fredmiranda.com Login

which lens has the most 3D POP?

  
 
raminolta
Offline
Details
p.97 #1which lens has the most 3D POP?
I can't say it looks flat. I can't say it's a good representation of the 3D POP either; like what I have seen in some photos in the past that have impressed me.


j4nu wrote:
raminolta wroteHonestly, the background is very busy and the bokeh is very non-smooth. This image is doing very bad in convincing people to buy the lens with which it was taken.

While 3D pop has a strong connection with wide aperture shots and blurred backgrounds, this doesn't tell the whole story. This image is an example. It's horrible. It due to the type of bokeh.

j4nu wroteSo, I've run into this image (not mine) by chance, while checking out Simeras reviews at:
https://opticallimits.com/nikon/nikon-z/thypoch-simera-28mm-f-1-4-z-review/

https://photos.smugmug.com/Thypoch-Simera-28mm-f14-Z/i-mVgbkZK/0/KTfKscV6W7GbfzbdWVHsfnB35tf96ZQ5rWVV2Ckg3/O/DSC_2094.jpg

I think this is one of the better recent examples of what I call 3D pop .
Ooops, maybe I wasn't clear in my post.
I only posted this picture because it shows what my brain / eyes recognize as 3D pop.

Do you agree or is it completely flat for you?


Nov 21, 2025 at 01:18 PM
philip_pj
Offline
Details
p.97 #2which lens has the most 3D POP?
What usually happens is that the photographer recalls the scene well, often vividly. This colors his judgment on the level of depth in the ensuing imagery. Get a woman to look at it. Not joking, they see (much) better than most men.
Nov 21, 2025 at 01:27 PM
cbass
Offline
Details
p.97 #3which lens has the most 3D POP?
I think we may need to consider if this is a subject matter issue. If our pictures were of attractive and young women (or men) with minimal cloths or nudes would anybody be looking for 3D pop? I am not convinced they would be, but instead focus on the subject matter itself. Ask not if the subject in my photo has pop--ask if your subject is willing to pop off some cloths for your photo.
Nov 21, 2025 at 03:40 PM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.97 #4which lens has the most 3D POP?
Jonas B wrote:
Jonas B wrote:
Earlier quoteNo Z-axis but an image taken with the second lens (is that a Summilux?) will have less finer details in the midzone. That may give other impression than the same subject taken with the first image (probably another Leica lens) as it will be sharper across the image. Similar but very much less pronounced than the Revuenon image we saw earlier (page 90 post #20).
j4nu wrote:
Earlier quoteThanks for the explanation.
I think my gripe is with "very much less pronounced".
Unless we're talking about lenses on the extreme (like the Revuenon), it's simply difficult (for my at eyes at least) to notice a slight dip in MTF around midframe when shooting non-test targets...

So, is the claim that lens sharpness / resolving power *across the frame* contributes to 3D pop?
It's all subjective as we know, and as I claimed already I favor blur as one of the most contributing factors, but in my case the area outside the focus target (which I want to pop) will simply be blurred too much for MTF to have any effect IMHO.

I don't know, maybe I need to see a non-extreme example to believe ...
Well, maybe not so much an explanation as a possible take on it.

Yes, "very much (less) pronounced" is a problem.
I once saved money and bought he Leica Summilux-M 35/1.4 pre FLE. It was a wonderful lens and I got several beautiful images using it. But the stupid lens wasn't able to render a flat target sharp from border to border. Big midzone dip.
The problem was visible in medium large and large prints. The MTF-value were pretty much looking like thos RustyBug posted a while ago (was it a quiz and if so, where are the answers?).
...Show more →

Wasn't a quiz, per se ...

For info, it is the M 24 Summilux and the M 24 Elmarit.

My .02 on the MTF's (can't confirm) is that (dang article I can't find) Leica's ethos to develop the scene depth had them, intentionally putting in that mid-Zone dip ... so the transition from A > B has a rapid reduction in fine detail, and then the return to higher MTF in Zone C provides this "looking over a valley" kind of presentation, and if you're subject is in Zone A, then the Zone B space falls off before picking up again in Zone C.

The Elmarit is then designed got have that "flatter" corner to corner, with a more gradual transition across A / B / C. Granted, this are X / Y axis, not Z axis graphs, but (going back to my CoC multiplier), they can "carry through" into the scene. Again, only exists in my head, but it kind jives with my experience / observations, of sorts.
Nov 21, 2025 at 05:52 PM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.97 #5which lens has the most 3D POP?
j4nu wrote:
I've never actually played with selective sharpening and de-sharpening in order to induce that 3d effect. But maybe with enough skill and care it can indeed be used towards that purpose.


Guaranteed that this indeed can be done.

The key / trick is to do it with a degree of judiciousness that it transitions naturally in concert with other visual cues of the scene ... otherwise, you can wind up with that fake look ... and a host of other tells, that tips your hand.

Given the complexity of the composition, it can be a labor of love, and with as many times as I've done it, and seen others attempt it ... few folks actually do it well enough that the tells can't be discerned by a trained eye.


As mentioned a few times throughout this thread ... the old thread had the A : B lens difference, and then the PP editing was done to make them "very close" via post.

So, here again ... absolutely, it can be done. But, it takes an earnest skillset to do it well. The basis being rooted in the understanding of visual physiological response cues. Just throwing some blur at the BG ... not quite the same thing.

Btw, your point about incorporating BOTH sharp / de-sharp is an integral aspect of push / pull that affords better presentation than in one direction alone. Using the film plane as the starting point for fore / aft work. Doing it to the level that represents a natural optic ... easier said than done, often times.
Nov 21, 2025 at 06:00 PM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.97 #6which lens has the most 3D POP?
Jonas B wrote:
j4nu wroteOk, that makes sense. But did that drop in sharpness of Leica Summilux-M 35/1.4 pre FLE, contribute to the depth of the image?
I just don't see how one could utilize the MTF graph (which goes from the center to each side) to compose an image in order to evoke more depth from it... Sorry, maybe I'm just ignorant .
If it was possible to frame in a way so the outer zones could be cropped away (so they didn't sharpen up again) it didn't hurt. If having the subject close to the border and angled it sometimes made a mess of things where the blur first increased and later decreased. Many times it didn't matter and many images were beautiful.

No, the MTF is useless for this. What it tells me is that we have to check for field curvature, much like tsdevine says. The ZM 35/1.4 is an example of a lens with a bad shaped curvature when
...Show more →

+1 for Fred's FC GIF's.

So, maybe my CoC x MTF mental gymnastics is more like CoC x MTF x FC (conceptual impact, not literal math).
Nov 21, 2025 at 06:09 PM
OregonSun
Offline
Details
p.97 #7which lens has the most 3D POP?
MC Macro Revuenon 28mm f/2.8


Nov 21, 2025 at 06:38 PM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.97 #8which lens has the most 3D POP?
RustyBug wrote:
…your point about incorporating BOTH sharp / de-sharp is…


This kind of stuff is standard practice among people who understand post-processing, as is adding controlled vignetting, adjusting the curves differently throughout the image, color balance, and saturation in various of the image, and more.
Nov 21, 2025 at 10:55 PM
Jonas B
Offline
Details
p.97 #9which lens has the most 3D POP?
j4nu wrote:
I'm happy we agree about MTF usefulness in this case .
I've never actually played with selective sharpening and de-sharpening in order to induce that 3d effect. But maybe with enough skill and care it can indeed be used towards that purpose.
When it comes to field curvature, I actually think it can help with 3d pop. Given it's the right kind of curvature for the scene, so that it increases the blur around the subject, but not excessively (i.e. like a toy lens).[...]


Of course... "de-sharpening" sounds so much better than my "blurring".
I think the excessive effects are for fun only but also something you get tired of quickly.
Nov 22, 2025 at 01:49 AM
j4nu
Offline
Details
p.97 #10which lens has the most 3D POP?
RustyBug wrote:
j4nu wroteI've never actually played with selective sharpening and de-sharpening in order to induce that 3d effect. But maybe with enough skill and care it can indeed be used towards that purpose.
Guaranteed that this indeed can be done.

The key / trick is to do it with a degree of judiciousness that it transitions naturally in concert with other visual cues of the scene ... otherwise, you can wind up with that fake look ... and a host of other tells, that tips your hand.

Given the complexity of the composition, it can be a labor of love, and with as many times as I've done it, and seen others attempt it ... few folks actually do it well enough that the tells can't be discerned by a trained eye.

As mentioned a
...Show more →

Right, so if we knew how to do it exactly in post, we'd probably also knew what scene and with which lens to shoot .

Still, I think MTF doesn't really help with this, one of the reasons already mentioned by others being that it's calculated/measusred at inifinity with center focus...

BTW, is there another "old" thread about this? Do you have a link to that post, as it sounds really interesting?
Nov 22, 2025 at 04:00 AM
 


Search in Used Dept. 

j4nu
Offline
Details
p.97 #11which lens has the most 3D POP?
raminolta wrote:
I can't say it looks flat. I can't say it's a good representation of the 3D POP either; like what I have seen in some photos in the past that have impressed me.

j4nu wrote
raminolta wroteHonestly, the background is very busy and the bokeh is very non-smooth. This image is doing very bad in convincing people to buy the lens with which it was taken.

While 3D pop has a strong connection with wide aperture shots and blurred backgrounds, this doesn't tell the whole story. This image is an example. It's horrible. It due to the type of bokeh.

j4nu wroteSo, I've run into this image (not mine) by chance, while checking out Simeras reviews at:
https://opticallimits.com/nikon/nikon-z/thypoch-simera-28mm-f-1-4-z-review/

https://photos.smugmug.com/Thypoch-Simera-28mm-f14-Z/i-mVgbkZK/0/KTfKscV6W7GbfzbdWVHsfnB35tf96ZQ5rWVV2Ckg3/O/DSC_2094.jpg

I think this is one of the better recent examples of what I call 3D pop .
Ooops, maybe I wasn't clear in my post.
I only posted this picture because it shows what my brain / eyes recognize as 3D pop.

Do you agree or is it completely flat for you?


Well, I guess that's the most common impression this picture evokes here, as there were no other comments.
Which to me is very strange, because, in my eyes, it's one of the best recent examples of the effect I've run into.
Unfortunately, this further proves the futility of the effort put in this thead ...
Nov 22, 2025 at 04:13 AM
vashadobri
Offline
Details
p.97 #12which lens has the most 3D POP?
philip_pj wrote:
...Related - guess where your visual cortex focuses first? Hint - it's not the far corners so beloved of reviews and APO enthusiasts. The photo lives or dies on its impact zones: the colorful, contrasty, bright and identifiable data in or near to the middle 'magic donut'. What is it? It's the circle that is formed with a radius of 12mm (known as the short edge).

Cooke knew this a hundred years ago, all their lenses conform to it. So do for example, the Simeras and many Chinese lenses. The fall-off in focus, contrast and muted color in corners are
...Show more →


Regarding your thoughts/expertise on the influence of film aesthetics on lens design, it seems to me that designers of the Hawk's VantageOne and VantageOne4 line were particularly guided by similar ideas and choices. So, if you are by any chance unfamiliar with them (and perhaps also considering the interesting 3D/depth topic of this thread), it might be not entirely in vain to take a look at the way they approached fulfilling their directional preferences:

https://www.vantagefilm.com/file/edee/downloads/optics/1x-spherical-lenses-made-by-hawk/vantage-one-t1-additional-info.pdf

https://hawklondon.com/optics/vantageone/

(Ron Howard's recent beautiful "Eden" was, as it seems, shot entirely with VantageOne lenses

https://www.imdb.com/title/tt23149780/
Nov 22, 2025 at 05:06 AM
j4nu
Offline
Details
p.97 #13which lens has the most 3D POP?
RustyBug wrote:
Jonas B wrote
j4nu wroteOk, that makes sense. But did that drop in sharpness of Leica Summilux-M 35/1.4 pre FLE, contribute to the depth of the image?
I just don't see how one could utilize the MTF graph (which goes from the center to each side) to compose an image in order to evoke more depth from it... Sorry, maybe I'm just ignorant .
If it was possible to frame in a way so the outer zones could be cropped away (so they didn't sharpen up again) it didn't hurt. If having the subject close to the border and angled it sometimes made a mess of things where the blur first increased and later decreased. Many times it didn't matter and many images were beautiful.

No, the MTF is useless for this. What it tells me is that we have to check for field curvature, much like tsdevine says. The ZM 35/1.4 is an example of a lens with a bad shaped curvature when used with cameras having a thick sensor stack. That curvature doesn't help at all. Some other lenses may have a field curvature bending in the other direction (making the background at the sides more blurry) and perhaps that makes it easier sometimes when looking for sharp center and blurry background.

What I tried to say earlier is that also small differences in perceived "sharpness" can help with dimensionality or pop. Local sharpening and sometimes blurring.

I like it when the focus plane is flat. I'm a mediocre photographer and have enough problems with my work without extensive field curvature adding to the soup. So, field curvature is one off the things I check when getting a new lens in my hands. I appreciate Fred Miranda's reviews where he post the animated GIF demonstrating possible field curvature.
+1 for Fred's FC GIF's.

So, maybe my CoC x MTF mental gymnastics is more like CoC x MTF x FC (conceptual impact, not literal math).


The thing here is that MTF shows us the end result, but it doesn't tell us anything about what causes the resolution to drop...
Nov 22, 2025 at 06:53 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.97 #14which lens has the most 3D POP?
cbass wrote:
I think this guys blog entry is worth reading if you have the time or desire on the subject.

https://theothersideofbokeh.wordpress.com/2018/02/13/3d-pop-zeiss-exclusive-traits/

Whomever remains and has not lost interest.


I do think this blog entry is useful. In my own experience, when I want 3D I get it most reliably by using what he calls depth by perspective. This type of 3D effect, I think, is driven mostly by composition and has very little to do with the lens or bokeh fall off or other elements. I also suspect it is the 3D that is most easily seen by the largest number of people.

Below are some of my shots that I think used this compositional technique to create images that I see 3D and which I think most people who see the images also see 3D.




  ILCE-7RM2    ZEISS Loxia 2.4/25 lens    25mm    f/4.0    1/2000s    100 ISO    0.0 EV  






  ILCE-7RM5    Voigtlander NOKTON 21mm F1.4 Aspherical lens    21mm    f/4.0    1/2000s    100 ISO    0.0 EV  






  ILCE-7RM2    ZEISS Loxia 2.4/85 lens    85mm    f/2.4    1/320s    100 ISO    +2.0 EV  






  Canon EOS 50D    50mm    f/2.0    1/1000s    200 ISO    +0.3 EV  






  LEICA M10    Summicron-M 1:2/28 ASPH. lens    28mm    f/2.0    1/125s    200 ISO    0.0 EV  






  Canon EOS 5D Mark II    Zeiss Distagon T* 2.8/21 ZE lens    21mm    f/6.3    1/125s    160 ISO    0.0 EV  

Nov 22, 2025 at 08:45 AM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.97 #15which lens has the most 3D POP?
Took another tree out of head shot, slightly missed on the angle though.







Sorry...I know this is OT from the 3D pop topic. But I couldn't resist. I promise there will be no more.
Nov 22, 2025 at 01:32 PM
1bwana1
Offline
Details
p.97 #16which lens has the most 3D POP?

tsdevine wrote:
Took another tree out of head shot, slightly missed on the angle though.

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/54940124891_5817002634_h.jpg

Sorry...I know this is OT from the 3D pop topic. But I couldn't resist. I promise there will be no more.


Ted, as we are always being advised to develop a signature style it is nice to see you have found yours.

Still working on mine...
Nov 22, 2025 at 04:01 PM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.97 #17which lens has the most 3D POP?
1bwana1 wrote:
tsdevine wroteTook another tree out of head shot, slightly missed on the angle though.

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/54940124891_5817002634_h.jpg

Sorry...I know this is OT from the 3D pop topic. But I couldn't resist. I promise there will be no more.
Ted, as we are always being advised to develop a signature style it is nice to see you have found yours.

Still working on mine...


Yeah, Ted just happened to sit on a root that wrapped around and made a perfect seat. Pretty hard to avoid the tree on that one.

I do take pictures of him where trees aren't one of his appendages. But he likes to hike, so sometimes they work their way in.
Nov 22, 2025 at 04:39 PM
dalegaspi
Offline
Details
p.97 #18which lens has the most 3D POP?
To me, one of them is the Zeiss 28mm Distagon. This thread made me think of that lens so I (re-) bought one.

A couple of old ones with the D700.









Nov 22, 2025 at 06:55 PM
jay w
Offline
Details
p.97 #19which lens has the most 3D POP?
I wonder if it's the imperfections that make me like a lens. My brother said that what makes a (guitar) amp sound good is the distortion. You don't want a perfectly clean sound. I wonder if there's an analogy in lenses where there imperfections add a signature, maybe some vignetting, spherical aberration, or whatever that gives a look you like. Years ago I adapted some of my old lenses (Contax and Nikon) and found I liked the "70s-80s" look.

Of course the viewer doesn't notice any of this, meaning it's the image that matters, but it's fun for the photographer.
Nov 22, 2025 at 08:48 PM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.97 #20which lens has the most 3D POP?
gdanmitchell wrote:
RustyBug wrote…your point about incorporating BOTH sharp / de-sharp is…
This kind of stuff is standard practice among people who understand post-processing, as is adding controlled vignetting, adjusting the curves differently throughout the image, color balance, and saturation in various of the image, and more.


Understood ... but, when the intricacies of depth are among a scene with a variety of neighboring components in multiple (and/or overlapping) planes, it can be more of a labor of love, than if the optic does so naturally. Keeping the "tells" at bay in such situations isn't always an easy task.
Nov 22, 2025 at 09:25 PM


FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister