Upload & Sell: On
Yeah, it's amazing the difference that a moon can make to a shot, both good and bad sometimes. Overall, #1 would be my favorite, the star display outways the foreground light. But you might consider blending in the foreground from #2 into your #1 shot, but only at say 1/2 the brightness it is now...
#1 is my favorite as well as I'm a sucker for a good milky way (Montana has me spoiled). I worked a little to blend the foreground last night but it's tricky. This is because I took the first shot before going to sleep, then packed up my stuff and went to sleep. The second shot was taken upon waking up outside my tent. So the perspectives don't quite line up. Plus my blending skills need work ha. But once finals are done I think I'll go in and see what I can do!