These are 2 totally different shot with apparently different persons. I actually like both of them. Maybe in the second one the sky could by more saturated.
Dpends on what you want to emphasize I think the first done outside would highlight the groom but obviously not the groomsmen. The second shot would share the attention. I would do both why choose right?
They are just two shots of 'the lads' that I like. I was thinking about putting one on an add. Just wondered which grabbed you the most, not a comparrison at all, just which one you liked :-) In the end I put some other shots in.