JimBuchanan wrote: Mr.Burns wrote:
The first one kinda reminds me of a LensBaby shot.
Interesting thread, and I appreciate and respect what all has been said here in the effort to get the best lens quality for the cheapest price.
The Canon digital EOS cameras evolved as the mainstream \"alt\" platform for non-Canon lenses, primarily due to the lack of IQ in Canon EF wide angle lenses, and the favorable short EF mount register compared to other lens mounts.
Am I correct in hearing, in this thread and others like this, that the FD line of wides is better than the EF offerings? This is not what I\'ve learned and experienced. Yes, the 50L and 85L class lenses seem to be roughly equivalent between the FD and EF versions, with excellent IQ. The Canon teles are reported to be excellent. However, the wides are thought to be lackluster with quite significant field curvature and other CA aberrations. Traits that are concealed by the shallow depth of field, close range, and B&W images on LCD monitors, exampled on these forum threads.
“Lens babies” like, maybe an appropriate adjective to use, due to the apparent sharpness/out of focus, in the wide angle FD lenses? No?
Jim,
I think the important thing is enjoyment/cost ratio here. I openly admit that my knowledge of machining tools and practices outweigh my knowledge and abilities to be able to fully analyze the various lens attributes revealed in any given photograph. These FD lenses can be obtained cheaply....much cheaper than their EF counterparts in the majority of cases...and I really enjoy the challenge of converting and \"rediscovering them\" so to speak.
Threads like this one serve as a helpful guide in showcasing and picking out potential conversion candidates. Critical analysis is valuable indeed; but it does not always tell the full story. As we all know, this is due to limited test samples and testing errors and inconsistencies.
In the end, if I enjoy the pics these lenses help me to take I am delighted. If sharing my experiences can help others find enjoyment in these lenses as well, then that is an added bonus.
Nov 21, 2009 at 08:51 AM
Previous versions of pengland's message #7801697 « Yet another hidden gem? »
