers & reduce this on the Lee holders.
I use the filter holders as opposed to hand holding to free my hands for other functions, saves scratching and wear on filters and to be able to use the DOF button to read the position of the filters.
BTW - when you see the IQ of the 24II - you won\'t want to use the other sub par lighter weight lenses - just carry the weight - it\'s worth it.
Nov 21, 2009 at 11:30 AM
Previous versions of mMontag's message #7802082 « Will a wide Cokin-P holder vignette on a 24mm TSE (shifted) or a 21mm ZE? »
