fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2021 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2021Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary

  
 
gocolts
Offline
Details
p.12 #1Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
Charlie N wrote:
gocolts wroteThe size of the 90 (along with the fact that my other 2 primes on either side are 50 & 135mm) make this an intriguing lens. Casual portraits would be breeze due to the size, and for travel it'd be a good "throw it in just in case I need some reach" lens. Will have to decide how much it'd actually get used.
I like the combo, I was on a trip with the 24/85 f1.4's and it worked out very well, love the contrasting style. The only thing was the size and weight, double of what a samyang 24mm f1.8 and sigma 90mm f2.8 would weigh, my current configuration since I've preordered

along with the 28-60, I think I can end my search for a travel kit. Since I had the m43's 85 equivalent, I've always wanted a closer focusing 85, 1:5 may not mean much for most folks, but for me, that's great, considerably better than the sony 85. I'm
...Show more →

I also have the 28-60 as a staple in my travel kit. Issue is that if I want to keep things small, currently 60mm is about as long as I can go. The 90 gives me reach plus f/2.8 if needed.
Sep 09, 2021 at 07:42 AM
chris9
Offline
Details
p.12 #2Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary

Sep 09, 2021 at 08:03 AM
j4nu
Online
Details
p.12 #3Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
j4nu wrote:
Hmm, 90mm seems to be very similar to 85DN when it comes to pincushion distortion....
I guess that's the price for the size.


Hmm#2, lenstip reports 24mm barrel distortion to be similar to that of Tamron, so pretty big...
I guess these are not lenses for optical purists .
Sep 09, 2021 at 08:19 AM
chris9
Offline
Details
p.12 #4Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary

Sep 09, 2021 at 08:28 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.12 #5Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
Sep 09, 2021 at 08:29 AM
smpetty
Offline
Details
p.12 #6Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
I wonder if Sigma has improved the AF of their lenses.

In terms of AF, the 65/2 DG DN behaves the best of the DG DN lenses, in my experience, but it's still not as good as Sony lenses.

The Sigma 85 DG DN is a stunning lens, but even my heavy old Sony 85 GM generated more keepers with eye-AF and moving subjects.

Debbie Downer,






Edited on Sep 09, 2021 at 09:17 AM · View previous versions
Sep 09, 2021 at 08:54 AM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.12 #7Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
j4nu wrote:
j4nu wroteHmm, 90mm seems to be very similar to 85DN when it comes to pincushion distortion....
I guess that's the price for the size.
Hmm#2, lenstip reports 24mm barrel distortion to be similar to that of Tamron, so pretty big...
I guess these are not lenses for optical purists .


Most likely not. If your not a fan of distortion which I’m not than maybe a tough call.
Sep 09, 2021 at 09:03 AM
sselhtrim
Offline
Details
p.12 #8Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
Sep 09, 2021 at 09:35 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
Sep 09, 2021 at 09:51 AM
Justin Stone
Offline
Details
p.12 #10Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
The Sigma bests the Sony 1.8 in most ways. Maybe oof rendering a bit nicer for the Sony, but I think it’s horses for courses when you get to mfd with the slower Sigma.

Mostly he’s focused on portrait applications, but the corner sharpness suggests what many of us will want to use this lens for: landscape.

I’m resisting hitting buy on this right now. But struggling.

chris9 wrote:




Edited on Sep 09, 2021 at 09:56 AM · View previous versions
Sep 09, 2021 at 09:54 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.12 #11Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
smpetty wrote:
I wonder if Sigma has improved the AF of their lenses.

In terms of AF, the 65/2 DG DN behaves the best of the DG DN lenses, in my experience, but it's still not as good as Sony lenses.

The Sigma 85 DG DN is a stunning lens, but even my heavy old Sony 85 GM generated more keepers with eye-AF and moving subjects.

Debbie Downer,


At first I thought the 65/2 DG DN was accurate but in reality it misses focus very often in AF-C, especially when using Eye-AF.
Sep 09, 2021 at 09:58 AM
j4nu
Online
Details
p.12 #12Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
Fred Miranda wrote:
smpetty wroteI wonder if Sigma has improved the AF of their lenses.

In terms of AF, the 65/2 DG DN behaves the best of the DG DN lenses, in my experience, but it's still not as good as Sony lenses.

The Sigma 85 DG DN is a stunning lens, but even my heavy old Sony 85 GM generated more keepers with eye-AF and moving subjects.

Debbie Downer,
At first I thought the 65/2 DG DN was accurate but in reality it misses focus very often in AF-C, especially when using Eye-AF.


Do you mean eyeAF of someone running towards you or more portrait-like usage?
I just can't get my heard around this, there seem to be so many reports of AF on DN series being on the poor side, but the only case where I really see my 85DN AF fall apart are action shots (like somebody running towards me, etc.).
Sep 09, 2021 at 10:11 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.12 #13Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
chris9 wrote:



Thanks Chris,
The best online review IMO.

Here is what I learned from this Sigma 90/2.8i review:
(cameralabs' tests and samples)

Strengths:

1) Super compact and well built 90mm AF lens
2) Low color aberration (Axial and Lateral)
3) Short focusing distance at 0.5m. (great for close-ups, flower shots, etc.)
4) Slight SA at close distance. Some may not like this but I do. :-)
5) Very low focus breathing. Great for video and focus stacking.
6) High resolution from center to corner at f/2.8. Noticeably beats the Sony 85/1.8 off-axis at any aperture.

Cons:

1) cats-eye bokeh at f/2.8, especially at mid-distance
2) rendering not as pleasant as the 45/2.8i
Sep 09, 2021 at 10:22 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.12 #14Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
j4nu wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
smpetty wroteI wonder if Sigma has improved the AF of their lenses.

In terms of AF, the 65/2 DG DN behaves the best of the DG DN lenses, in my experience, but it's still not as good as Sony lenses.

The Sigma 85 DG DN is a stunning lens, but even my heavy old Sony 85 GM generated more keepers with eye-AF and moving subjects.

Debbie Downer,
At first I thought the 65/2 DG DN was accurate but in reality it misses focus very often in AF-C, especially when using Eye-AF.
Do you mean eyeAF of someone running towards you or more portrait-like usage?
I just can't get my heard around this, there seem to be so many reports of AF on DN series being on the poor side, but the only case where I really see my 85DN AF fall apart are action shots (like somebody running towards me, etc.).


Both. After many months of usage, I don't find AF-C very reliable, especially when depth of field is narrow and small miss-focus is noticeable. I get better accuracy with my 85/1.4 GM which has slower focus.
Sep 09, 2021 at 10:25 AM
j4nu
Online
Details
p.12 #15Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
Fred Miranda wrote:
j4nu wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
smpetty wroteI wonder if Sigma has improved the AF of their lenses.

In terms of AF, the 65/2 DG DN behaves the best of the DG DN lenses, in my experience, but it's still not as good as Sony lenses.

The Sigma 85 DG DN is a stunning lens, but even my heavy old Sony 85 GM generated more keepers with eye-AF and moving subjects.

Debbie Downer,
At first I thought the 65/2 DG DN was accurate but in reality it misses focus very often in AF-C, especially when using Eye-AF.
Do you mean eyeAF of someone running towards you or more portrait-like usage?
I just can't get my heard around this, there seem to be so many reports of AF on DN series being on the poor side, but the only case where I really see my 85DN AF fall apart are action shots (like somebody running towards me, etc.).
Both. After many months of usage, I don't find AF-C very reliable, especially when depth of field is narrow and small miss-focus is noticeable. I get better accuracy with my 85/1.4 GM which has slower focus.


Thanks, I guess this is one of those mysteries that will never be solved ...
Sep 09, 2021 at 10:31 AM
grahamgibson
Offline
Details
p.12 #16Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
Fred Miranda wrote:
j4nu wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
smpetty wroteI wonder if Sigma has improved the AF of their lenses.

In terms of AF, the 65/2 DG DN behaves the best of the DG DN lenses, in my experience, but it's still not as good as Sony lenses.

The Sigma 85 DG DN is a stunning lens, but even my heavy old Sony 85 GM generated more keepers with eye-AF and moving subjects.

Debbie Downer,
At first I thought the 65/2 DG DN was accurate but in reality it misses focus very often in AF-C, especially when using Eye-AF.
Do you mean eyeAF of someone running towards you or more portrait-like usage?
I just can't get my heard around this, there seem to be so many reports of AF on DN series being on the poor side, but the only case where I really see my 85DN AF fall apart are action shots (like somebody running towards me, etc.).
Both. After many months of usage, I don't find AF-C very reliable, especially when depth of field is narrow and small miss-focus is noticeable. I get better accuracy with my 85/1.4 GM which has slower focus.


So I've been under the impression that Sigma lenses other than the 45i tracked well in AF-C, but is that not the case? I'm curious to try the 35i and this new 90i is also on my list of considerations, but having reasonably good eye-AF in AF-C is important to me. Otherwise I'll use my manual lenses.
Sep 09, 2021 at 11:13 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.12 #17Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
The 45i is definitely the least accurate in PDAF due to higher SA. (It’s fine on the Leica SL and SL2 since these bodies only uses CDAF) but the 65/2 and 85/1.4 miss focus more than most Sony lenses, especially the latest GMs. Hopefully the 90/2.8 will have greater accuracy.
Perhaps this is due to focus architecture or algorithm used, not sure. If it’s the later there is a chance it may be improved by firmware.

grahamgibson wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
j4nu wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
smpetty wroteI wonder if Sigma has improved the AF of their lenses.

In terms of AF, the 65/2 DG DN behaves the best of the DG DN lenses, in my experience, but it's still not as good as Sony lenses.

The Sigma 85 DG DN is a stunning lens, but even my heavy old Sony 85 GM generated more keepers with eye-AF and moving subjects.

Debbie Downer,
At first I thought the 65/2 DG DN was accurate but in reality it misses focus very often in AF-C, especially when using Eye-AF.
Do you mean eyeAF of someone running towards you or more portrait-like usage?
I just can't get my heard around this, there seem to be so many reports of AF on DN series being on the poor side, but the only case where I really see my 85DN AF fall apart are action shots (like somebody running towards me, etc.).
Both. After many months of usage, I don't find AF-C very reliable, especially when depth of field is narrow and small miss-focus is noticeable. I get better accuracy with my 85/1.4 GM which has slower focus.
So I've been under the impression that Sigma lenses other than the 45i tracked well in AF-C, but is that not the case? I'm curious to try the 35i and this new 90i is also on my list of considerations, but having reasonably good eye-AF in AF-C is important to me. Otherwise I'll use my manual lenses.

Sep 09, 2021 at 11:21 AM
Alan Parker
Offline
Details
p.12 #18Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
I'm mostly seeing somewhat good to great reviews on these new additions to the lineup. Not really the glowing reviews I was expecting; especially on the 90/2.8 but even on the 24/2. The pincushion distorting on the latter is just too strong and the portrait option comes quite close to its rivals for a similar price. Makes it quite a bit harder to see the value proposition and where these lenses differentiate from the pack.
It gives off the impression that it's just a little too rough around the edges and not quite on point for a $600-700 prime.
Sep 09, 2021 at 11:33 AM
j4nu
Online
Details
p.12 #19Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
grahamgibson wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
j4nu wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
smpetty wroteI wonder if Sigma has improved the AF of their lenses.

In terms of AF, the 65/2 DG DN behaves the best of the DG DN lenses, in my experience, but it's still not as good as Sony lenses.

The Sigma 85 DG DN is a stunning lens, but even my heavy old Sony 85 GM generated more keepers with eye-AF and moving subjects.

Debbie Downer,
At first I thought the 65/2 DG DN was accurate but in reality it misses focus very often in AF-C, especially when using Eye-AF.
Do you mean eyeAF of someone running towards you or more portrait-like usage?
I just can't get my heard around this, there seem to be so many reports of AF on DN series being on the poor side, but the only case where I really see my 85DN AF fall apart are action shots (like somebody running towards me, etc.).
Both. After many months of usage, I don't find AF-C very reliable, especially when depth of field is narrow and small miss-focus is noticeable. I get better accuracy with my 85/1.4 GM which has slower focus.
So I've been under the impression that Sigma lenses other than the 45i tracked well in AF-C, but is that not the case? I'm curious to try the 35i and this new 90i is also on my list of considerations, but having reasonably good eye-AF in AF-C is important to me. Otherwise I'll use my manual lenses.


I'd advise you to try it yourself, there are many opinions on this matter ...
Sep 09, 2021 at 12:14 PM
ReleaseDrive
Offline
Details
p.12 #20Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
I just can't decide if I should first continue building out my Voigtlander set or Sigma i series set. I don't have a voig. over 50 and the 75mm 1.5: it keeps calling my name.

This Sigma 90mm is much more pratical though l and obviously a longer focal length. Maybe I should buy both and let them fight it out amongst themselves.
Sep 09, 2021 at 12:31 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister