p.39 #1['NEW Fix' UPDATE!] - MkIII AF still broken
Wow.. what an interesting response.
Let me sum up the point of HROW's test as I see it. One shot was manually focused and the other was using AF. The AF shot consistently was not as sharp. I think that is what the situation is if I am not mistaken. No scientific testing.. just real world shooting environment for many.
p.39 #2['NEW Fix' UPDATE!] - MkIII AF still broken
apdieb wrote:
Wow.. what an interesting response. Let me sum up the point of HROW's test as I see it. One shot was manually focused and the other was using AF. The AF shot consistently was not as sharp. I think that is what the situation is if I am not mistaken. No scientific testing.. just real world shooting environment for many. FWIW
Yes, you are mistaken. There is a back story. He did more than one shot each, 35 shots in all, the shots were not "real world", he did make attempts to control a few variables.
p.39 #3['NEW Fix' UPDATE!] - MkIII AF still broken
Just for the record, I had to post this:
From Rob Galbraith today:
February 3, 2008: Canon USA informing VIPs of new EOS-1D Mark III AF fix
Starting on February 1, 2008, Canon USA began informing key photographers and key organizations using the EOS-1D Mark III that engineers at Canon in Japan have developed a new fix for the camera's autofocus, a fix that's in addition to the change in the sub-mirror mechanism and firmware updates introduced in 2007.
In closed door meetings at the PMA 2008 trade show in Las Vegas, at Super Bowl XLII in Phoenix, Arizona and on the phone, by our count it's a minimum of four different professional market reps that have revealed to photographers or managers at seven different sites using the EOS-1D Mark III that a new fix is in the works. In other words, Canon USA reps have been directed by their superiors to begin contacting VIP customers, and to tell those customers that there's good news pending on the EOS-1D Mark III autofocus front.
Details are scant right now. Here's some of what's being said by Canon USA reps:
Canon's autofocus engineers have determined the root cause of the EOS-1D Mark III's warm/sunny autofocus problems. They now know precisely what's wrong, and can completely correct it with the new autofocus solution. The phrase "root cause" or "underlying root cause" seems to be common to most or all of the briefings, suggesting the upcoming solution is meant to go well beyond the improvements introduced with the sub-mirror repair and the algorithm changes rolled into firmware v1.1.3.
Some are being told that the new fix is comprised of both a hardware change and new firmware, others are being told that it's not known yet at Canon USA whether the fix is comprised of hardware, firmware or both. This apparent discrepancy in what reps are saying is probably indicative of how new this information is to them, and how little information they themselves have been given so far by higher ups in the Canon organization. Canon USA reps aren't sharing any other specifics about the nature of the new fix.
VIP customers are not being told when the new fix will come available, or when Canon in the U.S. and elsewhere will begin broadcasting this news more widely, though some have been told that a public announcement will be made.
Historically, whispers like this from reps are followed fairly closely by an official release of information, since such news spreads like wildfire among pro shooters. Particularly when large numbers of them congregate at events like this weekend's Super Bowl. It therefore seems likely that a Canon website posting or press announcement will come sooner rather than later, and that the announcement is likely to contain a bit more about the what and the when of Canon's newest effort to improve EOS-1D Mark III autofocus. The level of detail in any Canon announcement will probably be driven by how far out in the future the new fix's availability is.
by ART MORRIS "The 70-200 f/4 is great for travel because of its light weight, especially when it is likely that you will be photographing birds or other wildlife at close range. And the more I use the 1Ds III the more I love it. Focusing is consistently more accurate then with my main MIII body (even after the sub-mirror fix). I need to try one of my back-up MIII bodies on the 500 and give it a good test. The California race of Brown Pelican is stunning in breeding plumage with the brightly colored bill pouch, especially the red at the base."
p.39 #6['NEW Fix' UPDATE!] - MkIII AF still broken
That guy waffles back and forth quicker than some of the birds he shoots! If I remember correctly, he was generally pleased with the performance of his first 1D MkIII, which he said didn't really need to be fixed. After the fix (or maybe he got a BD), then he was raving about how fantastic the thing focused. Now, when trickles of a new fix started to be heard, he's back to not being completely happy with his 1D MkIII, at least in comparison to his 1Ds MkIII. Don't pin me to the wall on the actual chain of events, as I don't follow what he writes, but I do recall the pattern of his waffle to be something like that...
He's got himself in a corner now, though, if the 1Ds MkIII is revealed to have the same defect. It really makes you wonder if that's why they have been so hard to come by since release. After all, the fewer Canon lets out, the fewer they'd have to fix. Given how many people have boasted about being 100% happy with the performance of their 1D MkIII, it really makes you wonder if this 'new' and underlying AF problem might also exist in the 1Ds MkIII, despite no widely reported issues.
p.39 #8['NEW Fix' UPDATE!] - MkIII AF still broken
Jeff wrote:
That guy waffles back and forth quicker than some of the birds he shoots! If I remember correctly, he was generally pleased with the performance of his first 1D MkIII, which he said didn't really need to be fixed. After the fix (or maybe he got a BD), then he was raving about how fantastic the thing focused. Now, when trickles of a new fix started to be heard, he's back to not being completely happy with his 1D MkIII, at least in comparison to his 1Ds MkIII. Don't pin me to the wall on the actual chain of events, as I don't follow what he writes, but I do recall the pattern of his waffle to be something like that...
He's got himself in a corner now, though, if the 1Ds MkIII is revealed to have the same defect. It really makes you wonder if that's why they have been so hard to come by since release. After all, the fewer Canon lets out, the fewer they'd have to fix. Given how many people have boasted about being 100% happy with the performance of their 1D MkIII, it really makes you wonder if this 'new' and underlying AF problem might also exist in the 1Ds MkIII, despite no widely reported issues....Show more →
If I recall correctly, he said he was pleased with the MkIII and then described his technique for photographing BIF which involved basically using manual focus until snapping the 2-3 frames he needed (i.e. not using the servo as it's supposed to work.) This is supposedly the way he's always done BIF but I'm not sure most BIFers do it this way (it's certainly a technique that people talk about but I'm not sure everyone uses manual focus to that extent when tracking birds.) I also seem to recall that he relayed the comments of people in his normal photo group (the "posse") and they were split right down the middle on whether the system worked properly (two of his group have since sold their Canon gear and gone Nikon.) So I don't know that I would say he has waffled back and forth (that would imply a definitive statement.) It's more like "stressing the positive" and yet leaving open some doors to people who like to read between the lines that maybe, just maybe, there were some issues that need addressing......
p.39 #9['NEW Fix' UPDATE!] - MkIII AF still broken
Disclaimer : I currently do not own a MK-III.
I'm very uncomfortable about the timing of Canon's apparent rumor, on the day of SuperBowl or a couple day's before ? Are they trying dodge pro photographers' irk by saying 'we-told-you-not-to-depend-100%-on-your-MKIII' if they get OOF shots because of the AF issue ??
p.39 #12['NEW Fix' UPDATE!] - MkIII AF still broken
Monito wrote: Yakim Peled wroteA new fix? That is getting pathetic…. Some people are never satisfied. If there were no new fix, they would complain. With a new fix, they complain.
You really want no improvements? OK. For you, we have a special deal. No fixes, no firmware updates, no updates to DPP.
They waited ~6 months to put out the first fix. One may think that when a large company like Canon takes such a long time they to investigate things, they could get it right the first time.
I can tell you what I think. I think that from the beginning they should announce publicly: We are investigating it. Then, after the problem is located and fix is found (and I mean a complete fix, not half-baked one) they should state that you can either fix your camera or replace it with a new one, free of charge.
In Israel one of the cellular companies had a major fault in their Motorola handsets some time ago. They build up a vast compounds in several major locations in Israel and replaced them for free. You wanted upgrade to compensate for the grief? You got it. Free. The CEO himself was there to make sure all is going well.
And please note. It was not their problem. It was a problem of one of their major handset suppliers. However, as it were their customers, they went all out to rectify things.
Public image is important. A stain on your name is not easily forgotten and - at least IMHO - it is well worth spending money to get your customers satisfied.
But as always, YMMV.
Happy shooting,
Yakim.
Added: Look at the subject name of the Israeli thread discussing this: "looks like the mkIII bullshit continues...." I did not write this. Also, I know you can't read Hebrew so I'll tell you that most posters (and, of course, the OP) feel just like me.
p.39 #15['NEW Fix' UPDATE!] - MkIII AF still broken
Monito wrote:
Nice try. No prize. No meaningful result. Sorry.
You failed to notice that he had said that IS was turned of, so why should we think that anything you said makes sense.
I have asked other people to tell me what is the best test, can you tell us what is the best way to test this camera.
All the good people on this forum who present us with their photos and tests, seem to get knocked on the head by people quoting reasons why the test is rubbish, so instead of knocking other peoples efforts to test, please put forward your test and photos.
Bob
p.39 #16['NEW Fix' UPDATE!] - MkIII AF still broken
inness wrote:
You failed to notice that he had said that IS was turned of, so why should we think that anything you said makes sense.
I have asked other people to tell me what is the best test, can you tell us what is the best way to test this camera.
All the good people on this forum who present us with their photos and tests, seem to get knocked on the head by people quoting reasons why the test is rubbish, so instead of knocking other peoples efforts to test, please put forward your test and photos.
Bob
I'll be honest with you, now that most of the AI Servo/AF issues revolving around the submirror have been fixed, it's much more difficult to accurately and specifically 'test' the camera. However, even the submirror 'fix' isn't fixing some cameras, and there are apparently Blue Dot cameras that have lingering issues as well (my current BD does not in relation to the submirror, though my first camera still didn't work after having gone back to Canon twice). You really need to go out and use it in a variety of conditions, with a variety of lenses (especially f/2.8 lenses), and scrutinize the images in relation to the results you feel you should have gotten given the techniques that you used. Examining the files at 100% view is required for this task, and it takes time and energy.
There are still fairly widespread reports of 'occasional' OOF images for no good reason, with no apparent plane of focus, nor any indication of front- or back-focusing. Also look for 'ghosting', or a sort of secondary image registration in one plane that looks like camera movement, but it is not (I've seen it at 1/8000th; see Rob G's most recent 'fast runner' series for examples, or the first page of this thread). I have not seen this 'ghosting' with my new Blue Dot, but I've only had the opportunity to put 400 images through it, mostly AI Servo testing (BTW, a runner coming at the camera using an f/2.8 telephoto lens is best for this test; center-point only, no expansion, default AI Tracking Sensitivity, 10 FPS). Lastly, the 'focal plane' (also referred to by some as 'fine detail smearing'?) issues that are also described in this thread are noted on Blue Dot models, mine included, thought to what extent I remain unsure, as I haven't been able to do much 'landscape' style testing, which highlights this issue rather well.
For what it's worth, many former users of MkII/n's simply say that the MkIII just doesn't quite live up to the performance of the MkIIn, and by Canon's own admission, it should have. I admit we're starting to split hairs here, because many people don't initially notice issues with their camera, especially if they use it for only certain types of shooting. My Blue Dot version is so much better than my early-production model that I am impressed, but the inconsistency in some of the results described above is hard to nail down without shooting a lot, using various techniques and lenses.
I know that probably isn't as definitive as what you'd hoped for, but that's all I've got.
-Jeff
PS: It will be interesting if someone's post about a 'harmonic balancer' being required for the fix ends up being true, as it would suggest that there is some sort of vibration issue going on...
p.39 #17['NEW Fix' UPDATE!] - MkIII AF still broken
Jeff wrote: inness wroteAll the good people on this forum who present us with their photos and tests, seem to get knocked on the head by people quoting reasons why the test is rubbish, so instead of knocking other peoples efforts to test, please put forward your test and photos.
BobI know that probably isn't as definitive as what you'd hoped for, but that's all I've got.
-Jeff
PS: It will be interesting if someone's post about a 'harmonic balancer' being required for the fix ends up being true, as it would suggest that there is some sort of vibration issue going on...
Many thanks for your posting, yes I have been following the debate here and on Rob G's pages.
I have a blue dot 1D lll and quite a few 2.8 L's ( oneday I may upgrade my sig ). I am in an electric wheelchair, so I dare not stand in front of runners . My copy seems to be ok, and I am the kind of person who never sells things, so for me it is ok, however if I can't test it, I may never know until I take a set of photos in the right circumstances, but then it may be too late. ( as in I may no longer be able to reproduce the photo that I wanted to take. )
p.39 #18['NEW Fix' UPDATE!] - MkIII AF still broken
inness wrote:
"...( oneday I may upgrade my sig )..."
Wow, no kidding Bob! I'd say you're a few generations behind!
Take care,
Jeff
PS: Once Canon admits to (and hopefully describes) the actual problem, it may become more clear how to test specifically for it, depending on how much detail they provide us.
p.39 #19['NEW Fix' UPDATE!] - MkIII AF still broken
Just got off the phone with Canon for the gizzilionth time after they didn't keep a scheduled call appointment, or return calls and played customer hand-off. At least they have come to their senses and decided that focusing with the * button is not the cause of the problems. I guess this is progress, not that they are willing to do anything to actually correct the situation but they are getting less idiotic about it. Moving up the food chain - hopefully - will see if I get a promised call from someone higher up in Customer Relations.
p.39 #20['NEW Fix' UPDATE!] - MkIII AF still broken
OK, so I finally got to take the new Blue Dot out for some actual shooting this weekend. Not bad with most of the AI Servo stuff, certainly a whole lot better than before...