Sashi wrote:
Mark
A great shot. IMHO, the grain detracts from the picture, especially in the bottom half where it makes the picture appear "soft" due to the lack of texture.
Thanks for sharing snaps of places not always available to everyone.
Thank you very much! I appreciate the honest feedback.
Interesting about your take on the grain. A difference in monitors might play into it. I have two that I rely most on for detail (non 4K or 5K on purpose because of the problems associated with seeing real detail at the right viewing percentages on those) a Mac 27 inch Thunderbolt (which views detail exceptionally) and a Dell Ultrasharp Wide Gamut and I can barely make out the slightest indication of the grain (with my face close to the monitor). If I might ask, what kind of monitor are you using?
Also, the grain did not make the bottom look softer. It did the opposite. The bottom was much softer than what you see here, due to the extra perspective warp/blend there, and additionally because of some various cloning/smoothing techniques used to remove a ton of pockmarks, scratch marks and such (caused by flash floods and things slamming into that area) on that part of the wall. The grain used there made it more cohesive to the upper portion of the image than it otherwise could have looked. You might not like it softer down there (and I too would rather it have more of the detailed look of the above walls, but this is as good as it is able to be). The same type of natural contrast / detail just does not exist down there. The only other option was to crop it out, which would not allow the image to be taken at this perspective.
Mark
Thanks for the explanation. Much appreciated. Guess the lack of texture towards the bottom half of the image to start with is what's causing this perception.