different for me
interested what you think

Scott

Nice balance and symmetry. Lovely, warm colors. Won't quibble over verticals, I like the proportions of horizontal divisions.

Regards,

Bob

I like the shapes and colors. Anything there to add to the bottom? The edge of the shelf perhaps?

Bob Jarman wrote:
Nice balance and symmetry. Lovely, warm colors. Won't quibble over verticals, I like the proportions of horizontal divisions.

Regards,

Bob
thanks Bob

AuntiPode wrote:
I like the shapes and colors. Anything there to add to the bottom? The edge of the shelf perhaps?
Nope. Shot a bit too tight. Of course there is always some cloning as an option.

Scott

I guess the edge of the bottom shelf would help to balance out the image. Since that is not possible, maybe crop just a tad higher so the traces of the bottom shelf are not visible and then crop on the top to remove the traces of the upper shelf and supports. You can create your own frame with a black border.

I tend to overthink these issues. The attention should be on the goards and the shelving makes little difference.

Yup. Possible to build a shelf:

excellent carpentry

Flipping good. Also much better than being shelfless.

Well done Karen. Just what the bottom pumpkins pined for.

Bob

mind sharing your how-to?

Used the rectangular selection to copy the top shelf edge and pasted from the clipboard to a new layer. Then moved the shelf edge and slightly rotated it. Then used the erase tool on some of the top edge of the shelf to restore the lower edge of the pumpkins. Then merged the layers and used the clone stamp on the edges to re-build the ends and apply dark to the underside. Also retouched the edge with the clone stamp to remove characteristic marks that could be obviously matched to the top shelf.

thx again Karen
its a great job, including the shadow beneath the shelf.
Scott