Lotusm50 Offline Upload & Sell: Off
|
philber wrote:
lotus, @f:3,5, the zoom would be wide open, whereas the 50 prime would be closed down one and a half stops. Not a fair comparison IMHO. But if you have something else in mind, let me kwow.
But it certainly is a practical comparison. If you need to use a 50mm lens a f3.5, then the comparison matters. If in a given situation, you would use the 50/2 at f3.5 but not the 35-70 at f3.5 then that is something to consider. If I said compare them at f2.0, that wouldn't be fair, becuase you just can not use the 35-70 at f2.0. But you can use it at f3.5. You can use both lenses at f3.5, so how do they perform there? Comparing them stopped down at f5.6 of f8 (around the optimum apertures) will show minimal differences other than say some qualitative and style differences. Useful to be sure, but not usually very revealing. The differences "may" be, or are potentially greater at larger apertures.
|