Mac/PC debate

FM Forum Rules
Nikon SLRs, primes, and zooms lenses reviews

FM Forums \| Nikon-mount SLRs \| Join Upload & Sell	Search Used
1 2 3 … 5 6 end

Archive 2009 · Mac/PC debate

Andre Labonte
Offline
Dedicated FM
Upload & Sell: Off

p.6 #1 · Mac/PC debate

^^^^ +1 to the SSD. But dang the price hurts. So, how do you configure it? Do you put all OS and apps on the SSD and userfiles on a standard HD?

Nov 06, 2009 at 04:49 PM

NightOwl Cat
Offline
Dedicated FM
Upload & Sell: Off

p.6 #2 · Mac/PC debate

Ok Michael, I went to a place here in Ohio that builds them, and also supports them, so when you call tech support, it's US Based

Since you're planning on getting a monitor separate, I didn't include it in my configurations.

Systemax PC http://www.systemaxpc.com then choose desktops:

Systemax Ascent A790 Build-to-Order Desktop PC - genuine Windows® 7 operating system, 780G chipset, micro or mid tower case, choice of options and upgrades

Here's the link to the machine itself:
http://www.productshippingcenter.com/applications/searchtools/configdetails.asp?Base=5307867

and the choices I selected:
$1321.98 with no monitor since you have your eye on a different one, and with the warranty extended 3 more years for a total of 4, subtract 119.99 if you want to forgo that

Select Operating System
Microsoft Windows 7 Professional 64bit (Add $35.00)

Select Chassis
SYX Mid-Tower ATX Chassis (Add $10.00)

Select Power Supply
500 Watt Power Supply (Add $15.00)

Socket AM2 / AM2+
Asus M3A78-EM Motherboard with HD Audio

Select Processor
AMD Phenom II X4 945 3.0GHz Quad Core Processor (Add $145.00)

Select Memory
8GB DDR2 PC6400 800MHz Memory (2GB x 4) (Add $120.00)

Select Hard Drive
1TB 3G SATA II Hard Drive (Add $40.00)

Select Second Hard Drive
1TB 3G SATA II Hard Drive (Add $80.00)

Select Optical Drive
22X Lightscribe DVDRW + 22X DVDRW SATA Drives (Add $30.00)

Select 3.5" Drive Device
9-in-1 Card Reader USB2 Black (Add $8.00)
Supports SmartMedia, SD/MMC, CompactFlash I/II, MS/MS PRO

Select Video
ATI Radeon HD4650 1GB PCIe (1DVI / 1VGA / 1HDMI) (Add $70.00)

Select Monitor
No Monitor Selected

Select Network Communication Device
Wireless N PCI Network Adapter (Add $20.00)

Select Keyboard
Microsoft Wireless Optical Desktop KB/Mouse USB (Add $20.00)

Select Input Device
Microsoft Basic USB Optical Mouse Black

Select Speakers
No Speakers Selected

Select Power Protection
Ultra 1000VA 600 Watt UPS (Add $109.00)

Select Microsoft Office Application
Microsoft Office Ready Pro 2007/60-Day Free Trial

Select Warranty
1 Year Parts & Labor Warranty
2 Yr Extended Desktop/Server Warranty (3 Yr Total) (Add $79.99)
3 Yr Extended Desktop/Server Warranty (4 Yr Total) (Add $119.99) <-- chose that.

3 Year Desktop/Server Warranty + Onsite Service (Add $139.99)
Onsite Service Option Not Valid in CA, CO, ME, MI, NJ, NY, NC, and PA

4 Yr Extended Desktop/Server Warranty (5 Yr Total) (Add $189.99)

4 Year Desktop/Server Warranty + Onsite Service (Add $199.99)
Onsite Service Option Not Valid in CA, CO, ME, MI, NJ, NY, NC, and PA

5 Year Desktop/Server Warranty + Onsite Service (Add $329.99)
Onsite Service Option Not Valid in CA, CO, ME, MI, NJ, NY, NC, and PA

Firewire Adapters
Integrated Firewire

Select Antivirus
CA Internet Security Suite Plus 2010 30-day Trial

MichaelKirk wrote:
and my post shows my computer ignorance. but for anyone that has read the entire thread - I'm pretty much a computer idiot much like a high percentage of users out there. My previous post ask more about not building a system ones self, but more about "ordering" a system where they build it for you.

So my questions should have been better stated asking about a comparable PC system to the iMac that someone builds for you such as the HP Z400 or I saw this one posted in a different FM thread:
http://www.avadirect.com/product_details_configurator.asp?PRID=14884

I tell you, buying a new computer system is as bad as buying a house and a car now

Michael

NightOwl Cat wrote:
DaveEP, since you quoted me responding to Michael's question, I was giving him an answer to his question which I had also quoted in my response, since he included his budget for the PC.

MichaelKirk wrote: OK I'll be the one to ask the DIRECT question. This if for those "in the know" so to speak. Those that have some real computer knowledge. I'm still tossing back and forth between PC and MAC but get so damn confused when I go to a site and try to build my own - I really have no idea and ofter end with a final build over $3,000. 27" iMac is gonna run about $2,000 - right!? Can some post up a PC build in the price range of $1,250-$1,450 that will be as good as or better than the iMac. PC would be with Windows 7. Adding a 24-25" monitor is gonna add another $500-$650 so the final prices should be compariable. let em rip! Michael

Yes, I build them for fun, and yes, I build them for work, and I have bought off the shelf as well. And yes, I build and fix them for friends and family as well. And yes, I was surprised a couple years ago when the off the shelf Compaqs I bought for work had ASUS motherboards in them

Nov 06, 2009 at 05:13 PM

Andre Labonte
Offline
Dedicated FM
Upload & Sell: Off

p.6 #3 · Mac/PC debate

I'm not sure I would go AMD. I'd go I7 myself, and that means a larger power supply too (watch that the individual rails are large enough, not just the over-all power). As for the SSD, it will boost performance but at a price. Also, I'm not convined yet of their reliability as far as data retention. I'll stick with 7200 rpm SATA II drives for now.

Nov 06, 2009 at 05:47 PM

Andre Labonte
Offline
Dedicated FM
Upload & Sell: Off

p.6 #4 · Mac/PC debate

For anyone interested. Here is a nice, pre-built box from HP for a great price ($1100.00)

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16883147039

It includes keyboard & mouse. You have to supply the monitor and speakers.

Nov 06, 2009 at 07:51 PM

snitramc
Offline
Upload & Sell: Off

p.6 #5 · Mac/PC debate

If the only difference between Mac and PC is the OS, then just build a PC and load OSx86 onto it. Then you have a Mac for half the price. As far as the box being sexy? Yawn. I work with the lights way down anyways. I prefer to look at my images, not my computer.

Nov 06, 2009 at 08:11 PM

Avi B
Offline
Dedicated FM
Upload & Sell: On

p.6 #6 · Mac/PC debate

Wait, but you can't!! Mr Jobs et al won't let you load the OS onto non-Mac hardware - legally at least.

And NightOwl Cat, I managed 633 myself. That was using QEMM's hi-memory manager.

Nov 06, 2009 at 08:18 PM

Silenus
Offline
Upload & Sell: Off

p.6 #7 · Mac/PC debate

I'd actually love to build a "hackintosh." If I could try the mac OS but still be able to build my own hardware, I'd be all for that. I know people do it I just haven't sat down and tried it.

@Andre - If SSD's were affordable to ALL my storage space I'd use them in a heartbeat, for reliability reasons as well as speed. I'd bet my money on the reliability over a platter based drive. This is assuming a good quality drive such as the Intel's. As for the performance at a price...yes it is! But I argue that even right now, it is WORTH the price.

As prices drop and capacity increases over the next year or two it will just get better.

Nov 06, 2009 at 08:41 PM

Andre Labonte
Offline
Dedicated FM
Upload & Sell: Off

p.6 #8 · Mac/PC debate

Silenus wrote:
I'd actually love to build a "hackintosh." If I could try the mac OS but still be able to build my own hardware, I'd be all for that. I know people do it I just haven't sat down and tried it.

@Andre - If SSD's were affordable to ALL my storage space I'd use them in a heartbeat, for reliability reasons as well as speed. I'd bet my money on the reliability over a platter based drive. This is assuming a good quality drive such as the Intel's. As for the performance at a price...yes it is! But I argue that even right now, it is WORTH the price.

As prices drop and capacity increases over the next year or two it will just get better.

+1 on the "hackintosh" if it were legal. I refuse to run any pirated or illegal software on my computers. I would build a dual-boot box in a second if I could buy the Apple OS seperately ... just to test it out more completely.

As for the SSD, I have not heard such good reports on their bit integrity, especially over time. Total failure, like we get with the platter based drives wearing out, is most likely better with SSD, but individual bits can be lost more easily with the SSD drives. SSD drives more susceptible to outside magnetic and static issues. Maybe they have fixed that since I last read about it .... time for me to do some homework.

For sure, I would be willing to spend the money on SSD for the performance on the applications drive if the reliability is there. I think for long-term mass storage of files, the old magnetic platters are the cost effective solution, especially when talking about redundant backups.

Nov 06, 2009 at 10:02 PM

patrickphoto
Offline
Upload & Sell: On

p.6 #9 · Mac/PC debate

no need to upgrade LR, and believe the same is true for PS. Just go online to your adobe account and both platform downloads are available.

Nov 06, 2009 at 10:09 PM

Silenus
Offline
Upload & Sell: Off

p.6 #10 · Mac/PC debate

Andre Labonte wrote:

+1 on the "hackintosh" if it were legal. I refuse to run any pirated or illegal software on my computers. I would build a dual-boot box in a second if I could buy the Apple OS seperately ... just to test it out more completely.

As for the SSD, I have not heard such good reports on their bit integrity, especially over time. Total failure, like we get with the platter based drives wearing out, is most likely better with SSD, but individual bits can be lost more easily with the SSD drives. SSD drives more susceptible to outside magnetic and static issues. Maybe they have fixed that since I last read about it .... time for me to do some homework.

For sure, I would be willing to spend the money on SSD for the performance on the applications drive if the reliability is there. I think for long-term mass storage of files, the old magnetic platters are the cost effective solution, especially when talking about redundant backups.

For mass storage of data and backup...yes certainly hard drives are the only financially feasible way to go right now. SSD for just OS/app drive makes sense. Consider that some of the first SSD's available from Intel, the X25-E extreme series, were targeted at enterprise server applications such as high speed databases. If the reliability wasn't there they wouldn't such a big hit in that environment. The earliest SSD's out on the market WERE terrible and not worth it. That may have spoiled the initial impression many got. They are rapidly getting better however. This is why I always try to put the caveat of a "quality" SSD in my comments.

There is no harm in waiting though.

The longer you wait the better deal you'll get. Over the course of 2010 you will see SSD's pick up a lot steam and even more performance. Capacities will likely at least double for the same price points they are now.

Nov 06, 2009 at 10:19 PM


FM Forums \| Nikon-mount SLRs \| Join Upload & Sell 1 2 3 … 5 6 end