gdanmitchell wrote: mttran wrote:
Lifting 4 stops clearly showed banding that would show in a print.
\"... would show in a print?\" How much printing do you actually do, mttran?
How many times i have to repeat this sample.
I think we reached that threshold long ago. You continue to produce - along with a few other folks - test images that, ahem, \"prove\" that 5D2 noise banding is the Terrible Awful Scourge of Photography That Cannot Be Denied. Meanwhile, lots of other folks go on making pretty darn fine photographs with the camera, shake their heads, and wonder about this obsession with an issue that isn\'t an issue at all in actual photographs.
You can post this a thousand times and it won\'t prove that my photographs are deficient due to 5D2 noise banding. And I can reply a thousand times pointing this out and you\'ll still believe I\'m, well, I\'m not sure what you think... but I\'m sure that you won\'t believe me.
It becomes pretty pointless, doesn\'t it?
Let\'s be real gentlement
Now that is a fine idea...
Dan
Dan, please don\'t quote someone else\'s words into mine...reader know how to read well and really don\'t need your help to understand mine. So, don\'t distort my msg. Read again if you still don\'t get what i wrote. Ok, let\'s have a good holiday break, Dan.
Take care
Dec 26, 2011 at 01:46 PM
Previous versions of mttran's message #10194659 « 5DC vs 5D2 colors? 5DC better? »
