Definitely the first one. Something unsettling about the second one, almost like the door was added into that portal in photoshop. I think that image needs to have just a bit of the door showing in the main opening to the porch (a bit left from where this shot was taken). But the first one, very nice!
I have to come down on the side of the first also Tom. For some reason and perhaps the pov or color difference, the second looks like the plane of the door is different than the wall of the house.
Douglas
Tom, cloning out the two "wrong" horizontal lines on the wall next to the door
should eliminate the illusion that something is wrong about the door.
Chris
