It really depends on how you approach the matter.
Based on objective criteria for image quality, probably not.
The comparison on phillipreeve shows this quite clearly.
If autofocus is a must, the AF-S 28mm f/1.4 E is likely the better choice.
Not only in terms of autofocus, but also in terms of the objective criteria for good image quality.
If AF is a non-factor, then the Thypoch Simera gives you a 28mm f/1.4 that, despite its compact size, is definitely nothing to sneeze at.
It’s clearly superior to the AF 28/1.4 D in many aspects of optical aberration control, and—despite the subjective nature of this criterion—it’s also one of the best 28mm f/1.4 lenses currently on the market in terms of bokeh, costing at most one-third the price of a new lens.
But of course, that doesn’t change the fact that the AF 28/1.4 D is a very special lens with a touch of vintage rendering that isn’t found in current competing products.
It’s also relatively rare, was far ahead of its time, and thus enjoys something of a cult status; so if a buyer is primarily interested in these criteria—including the vintage touch in the rendering—then there are few alternatives.
Given its rarity and cult status, it’s also likely to hold its value very well if cared for properly, with the potential to even increase in value slightly over time.
Sep 04, 2026 at 10:26 AM
Previous versions of Vento's message #17100652 « 28mm f1.4D the wide Noct »
