Fred Miranda wrote:
DavidBM wrote
@Fred Miranda@@@, I see you have or had the Leica M Apo Telyt 3.4/135.
How does it compare against the Batis?
I recall seeing tests by Jim Kasson against the ZF.2 2/135 Apo Sonnar in which the Zeiss came out better at all shared apertures, but close enough so that when e.g. handholding you would be unlikely to tell the difference.
If the Apo Telyt is near enough stopped down, it might be a good hiking tele for someone with more spare cash than me... David,
I didn't warm up to the Telyt-M 135/3.4. My copy was well centered and sharp at close distances. However, at infinity distance, it could not keep up with my Vario-Sonnar 100-300 and that surprised me. Only at diffraction territory apertures they looked somewhat similar.
I saw some CA and that was disappointing as well. However, since I only tested ONE copy, I can't say that's how it really performs... Honestly, I didn't think it was worth its price and very much doubt it's comparable to the Batis 135/2.8.
Thanks Fred; I suspected as much. Apart from anything else it's hard to imagine that at the time of its design something that small and less than a stop slower than the B135 could keep up, no matter how premium it was then...