Switch back and forth between the 25600 image and the 6400 image and you know where to look.
What do you guys think about this. Am i seeing ghosts, or do we have a 5D mark II like problem?
It might be the processing or firmware. Didnīt DPR had a production R6 only (but no final R5)?
I compared the ISO 12800 shot of DPR from the link above with Gordon Laings two ISO 12800 shots of the final production R5. The DPR shot shows clear visible banding if the gradient curves are rased. But I can not see any banding in Gordon Liangs night shots.
DPR states these images are from their production R5. They had the R6 first and that is why the review came out first but even in that review they said they had just received their production R5 and would be working away on the review for it.
Agreed, I just threw that jpeg into LR and cranked up exposure 3 stops and can't see any.
May be related to what shutter mode was used??
Although I also downloaded the DPR 6400 shots and cranked its exposure, played around with dehaze to extremes and don't really see the banding in that file either.
So maybe it really is only showing itself at the real high-ISO??
---------------------------------------------
Ralph Conway wrote: photoin.nyc wrote:
He has this astro shot and I don't see any signs of banding at all.
Switch back and forth between the 25600 image and the 6400 image and you know where to look.
What do you guys think about this. Am i seeing ghosts, or do we have a 5D mark II like problem?
It might be the processing or firmware. Didnīt DPR had a production R6 only (but no final R5)?
I compared the ISO 12800 shot of DPR from the link above with Gordon Laings two ISO 12800 shots of the final production R5. The DPR shot shows clear visible banding if the gradient curves are rased. But I can not see any banding in Gordon Liangs night shots.
DPR states these images are from their production R5. They had the R6 first and that is why the review came out first but even in that review they said they had just received their production R5 and would be working away on the review for it.
This is 6400 only. In ISO 6400 the DPR files doenīt show banding, too.
When I had the 5D IV I had a similar issue but it was visible only when shooting full frame dark scenes (astro). It was showing even at ISO 100 when the file was pushed above 2 stops. It was hardly visible if the shot contained highly lit spots in comparison to the rest of the frame.
I still hope that whatever we're seeing right now it's just a firmware maturity issue and the production model is ok.
This is 6400 only. In ISO 6400 the DPR files doenīt show banding, too.
Maybe, you weren't as brutal
This is what I got:
LEFT: DPR and RIGHT: Cameralabs
Jul 23, 2020 at 10:14 AM
Previous versions of photoin.nyc's message #15292079 « R5 banding in high iso shots? »
