You\'ve just never been able to explain why Modern Photography\'s multiple-sample tests of these lenses show the Tamron to be the superior lens more in ways than one, yet you maintain that it is not even close. I choose to believe Modern Photography\'s evaluation, and my experience with two samples of the Tamron have led me to that conclusion. Your conclusions do not coincide in the least. So, you tell me; why does this smell fishy?
You\'ve just never been able to explain why Modern Photography\'s multiple-sample tests of these lenses show the Tamron to be the superior lens more ways that one, yet you maintain that it is not even close. I choose to believe Modern Photography\'s evaluation, and my experience with two samples of the Tamron have led me to that conclusion. Your conclusions do not coincide in the least. So, you tell me; why does this smell fishy?
Nov 15, 2009 at 10:31 PM
Previous versions of cogitech's message #7780471 « The Tamron SP 17/3.5 Thread »
