I'm planning a trip to Lake Garda in August/September. Will start from Venice for 2 days, then around 7 days to Lake Garda and 3 days Toscany.
So far I have and will take with me Nikon Zf and 17-28/2.8.
Need to buy one more lens, but wondring which one would be more used - 24-120mm or 24-200mm?
Also, Which of those beautiful towns around Garda are worth to see? I will have around 7 days for it, can spend like 1-2 days in each town.
After that - what should I see in Toscany? Should have around 3 days for it. Would like to see Florence, Piza and do some wine tasting, visit some famous winery.
Personally, I would rebalance the time spent between Lake Garda and Tuscany.
If not exactly reversing it, then at least splitting the days evenly.
Lake Garda is very beautiful, especially the Brescia side: Salò, Limone, Gardone, and down to Desenzano, and even better, Sirmione.
Tuscany, for its part, has many areas worth seeing.
Let’s say that within an hour and a half of Florence, you have Pisa and Siena.
Those alone require a day; add two days for Florence, especially if you’ve never been there.
Also about an hour away are San Gimignano and Volterra.
Another half-hour from Siena is the Val d’Orcia, with Montalcino and Montepulciano nearby.
If possible, consider coming in September: it’s usually cooler, less crowded, and the weather is stable.
It must be said that, with the changes currently underway, the weather could also be very different, unfortunately.
Personally, I would rebalance the time spent between Lake Garda and Tuscany.
If not exactly reversing it, then at least splitting the days evenly.
Lake Garda is very beautiful, especially the Brescia side: Salò, Limone, Gardone, and down to Desenzano, and even better, Sirmione.
Tuscany, for its part, has many areas worth seeing.
Let’s say that within an hour and a half of Florence, you have Pisa and Siena.
Those alone require a day; add two days for Florence, especially if you’ve never been there.
Also about an hour away are San Gimignano and Volterra.
Another half-hour from Siena is the Val d’Orcia, with Montalcino and Montepulciano nearby.
If possible, consider coming in September: it’s usually cooler, less crowded, and the weather is stable.
It must be said that, with the changes currently underway, the weather could also be very different, unfortunately....Show more →
100%.
Venice, Rome and Florence are the bucket list cities. Most Americans don't know that each major city is pretty much a distinctly different city-state, with independent histories, government origins, food and culture.
No one can understand what a Neapolitan says and Venetians only sell pizza because American tourists (and the seagulls) expect it.
My general recommendation is to run the line from Rome to Venice and stop in Tuscany along the way (Florence/ Siena/ & the day trip towns Leo lists) along the way. Most US tourists don't stop in Bologna, which is along the line as it doesn't have the overwhelming attractions of the others, but I love its lifestyle.). The train takes that route, which makes it easy. You can also rent a car and drive it, which is fun, too, but it's not necessary.)
Hopefully, you can treat this as a scouting trip for next time. Don't do too much - it's all good. Just "take in" the place and accept that you will need to return.
Flying out of Venice is a beautiful, sad, water taxi ride to the airport. Best flights are to/from Rome.
I don’t know your photography style or your preferred focal lengths, but I’m guessing you’re not really into intimate landscapes or wildlife…
A 28mm lens is probably too wide-angle for this trip.
A 24-120mm lens is usually sufficient for the cities and places you’ll be visiting.
The 24-200 is lighter, a bit darker, and chromatically less "beautiful" than the 24-120.
The difference in focal length isn’t that great, and above all, it isn’t significant in those areas.
Only if you planned to go to Val d’Orcia and wanted to shoot some small trees on the hilltops would I take a longer lens, and in that case, I’d jump straight to a 28-400.
Even though it’s dark, you’d be shooting in broad daylight, so it shouldn’t be a problem.
Getting back to the trip, I don’t know your age or preferences, but considering that traveling to Italy from the UK isn’t a huge journey, I’d focus on 3 or 4 places and save Rome and the rest of the country for another trip - actually, at least two more!
IF you go to Venice…there's the Venice Biennale (La Biennale di Venezia). Until November 22nd. Highly recommended if you like to see art. Prices for hotels can be a bit steep though (but still very much recommended). Try to stay in Venice itself.
As to the 24-120 vs 24-200, I find that I do take some longer "travel" shots, out to 200mm. If I were to sort them out by focal length, it wouldn't be a huge number. I'd planned on a 24-105 (or 120), over time, thinking of going to ff from aps-c, in dslrs then in mirrorless. A Sony user, I did decide to go with a Tamron 28-200 instead, the "superzooms" getting better over the years, I'd used an 18-140 or 18-135 in aps-c so liked the range.
These two, the price and sizes are very similar, so no big driver either way. I don't know the image quality differences except at a distance by reputation/forum discussions. Use wise, I'd prefer the 200mm to be available unless there's a distinct quality concern. End use might suggest more or less concern over the image, viewing on screen mostly, social media sharing, or going for prints? I use an A7Riv now so have more "crop space" than the ZF so that might be a nudge towards the 24-200 if you see using the longer focal lengths more vs being able to crop.
Location wise I'm of no help. Our daughter was in school in Florence for a year and got all kinds of travel in including the Biennale mentioned. It's one of those not enough time and too many places.
Personally, I would rebalance the time spent between Lake Garda and Tuscany.
If not exactly reversing it, then at least splitting the days evenly.
Lake Garda is very beautiful, especially the Brescia side: Salò, Limone, Gardone, and down to Desenzano, and even better, Sirmione.
Tuscany, for its part, has many areas worth seeing.
Let’s say that within an hour and a half of Florence, you have Pisa and Siena.
Those alone require a day; add two days for Florence, especially if you’ve never been there.
Also about an hour away are San Gimignano and Volterra.
Another half-hour from Siena is the Val d’Orcia, with Montalcino and Montepulciano nearby.
If possible, consider coming in September: it’s usually cooler, less crowded, and the weather is stable.
It must be said that, with the changes currently underway, the weather could also be very different, unfortunately....Show more →
Ciao Leo
Thank you for your suggestions.
I know weather might be a mixed bag next week, but unfortunately I had to choice (work comitments).
So, we are going there next week, starting Wednesday from Venice 1.5 day, Garda 5 days, then Florence 3.5 days.
Venice is just to be and see it, not planning much, one full day, will go on that Bell Tower and that's it, rest will be simply walking around, absorbing the atmosphere of the city, plus maybe few cannolli and about 100 litres of crema di caffe
I tried it in Rome 2 years ago for the first time in my life and it became one of the best things I tried
Garda will be busy, I planned whole 5 days around, lots of ferry travelling, eating lake fish, some nice pizza etc
Monte Baldo, Garda, Bardolino, Sirmione, Desenzano, Limone, Malcesine, Salo, Riva.
Florence - here I have nothing. I mean I'm not a fan of churches, but will go and see Cattedrale di Santa Maria del Fiore of course. second thing I have on the list is Ponte Vecchio and that is it.
I'm planning rest of the time to do excursions, first one to Pisa, taking train, see the tower. Next wine tasting half day orginised trip to few Chianti vineyards.
Now, I would love to see all those fantastic places you mentioned, Val d’Orcia especially. However, I dont know if its doable without a car.
What would you suggest?
Florence, pretty walkable, even if not a big fan or churches,the Basilica di Santa Croce is one of the larger churches, and is also the resting place for ta number of notable Italians, including those from the Italian Renaissance such as Michelangelo, Galileo, and Machiavelli, as well as the poet Foscolo, political philosopher Gentile and the composer Rossini, and as recent as Enrico Fermi, so has more than a little tourist type interest. Several museums, Academia (David),Uffizi Gallery, Pitti Palace, Boboli Gardens. Piazzale Michelangelo for the sunset view. With some planning Cinque Terre and Pisa can be a day trip by train.
I would bring a small light prime for early morning and night photos. I haven't been to Lake Garda but I have been to Venice several times and early mornings and late evenings were my favorite times there.
phinix wrote:
I'm planning a trip to Lake Garda in August/September. Will start from Venice for 2 days, then around 7 days to Lake Garda and 3 days Toscany.
So far I have and will take with me Nikon Zf and 17-28/2.8.
Need to buy one more lens, but wondring which one would be more used - 24-120mm or 24-200mm?
Also, Which of those beautiful towns around Garda are worth to see? I will have around 7 days for it, can spend like 1-2 days in each town.
After that - what should I see in Toscany? Should have around 3 days for it. Would like to see Florence, Piza and do some wine tasting, visit some famous winery....Show more →
When you write “7 days,” “1-2 days,” “3 days,” I’ll assume that you mean that may nights in accommodations there, which means that you actually get one less “day” at each, with the intervening days largely devoted to travel to the next town.
I can’t offer much about the Garda area since I have not visit it.
I have spent a bit of time in Tuscany, visiting on several occasions. Assuming htat you haven’t been to that area before…
Three days could be enough for a brief visit to Florence, but in my view that might be about it. If you minimize your time in Florence you might be able to add an out-and-back trip to one other place, but Florence alone is worth the full three days. There’s a lot to see and do there, and you’ll get plenty of recommendations. I’ll offer two:
- First, get up early and go out into the streets with your camera before the tourist mob wakes up and eats breakfast. It is a whole different Florence.
Second, one very touristy thing that I do recommend there is t join the throng hiking up to Piazalle Michelangelo for sunset. We almost didn’t, because we shy away from some of the overdone tourist stuff, but since we had time and no other plans one evening we said, “Oh, what the heck.” I don’t know if it is always like it was when we went up there or if we just got lucky, but it was completely magical. At one point some the crowd noticed some busker who had been playing in a corner for euros and began singing along with whatever he was playing at that moment – hundreds of people, perhaps over 1000. It was really quite something. Of course, you might go up there and find… just a crowd. That’s the thing about travel, you never know.
As mentioned above, by someone who knows the area much better than I, there’s a whole lot of other stuff to see and do in Tuscany. Honestly, a visit to “Tuscany,” as differentiated from, say, “Florence,” is more than a 3 day thing. A week woud be a good start, but…
Siena is well worth a visit. The first time we were there it was on one of those short day visits while we stayed elsewhere… and it wasn’t nearly enough time to truly explore the remarkable curving streets of that city. We went back later and stayed three nights and that was better.
VENICE
If by “2 days” in Venice you mean “two nights,” I urge you to reconsider. Yes, it will be a zoo during tourist season. (Though with some planning you can get outside of the areas with the worst crowds.) Yes it is super popular. But there’s nothing else like it. The first time we visited we splurge on a water taxi from the train station to our accommodations — and seeing the actual Venice from that boat moments after we stepped off the train was one of the most memorable of our travel experiences.
As with Florence, get up early and just go out and wander… among the workers delivering supplies to shops and restaurants in the early morning before the tourists arise, and when the light is magical.
But find a way to spend at least one more night there.