Nice model and available lights.
The first one makes the model look really short, whe should have been standing or half length crop ?
The second one needs better composition IMO as the image is not well balanced.
The last one is very "centered" but works well for me. I would have put some more contrast though.
Nice model.
Thierry.NC wrote:
Nice model and available lights.
The first one makes the model look really short, whe should have been standing or half length crop ?
The second one needs better composition IMO as the image is not well balanced.
The last one is very "centered" but works well for me. I would have put some more contrast though.
Nice model.
You are entitled to your opinion...but I do think you tried very hard to "tear down" these photos. I've already had several photographers critique them for me who have extensive experience and not one of them had a negative comment. I'll go with their critiques.
...and really what is the point of leaving your website url on my thread? really?
I didn't really get the feeling that Thierry was trying to tear down your photos as much as simply provide his/her opinion, which you open yourself to by posting photos. I for one agree with the comment about #3 in that I feel it would present better if a wee bit was cropped from the top, making it less "centered". I very much like #1, the tone, the image, all work well together. #2 doesn't work as well IMHO, it looks somewhat awkward, mostly because of her position.
Please don't think that folks here are being negative just because they don't agree with your "image" of how a picture should be. I for one have learned more from the constructive criticism than from the ones who just say "I love it". Makes me look at my own pictures in a different light. If we all saw things exactly the same way, what kind of world would that be
The website URL is probably part of Thierry's signature, and was not left specifically on your individual photo.
Jo Dilbeck wrote:
I didn't really get the feeling that Thierry was trying to tear down your photos as much as simply provide his/her opinion, which you open yourself to by posting photos. I for one agree with the comment about #3 in that I feel it would present better if a wee bit was cropped from the top, making it less "centered". I very much like #1, the tone, the image, all work well together. #2 doesn't work as well IMHO, it looks somewhat awkward, mostly because of her position.
Please don't think that folks here are being negative just because they don't agree with your "image" of how a picture should be. I for one have learned more from the constructive criticism than from the ones who just say "I love it". Makes me look at my own pictures in a different light. If we all saw things exactly the same way, what kind of world would that be
The website URL is probably part of Thierry's signature, and was not left specifically on your individual photo.
I make "my art" exactly the way I see it. I wouldn't change one thing about them. If I start changing "my art" to please everyone else...well then, it wouldn't be my vision anymore. Everyone has a different opinion...but, that is just it...it is their opinion...doesn't mean it is accurate...just their opinion.
I choose to build up others and not tear their work down. Afterall, it is their vision of what their art should be...not mine.
