Lisa_Holloway Offline Upload & Sell: Off
|
p.1 #7 · p.1 #7 · Victoria, using my favorite lighting setup | |
4meNex7 wrote:
All I did was give my opinion on your image. Why is it that you can give comments on other's images, but get upset when yours are critiqued? I gave my honest opinion on your image. In replies to your posts I never questioned or attacked your abilities. I never said you were rude to your comments on an image. Your rudeness came with your refusal to accept a poster not wanting an image edited. Your very hostile response to my critique of your flawed image shows you are unable to take constructive criticism. To say critiquing one of your images on what you claim is a public forum is "stalking" your thread, shows you only see the forum as "public" when the comments are to your liking. You need not worry about my commenting on your images. Your hostility shows you are not the least bit open to criticism.
1. On the calibrated monitor we use for final production, her cheek is the product of a poor attempt to process her skin.
2. The left hand is not a case of DOF. There is a definite case of blur on parts of the hand.
3. The color at the left side of the midriff is very unnatural, like that of a corpse.
4. The lighting on the leg is wrong, for whatever reason
5 . There are over sharpening artifacts at different parts of the image, very noticeable on the wand she is holding.
6. The right hand show motion blur, which can not be passed off as DOF as there are processing artifacts near the hand.
7. The overall color of the image is not pleasing to the eye'
8. And like I said. Whatever I feel about your work, the model is attractive.
9. My critique was intended to help
10. I did get my facts straight.
11. Do.t worry about future comments, you hold the distinction of being the first forum member that I have blocked.
...Show more →
Your critique is all spot on, I totally agree.
|