I shot this pano on Sept 1st on my first visit to Crater Lake. Forest fires in Northern California gave the skies incredible color at sunset. There were still a few pockets of snow remaining on the north-facing shoreline. 14-Shots stitched together in Photoshop.

C&C are always welcomed!

Jim,

I like this because it is different. I like these "shadow" type shots. Sometimes shots give too many detail; this one is very nice.

I like it, makes me wish Crater lake had been open when I was there. I would be tempted to clone the white spots on the left, they distract from the silhouette of the shoreline.

Very nice Jim, it looks darn good to me.
Is this a single row?

Mike

This is just my opinion; take it for whatever you think it's worth.

I think it's a very pretty photograph; you captured unusual light in a pretty scene, very well.

That said, I think Crater Lake is the most serenely beautiful place I've ever seen (and I've seen a lot of very beautiful places), and I'm afraid that this photo has a generic look to it that doesn't perhaps take full advantage of the incredible and unusual beauty of Crater Lake.

Again, JMO.

Outstanding, now GET IT PRINTED.
And don't get cheap with some little bitty thing.
Think big, own the wall!!

that's beautiful

Beautiful shot Jim, the colours and silhouettes are just perfect
David

Love this image Jim, thanks for sharing!
Scott