Home · Register · Search · View Winners · Software · Hosting · Software · Join Upload & Sell

My posts · My subscriptions
  

  Previous versions of naturephoto1's message #11910744 « A7/A7r - performance with WA RF lenses »

  

naturephoto1
Online
Upload & Sell: On
Re: A7/A7r - performance with WA RF lenses


Makten wrote:
While not being a "wide angle", I can now happily inform you that the tiny Leica 40/2 Summicron-C performs unexpectedly good on the a7R. I met Martin Agfors (I'm sure he's here, but don't know his alias) for lunch and a little walk, and he kindly lent me the a7R, while he got to play with my ZF 35/2 and CV 40/2.

Wide open:


Martin Agfors by Martin Hertsius, on Flickr


I also tried my Nokton 35/1.2, but either there is something wrong with it, or it must be stopped down to get sharp outside the central part of the image. So, I won't show you anything from it, but I can at least say that it does give the same color shift as the Summicron-C, which is... close to none!

The C at infinity, wide open (go to Flickr for full resolution):


Summicron-C @ f/2 by Martin Hertsius, on Flickr


And at f/5.6 (or perhaps f/8, I don't remember):


Summicron-C @ f/5.6 by Martin Hertsius, on Flickr


As you can see, despite the extremely compact design, resolution is OK even wide open, except for the extreme corners. There is a midzone hump with somewhat lower resolution, but in my opinion, absolutely nothing to worry about. The spherical aberration wide open was expected from this sort of classic lens, and I don't mind it at all.
Worth to mention is that the camera was set to some sort of auto-correction of shading, but it would be very surprising if it did something to files shot with "no lens" on the camera. Also note that CA is very, very low.

How about curvature of field? Here is a full sized semi-closeup at f/5.6:


Summicron-C @ f/5.6 by Martin Hertsius, on Flickr

I must say I'm impressed. This little, unexpensive thing will do fine as a walkaround lens. Now, the FE 35/2.8 is clearly better, but it is somewhat clinical in its rendering.
Interestingly enough, the FE, Nokton and Summicron-C all have ~the same exit pupil distance from the sensor, if my eyes weren't lying.

The most important question is still unanswered: Would these lenses do better on the a7? I have no clue.


Martin,

Thank you very much for the tests. This makes me very very happy indeed. I expect and hope that my Minolta CLE MC 40mm f2 M-Rokkor performs like your Leica C 40mm f2 Summicron.

This should make for an excellent small package and to add to it a couple of wider angle lenses (hopefully RF) and at the longer end of the spectrum (and zooms and macro) my Leica R lenses,

Rich



Nov 04, 2013 at 08:13 PM



  Previous versions of naturephoto1's message #11910744 « A7/A7r - performance with WA RF lenses »