Ryder Offline Image Upload: Off
|
p.1 #9 · D2X Eagle Shots from Yesterday | |
Karen80 wrote:
I'm not sure I understand the post processing comment from another member. It strikes me as very weird that someone else will tell you how your photos should look when they weren't even there. Also photography is an art, not a science. So how you, the photographer, want the photo to look is a subjective thing.
Cheers, Karen.
Hi:
I think that's me Karen is talking about. I don't want to tell anybody how their shots should look and I totally agree that it's subjective. John might offer that kind of opinion (not that he did!)but I have no businees in that arena. That is why I said "I'd" and not some catagorical statement like "it should be." Also, anybody who posts here knows I'm a beginner so take what I say with a grain of salt at least.(more if necessary)
On the subjective side, I'm prone to see shots as over sharpened (you will likely tell me that it was not sharpened at all!) and that is what I was talking about in the above post. Where some folks see perfection I often see digital as to edgy or something. It's me and likely my monitor that I am replacing this week (Samsung 214T on its way).
With regard to your comment that "It strikes me as very weird that someone else will tell you how your photos should look when they weren't even there."
Well, that strikes me as silly. If that is true then nobody can make a constructive comment or have anything to say about almost all photographs. This is not the case. Photographs can clearly be judged (although I'm certainly not one to do it for the most part) on a number points,,,exposure, composition, pp, without the person actually "being there." Nothing "weird" about it. To call someone "weird" for just stating an honest opinion is unhelpful IMHO. (hopefully my comment wasn't rude which is a different thing altogether.)
Anyway, I'd be proud of getting that shot as I'm a birder first and a photographer a distant second. The shot itself is great. My comments involve moving a slider slightly one way or another or entering a slightly different number into a dialogue box. Not a big deal. I hope it is taken as intended.
Cheers,
Craig
Edited by Ryder on Dec 30, 2005 at 08:24 AM GMT
|