Upload & Sell: On
Thanks for the feedback, illustrated suggestions.
Kent: I like your crop. To me its the negative space shape in the upper right corner that improves.
Bob: And I prefer the balance as you do. But I could combine the balance with a tighter crop at top.
Karen: Maybe a bit less natural, but quite a bit more stunning. I spent some time softening the darkish black band at the left. However your rework obviates some of that need and really adds more depth. Not sure I can emulate what you did so well, but I will see what I can incorporate.
Jo: Thanks for the additional feedback. My take home is that both crops work