EB-1 wrote:
gdanmitchell wrote
Perhaps counter intuitively, I’m skeptical of reviewers whose qualification is that they “own all three (or more) systems.”
There certainly is some truth to the fact that if they actually use all of them sufficiently to become deeply familiar with all three (or more) that they have a basis for offering some comparisons that others may lack.
However, too often for comfort, I’seen folks who own a ton of gear and brands whose actual photography suggests that their talent lies more with the acquisition of gear than with its use to make fine photographs — which makes me question, at least a bit, their perspective.
(I know nothing of the specific reviewer mentioned in this thread, and I’m making a general comment without reference to any specific person.) The reviewer should be good at testing and reviewing the gear, analyzing the results and presenting it well. Nobody is expecting them to be make fine photographs; that's often a different skillset. The Googles UTube video in question is not particularly useful, though I have no idea if that is normal. I've pretty much not gained anything from it, but may be of some use to novices looking to start a system.
EBH
Yes. And no.
Reporting facts and data is important, and it isn’t impossible to do that even if one isn’t a decently skillful photographer, I suppose. Certainly, a skillful technician can run image tests and collect data about, say, a lens or dynamic range or noise levels. Those things are fairly objective and subject to quantitative measurement.
But it is rare that photographic gear reviews simply report such data. They virtually always go well beyond that, both interpreting the significance of the data and assessing/rating various individual things that are not simply objective measurements and then attempting to come up with some overall evaluation that weights these various objective and subjective elements.
When it comes to that process, the skillful technician and “measurer” is often not able to offer truly meaningful or relevant assessment of the actual performance of the camera or other gear.
One other problem I have with the “own everything” reviewers is their too-frequent dismissal of the perspective of anyone who doesn’t “own all the gear.” Too often, it comes off as a defense mechanism: “I own everything so I know about all the gear. If you don’t own everything, your perspective isn’t valid.”
There are useful exceptions among some people whose full time job seems to be testing and assessing photography equipment.
Finally, I’m extremely skeptical of the “winners and losers” approach to evaluating things like, but not limited to, camera equipment. It gets attention — and “clicks” — but rarely is objectively accurate.