Timmeh Offline Upload & Sell: Off
|
Hi VeeJay,
Welcome to the landscape forum! I like your compositions overall, and I think I prefer #1 except for the processing (or lack thereof). Since you've ended up with strange casts in #1 and #3, are you editing on a color calibrated monitor?
The magenta cast in the clouds, and the green grasses look oversaturated like they've been colorized rather than part of the original scene. The contrast seems to have been pushed too much as well. The windswept grass and the slow shutter speed can definitely give a sense of the mood, but it doesn't usually work well for me.
For #2 the color in the sky is nice, but a small nit is that the bottom should either have more shoreline or less. It feels ever so slightly cut off. Otherwise I really like the silhouette and the clouds.
#3 doesn't do too much for me as it feels pretty generic (as you already stated from its description). The shape is ok, but there isn't anything there that makes me want to explore the image.
For your philosophy on photography, you may have reasons for wanting "straight out of camera" and no cropping, but without explanation I find them both confusing. Refusing to crop a photo to its detriment leaves you with uncompromised images that are less good than they could be. Why?
I am a big proponent of naturalistic processing, but the SOOC, no filter, pure shooting, whatever other tag just says I don't know, and I don't want to know. I think it's disingenuous to claim these titles because you are playing off of ignorance of the general public where "Photoshopped" means fake and manufactured. Yet those same people recognize Ansel Adams one of the greatest photographers, and they'd be shocked to hear just how much processing he did. You could benefit hugely from learning the digital darkroom so that you can adjust the image to fit your vision. I learn more processing every year, and it makes my images more natural looking according to my eye rather than less.
You don't have to defend yourself to me, and I don't mean this as an attack. My goal is to get you to think about your philosophy rather than stick with it unchallenged.
Tim
|